Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout051812_Agenda Packet Ernest Kanekoa Jr, Members: Chair Charles Iona Alfredo Nebre Jr. Bradley Chiba Randall Francisco James O'Connor Donald Okami Sr. Vice-Chair COUNTY OF KAUA'I POLICE COMMISSION R I C- k _!C",_ L L) NOTICE OF MEETING AND AGENDA Friday, May 18, 2012 '12 MAY 10 P 4 :27 9:00 am. or shortly thereafter Mo'ikeha Building, Meeting Room 2 A/B 4444 Rice Street, Lihue, HI 96766 r CU J CALL TO ORDER APPROVAL OF MINUTES • Special Meeting Open Session Minutes of April 17, 2012 • Regular Open Session Meeting Minutes of April 27, 2012 COMMENDATION REPORT CHIEF'S MONTHLY REPORTS 1. Administrative, Technical Services & Training Reports/Orders 2. Fiscal Report 3. Investigative Services Bureau 4. Patrol Services Bureau&Traffic Reports 5. Community Oriented Policing Report Traffic Safety Unit 6. Community Oriented Policing District Reports for Lihu'e, Hanalei, and Waimea 7. Chief s Announcements and Pertinent Updates COMMUNICATIONS KPC 2012-17 Communication dated 05/02/12 from Chief Darryl Perry to Chair Ernest Kanekoa Jr., and Commission Members, concurring with the Commission's findings related to complaint KPC 2012-03. KPC 2012-18 Communication dated 05/02/12 from Chief Darryl Perry to Chair Ernest Kanekoa Jr., and Commission Members, concurring with the Commission's findings related to complaint KPC 2012-10. An Equal Opportunity Employer KPC 2012-19 Communication dated 05/02/12 from Chief of Police Darryl Perry to Chair Ernest Kanekoa Jr., and Commission Members, concurring with the Commission's findings related to complaint KPC 2012-11. BUSINESS KPC 2012-02 Discussion on the Police Department's Proposed Budget for FY 2012- 13. (On-going) KPC 2012-20 Public announcements for the following Police Commission notarized complaints that were filed against officers of the County. ES-28: KPC 2012-15 ES-29: KPC 2012-16 ANNOUNCEMENTS Next meeting: June 22, 2012 at 9:00 a.m. at the Mo'ikeha Building in Meeting Room 2A/2B followed by Executive Session. EXECUTIVE SESSION Pursuant to Hawaii Revised Statute §§92-4, 92-5 (a) (4), 92-9 (a) (1-4) and (b), the purpose of this Executive Session is to receive and approve the following Executive Session minutes and to consult with the Commissions legal counsel on issues pertaining to the Commissions and the County's powers, duties, privileges, immunities, and/or liabilities as they may relate to this item, deliberate and take such action as appropriate: ES-31 Executive Session Minutes of April 17, 2012 Executive Session Minutes of April 27, 2012 Pursuant to Hawaii Revised Statutes §§92-4, 92-5 (a)(2) and (4), the purpose of this Executive Session is to consider the evaluation, dismissal or discipline of an employee or officer of the County where consideration of matter affecting privacy will be involved, provided that if the individual concerned requests an open meeting, an open meeting shall be held; and to consult with the Commissions legal counsel on issues pertaining to the Commissions and the County's powers, duties, privileges, immunities, and/or liabilities as they may relate to this item, deliberate and take such action as appropriate: ES-26: KPC 2012-13 Complaint filed on 03/12,112 alleging that officers and their superiors of the County are charged with the suppression and oppression of Native Indigenous Aboriginal Hawaiian Human Rights, which is a violation of International Law. ( ►eferred on 04/27/12) Kaua'i Police Commission- May 18, 2012 21 P a ES-27: KPC 2012-14 Complaint filed on 03/12/12 alleging that officers of the County illegally took the complainant's Hawaiian government license plates and vehicle registration. (Deferred on 04/27/12) ES-32: KPC 2012-17 Complaint filed on 04/19/12 alleging an officer of the County violated the County of Kauai Policy Against Discrimination and Harassment, 2012 Edition. ES-33 Pursuant to the Hawaii Revised Statutes §92-4 and §92-5 (a) (4), the purposes of the Executive Session is for the Commission to consult with its attorney as to the powers, duties, privileges, immunities, and liabilities as they may relate to a Declaratory Action to determine the powers of the Mayor and the powers of the Police Commission. RETURN TO OPEN SESSION Ratify Police Commission's actions taken in Executive Session for items: ES-26, ES-27, ES-31, ES-32, and ES-33 ADJOURNMENT EXECUTIVE SESSION Pursuant to Hawaii Revised Statutes, ("H.R.S.") §92-7 (a), the Commission may, when deemed necessary, hold an Executive Session on any agenda item without the written public notice if the Executive Session was not anticipated in advance. Any such Executive Session shall be held pursuant to H.R.S. §92-4 and shall be limited to those items described in H.R.S. §92-5(a). Discussions held in Executive Session are closed to the public. cc: Deputy County Attorney Jennifer Winn PUBLIC COMMENTS and TESTIMONY Persons wishing to offer comments are encouraged to submit written testimony at least 24-hours prior to the meeting indicating: 1. Your name and if applicable, your position/title and organization you are representing 2. The agenda item that you are providing comments on; and 3. Whether you will be testifying in person or submitting written comment only. 4. If you are unable to submit your testimony at least 24 hours prior to the meeting, please provide 10 copies of your written testimony at the meeting. While every effort will be made to copy, organize and collate all testimony received, materials received on the day of the meeting or improperly identified may be distributed to the members after the meeting is concluded. The length of time allocated to person(s) wishing to present verbal testimony may be limited at the discretion of the chairperson or presiding member. 3 1 P tti Kaua'i Police Commission- May 1 8, 2012 Send written testimony to: Kaua'i Police Commission Attn: Mercedes Omo-Yours Office Boards and Commissions 4444 Rice Street, Suite 150 Lilme, HI 96766 E-Mail: mvounc,-(,,,kauai.,-o Phone: (808) 241-4920 Fax: (808) 241-5127 SPECIAL ASSISTANCE If you need an alternate format or an auxiliary aid to participate, please contact the Boards and Commissions Support Clerk at (808) 241-4920 at least five(5)working days prior to the meeting. 4 P a c Kaua'i Police Commission- May 18, 2012 COUNTY OFKAUAI H Minutes of Meeting SPECIAL MEETING - OPEN SESSION Board/Committee:... KAUAI POLICE COMMISSION Meeting Date April 17, 2012 t.ocation Mo'ikeha Building- Meeting Room 2A/B Start of Meeting: 1:30 P.M. End of Meeting: 2:30 P.M. Present Chair­Erne�stKauckoa J*rVic'e-Chair­James OC­onnor,�Members: Charles Iona, Alfredo Nebre Jr., Bradley Chiba, Randall Francisco, and Donald Okarni Sr. Also Deputy County Attorney Jennifer Winn; Board& Commissions Office Staff, Support Clerk Mercedes Youn; Administrator Paula Morikamil.- Administrative Aide "Teresa Tamura Excused Absent SUBJECT DICSSIN C A CT ION - —Call T o O rder O C h a i r K a n e o a c a f I ed the meeting t oorder at 1:30 m. Business KPC 201')-11 Discussion relating to the salaries of the Chief of Police and Deputy Chief of Police positions Chair Kaneko a turned the meeting over to Mr. Iona to provide the Commission with a recap of what took place at the recent County Council meeting on April 11, 2012. Mr. Iona explained that the County Council received Resolution 2012 -1 from the Salary Commission amending Resolution 2011-1 relating to the salaries ot'certain officers and employees of the County of Kauai. The Resolution proposed that all salary increases for the positions listed in Resolution 2012-1 would take effect on July 1, 2013, Mr, Iona stated that back in 2009 when the Police Commission was under the leadership of then, former Chair Russell Grady, the Police Commission was approached by the Salary Commission to consider a salary freeze for the Chief of Police until such a time when economic and budgetary conditions Kauai Police Commission Special Meeting - Open Session April 17, 2012 Page 2 SUBJECT f DISCUSSION ACTION improve. Ile noted that at that time, the Police Commission voted to freeze the Chief's salary for a period of one year, with the option to revisit the issue after the year was over. However, the Police Commission was not given the opportunity to do so. Mr. Iona mentioned that there were two (2) items on the table,one of which was recommendation by Councilman Mel Rapozo to either accept the Resolution or reject part of the Resolution. Councilman Rapozo felt that the Resolution should be rejected in part due to some confusion regarding the date 07/01/11 which was bracketed and had a line through it and the date 07/01/13 which was underlined. Mr. Iona explained that after clarification from Deputy County Attorney Mona Clark, it was found that the date 07/01111 was in error and that it should not have appeared in the Resolution. After further discussion, the Council voted to reject Resolution 2012-1 in part by a vote of to 3. Mr. Iona then explained that the second motion was to accept the Resolution as a whole which also resulted in 4 to 3 vote and again it did not pass. He noted that without a super majority for both motions it failed to pass. 1-le voiced his concern about the sixty (60) day window which would allow for intervention, however, if'nothing is done, Resolution 2012-1 would become law. Mr. long mentioned that based on the discussion, it was mentioned that although the Kauai Police Chief*is the most senior ol'all the other Chief's within the State, and with the most experience, he is the lowest paid Chief within the State. Kauai Police Commission Special Meeting - Open Session April 17, 2012 Page 3 SUBJECT DISCUSSION ACTION ION With regards to the salary of the Police Chief, Mr. Iona pointed out that an increase of$7,000.00 would bring his salary range from$107,335 to $114,848 which would be parity to the Big Island Police Chief salary range of$121,000 which included a subsidy of$7,000.00 Mr. Iona indicated that Prosecuting Attorney Shaylene Iseri-Carvalho's rationale for raising;the salaries for the Police Chief and their respective deputies is that public safety demands that the County of Kauai recruit and retain the best qualified people for those positions. Mr. Iona indicated that the County Council agreed that there should be raises given to certain department heads, however, they found that the way the Salary Commission structured the Resolution it gave all department heads a salary increase. Mr. Iona mentioned that an argument was made that the Salary Commission can only set the salary cap and it is up to the appointing authority to recommend a salary lower than the salary cap set by the Salary Commission. Mr. Iona noted that based on the County Council's discussions, Council Chair,lay I{urfaro sent a memo to the Salary Commission requesting that they reconvene as soon as possible to consider immediately raising the salaries and lifting the effective date constraints for certain positions. Mr. Iona pointed out that the Police Commission's main concern is the position of the Police Chief because should the present Chief leave, his replacement would probably come from within the department rather than outside, unless there are circumstances far beyond the Commissions control. Mr. Iona provided information regarding annual salaries of police officers and other high ranking officers and expressed his concern whereby salaries of"tle Police C lieland Deputy Police Chief would be surpassed due to the w Kauai Police Commission Special Meeting- Open Session April 17, 2012 Page 4 Sl E3,1F C f DISCUSSION ACTION - _._ annual increases provided in the collective bargaining agreement. Mr. Iona expressed to the Commission to consider that what is being asked is a$7,000.00 salary increase for the Chief of Police which is not much, but it is something better than letting it go until July 1, 2013 when the salary increases become effective. Mr. Okarni asked whether it was necessary to use the Big Island as a measuring gage for the salary when the population is two and a half the size of our Police, Department and that their crime rate is almost the lowest in the State. Mr. Iona indicated that an argument was made by Salary Commissioner Randy Finlay who indicated that the Police Commission should not compare the Chief's salary with the island of Maui. Mr. Iona stated that he explained to Mr. Finlay that the Police Commission only wants what is fair as far as the salaries and that Maui was a good comparison. Mr. Francisco expressed his embarrassment that his seven(7) years with the Chamber of Commerce and his salary is still the same as when he first started. 1--le noted that the private sector is taking the brunt of it and felt that it's a matter of talent and precedence. Mr. Francisco indicated that he supports a salary increase for the Chief and suggested that the Commission make a statement that it recognizes the positron of the Police Chief and its concerns that succession planning in the department would be affected by a low salary. Mr. Iona noted that the Police Commission and Fire Commission are both the appointing authorities and they must complete a performance evaluation, and based on the evaluation results the appointing authority would recommend whether a salary increase should be granted, Mr. Iona felt that for each_year that the Police Commission completed the Chief's performance Kauai Police Commission Special Meeting - Open 'Session April 17, 2012 Page 5 SUBJECT C 1 DISCUSSION _ ACTION evaluation in which he was rated above excellent, he received no salary increase and only a pat on the back. Mr. Iona indicated that another concern that was raised at the County Council meeting was about the salary inversion; where the Department Ilead°s are paid less than the employees that they supervise and about using a different pay scale for those positions that require professional licenses. Mr. Iona humbly asked his fellow Commissioners to consider all that is being; said in support of salary increase for the Chief of Police. Mr. O'Connor questioned what position is the Police Commission taking as feu•as going before the Salary Commission to present testimony. Mr. Iona indicated that the Salary Commission is scheduled to meet on Monday, April 2:3, 2012, at 9:00 a.m. and suggested that Chair Kanekoa and members of the Commission attend the meeting. Mr. Francisco suggested to the Commission that it would be helpful to have prepared bullet points to assist the Chair with the testimony. Chair Kanekoa called for the motion. Mr. Iona moved that Chair Kanekoa and members of the Police Commission provide testimony before the Salary Commission in support of an increase in compensation for the Chief of Police. Mr. Nebre seconded the Mr. Okami agreed about the idea of having the bullet points and cautioned motion. the Commission on not to do a comparison between the Big Island and Kauai because although Kauai has a small population compared to the Big Island, our crime rate has jtrrrr ed over the; last couple of'years. Kauai Police Commission Special Meeting - Open Session April 17, 2012 Page (i SUBJECT L�1SC~IISSIC)N M_ _..._ ._ _. ACTION He suggested that the Commission place its focus on the dangers of the Police C'hief's position. Mr. Iona indicated that in 2007 the County of Kauai hired compensation consultant Dr. Michael M. Nash to engage to perform a study of the excluded managerial compensation plan for the County Department of Personnel Services. Based on the study, the Salary Commission recommended a salary increase which provided a 25% increase for all non- elected positions, but nothing happened. Ms. Winn explained to the Commission that during that time she was with the Prosecutor's Office, She remembers that they got a huge pay increase which was followed each year for four years with a 7% increase, until the Mayor requested that the Salary Commission put a freeze on all salary increases for the administrative officers and certain employees and excluded the Prosecutor's Office, Mr. O'Connor recalled that at one time the Chief of Police asked the Police Commission for support to block the Mayor's proposal of furlough that would affect the Police Department. Fortunately, the Commission's recommendation had an eff Kauai Police Commission Special Meeting - Open Session April 17, 2012 Page 7 SUBJLCl _. _ _ __....... _.:. DISCUSSION _ w_d _._ _,..._._ DISC..L1. ACTION may look at it as $7,000.00 times seven (7). Mr. Francisco noted that the Commission should advocate for this particular position and its uniqueness and that it's really about public safety. Mr. Okaini indicated that if the Police Commission expects to recruit or get People to step up to that position, there must be an increase in compensation for the Chief of Police in order to assist them in recruiting a new Chief. Mr. long noted that First Deputy Prosecuting Attorney Jake Delaplane provided a power point regarding salaries of the rank and file within the Police Department. Mr. Francisco asked when the Chief's next performance evaluation is. Staff informed the Commission that his performance evaluation is due on October 31, 2012. It reflects the time period from October 2011 to October 2012. Mr. Francisco suggested using the Chief's performance evaluation as justification for a salary increase. Ms. Winn cautioned the Commission that the Chief's performance evaluation is a private matter and that any discussion about it is prohibited unless the Chief allows it. Mr. Okami recommended that the Commission base its justification solely on the importance of the position and the importance of increasing the compensation for the Chief of Police's position in order to assist them in recruiting duality candidates in the future. With no further discussion, Chair Kanekoa called for the vote. Motion carried 7:0 Kauai Police Commission Special Meeting - Open Session April. 17, 2012 Page 8 SUBJECT DISCUSSION AG ION Executive At 2:05 p.m. Mr. O'Connor cited the Hawaii Revised Statutes §92-4 and Session §92-5 (a) (4),the purpose of this Executive Session is for the Commission to consult with its attorney as to its powers, duties, privileges, immunities, and liabilities as they relate to the selection of an attorney to represent the Commission in a Declaratory Ruling;to determine the powers of the Mayor and the powers of the Commission pertaining to disciplinary powers. ((hair Kanekoa called for the motion to enter into Executive Session Mr. O'Connor moved to enter into Executive Session. Mr. Iona seconded the motion. Motion carried 7.0 c Annc uncenxents N t mee --ting April-2-7—,-2-0-1-2--at--9:00 a.in. at the Mo`ikeha_.Bu__ilding;, . m_ _ _..... 111 in room 2 AJB. Followed by Executive Session. Return to Open At 2:30 p.m. the meeting reconvenes in Open Session. Session to ratify the actions taken Chair Kanekoa called for the motion to ratify the actions taken by the Police: by the Police Commission. Mr. Iona moved to ratify the actions taken by Commission in the Police Commission in Executive Session. Executive Mr. Nebre seconded the motion. Session. _ Motion carried 7:0 _ Adjournment__m__.p Chair Kanekoa called for the motion to adjourn. Mr. O'Connor moved to adjourn. Mr. Nebre seconded the motion. Meeting adjourned at 2:30 :.m. Motion carried 7:0 Kauai Police Commission Special Meeting - Open Session April 1 , ?()l2 Page 9 Submitted by: Reviewed and Approved by: Mercedes Youn, Staff Support Clerk Ernest Kanekoa Jr., Chair Approved as circulated (add date of meeting approval), Approved as amended. See minutes of-,,,—---—------------meeting. COUNTY OF KAUAI aHR_AIFYTITI�B-41@ A-T BONHAM Minutes of Meeting OPEN SESSION Board/Cornmittee: KAUAI POLICE COMMISSION Meeting Date April 2'7,2012 — I,ocation Mo'ikelia Building- Meeting Room 2A/B Start of Meeting: 9:10 am. End of Meeting: 11:55 a.m. -P—reserit Chair Ernest Kanekoa Jr., Vice-Chair James O'Connor; Members: Charles Iona, Alfredo Nebre Jr., Br,adley Chiba, and Randall Francisco. Also Deputy County Attorney Jennifer Winn; Board& Commissions Office Staff- Support Clerk Mercedes Youn; Administrator Paula Morikarni; Adnimistrative Aide Teresa Tamura Excused Donald Okami Sr. Absent SUBJFC_T DISCUSSION Call To Order ACTION Chair Kan(.�V�-a-called-'the--meeting-to--order--a-t- 9:10 a.m. Chair Kanekoa indicated that Mr. Okami could not attend the meeting due to personal obl' rations. Approval of Regular Open Session Minutes of March 23, 2012 Mr. O'Connor moved to approve the minutes Minutes as circulated, Mr. Nebre seconded the motion, -Motion carried 6:0 Recognition Employees for the Month of April: Officers Makana Rivera and Joseph Report Russell Hiniongala. Officer Damien I,00 read the recognition report. Patrol Officers Fliniongala and Rivera were recognized for their response to a call during a heavy storm that hit Kauai last month. Their actions resulted in saving and preserving human life that otherwise would have been lost without their direct involvement. Chief Perry presented Officer Joseph Russell Himorigala with a Certificate in recognition of outstandinnd exemplary�service to the community on Kauai Police Commissioti Regular Open Session April 27, 2012 Page 2 SUBJf C 1 ._ DISCUSSION ACTION behalf of the citizens of'the County of Kauai. It was noted that Officer Makana Rivera could not attend the meeting because lie worked a double shift and was at home resting. Chef's 111o��thly I. Administrative, Technical Services & Training Reports/Orders and Quarterly{ Fiscal Report Report 1 investigative Services Bureau Patrol Services & Traffic Reports 5. Community Oriented Policing Report Traffic Safety Unit Community Oriented Policing District Reports for L,ihue, Hanalei, and Waimea. 7. Personnel Orders 8. Chief s announcements and Pertinent Updates: • Recent promotions of six (E) Sergeants to the position of lieutenant and ten (1 Q) Officers to the position of Sergeant. • Completion of the Stripes Class—a refresher course for officers that focused on topics such as leadership, corrective action, fiscal matters, contracts, risk management, sexual harassment and workplace violence, • 82nd Recruitment class will begin on May I". • 83'a Recruitment class should begin in December 2012. • Meeting with representatives of the Kauai High School Project Graduation. • Completion of the Shattered Dreams Project that was held the Waimea High School. • Recognition of National Telecommunications Awareness Week, • May 13 — 19 is police Week - A proclamation is planned by the Mayor and the County Council. Kauai Police Commission Regular Open Session April 27, 2012 Page 3 SUBJECT I DISC_USSION he.. Commission requested for information on the planned activities for the ACTION_,n.._ 1 Police meek. Chief Perry acknowledged the Commission's request. 'eanzrnunications KPC 2012-12 Communication dated 03/27/12 from Chief Darryl Perm to Chair Ernest Kanekoa and Commission Members concurring with the Commission's findinus related to complaint KPC X012-04 The Commission acknowledged the receipt of the communitarian. KPC 2012-13 Communication dated 03/17112 from Chief Darryl Perry to _ Chair Ernest Kanekoa and Commission Members concurring with the Commission's findin xs related to complaint KPC 2012-07. The Commission acknowledged the receipt of — -- - - — the communication. usin+ess KPC 2012-02 Discussion on the Police De artment's Proposed Budget for FY 2012-13. C)n-xoin Chief Perry reported that he had met with the Administration to review the Police Department's final budget for FY 2012/13 and awaiting the outcome: Mr. Iona asked whether the clerk's position would be transitioning over to the new Human Resources Department. Chief Perry stated that it is his understanding that the position would be moving over to the new HR Department at the start of the new fiscal year. KPC:' C)12-14 'ptition dated 04/11/12 from Retired Police Officer Paul 13unaezrag on behalf of Petitioners to Chair I rnest Kanckoa urging the eta or anc the Kauai Police Commission to act to have Chief Darryl Perr iSsue all retired olive of'ticers who have retired in xood standin x a Retired Police Officer Photogrhic Identif�n _._ m 6iief Perry re aorted that this matter is being addressed and that the Kauai Police Commission Regular Open Session April 27, 2012 Page 4 DISCUSSION department is currently working on developing a policy that would protect the interest of the Police Department, as well as the County. lie explained that the department felt that certain requirements must be met before the retired officers could receive their identification card. One of the requirements is the retired officers would have to do a psychological evaluation every two years at their own expense. Chief Perry further explained that the policy would be in conjunction with the Hawaii Revised Statutes and incorporated into the department's general orders. Mr. Iona stated that although he supports this law he expressed concern and believes policies must be in place to meet the requirements of the statutes. Mr. Iona gave an example situation. When a retired police officer who has been out of service for a while confronts a situation where he exposes his weapon, the responding officer might not know that he is a retired officer. PC ?tI I -15-A. roval of the Pro os d Amendments to Mule 6-I x I and d of the Kauai Police Commission Rules on Administrative Practice and Procedures. Chair Kanekoa indicated that at the last meeting the Commission held a public hearing to allow testimony on this matter and that no testimony was received. Chair Kanekoa called for the motion to adopt the amendments. Mr. Iona moved to adopt the amendments to Mule 6-1, section (g) (1), and (d) of the Kauai Police Commission Rules on Administrative Practice and Procedures. Mr. O'Connor seconded the motion. Motion carried 6:0 Kauai Police Commission Regular Open Session April 27, 2012 Page 5 DISCUSSION AC TION Public znnouncernents f'or the following Police Commission notarized complaints that were filed a rainst officers of the C punt , ES:07 KPC 2012-07 Complaint filed on 02/07112, against three officers of the County alleging that the complainant was improperly cited for having a Hawaiian Kingdom license plates and driver's license on three separate occasions. Based on the nature of the complaint, the Commission found that the complaint is not within the jurisdiction of the Commission and therefore did not sustain the complaint. The complaint has been forwarded to the Office of the Chief of Police for further review and to investigate if deemed necessary. This officially concludes the Commission's review of complaint KPC 2012-07, ES:15 KI'C 2012-08 Complaint tiled on 02115/12, alleges that an officer of the County violated the complainant's rights by entering the residence without permission. Based on the information received, the Commission found that there was sufficient evidence to sustain the complaint and has forwarded the complaint to the Office of the Chief for further review and investigation. This officially concludes the Commission's review of complaint KPC 2012- 08. ES:16 KPC 2012-10 Complaint filed on 02/27/12, against two officers of the County alleging that the complainant was not given the Miranda Rights, false arrest and removal from the scene, harassment and conflict of interest. Based on the information received, the Commission found that there was insufficient evidence to sustain the complaint and has forwarded the complaint to the Office of the Chief for further review and investigation if deemed _. necessar . Kauai Police Commission Regular Open Session April 22, 2012 Page 6 SUBJECT DISCUSSION __. _ _ __.__ _._ ___ _ ACTION _ This officially concludes the Commission's review of complaint KPC 2012- 10. ES: 7 KPC 012-11. Complaint filed. on 0212 7112, against an officer of the County alleging wrong protocol and harassment. Based on the information received, the Commission found that there was insufficient evidence to sustain the complaint and has forwarded the complaint to the Office of the Chief for further review and investigation if deemed necessary. This officially ,.T..------.,_concludes the Commission's review of complaint KPC 2012-11. en,ts Next meeting— May 18 f, y , . 012 at 9:0() a.m. in the Nio`ikeha E3uilding in Room 2 A/B, followed by Executive Session. Executive Session At 9.47 a m Mr. O'Connor cited the Hawaii Revised Statutes §92-4, §92-5 (a)(4), §92-9 (a) (1-4) and(b), the purpose of this Executive Session is to receive and approve the following Executive Session minutes and to consult with the Commissions legal counsel on issues pertaining to the Commissions and the County's powers, duties, privileges, immunities, and/or liabilities as they may relate to this item, and to deliberate and take such action deemed appropriate. ES-22 f?xecutive Session Minutes of March 23, 2012. ES-23 Pursuant to the Ilawai'i Revised Statutes §92-4 and §92-5 (a) (4), the purpose of this Executive Session is for the Commission to consult with its attorney as to its powers, duties, privileges, immunities, and liabilities as they relate to special counsel selected to represent the Commission in a Declaratory Ruling to determine the powers of the Mayor and the powers of the Police Commission pertaining to disciplinary powers. Eursuant to Hawai'i Revised Statutes §§92-4, 92-5 (a) (2) and (4), the Kauai Police Commission Regular Open Session April 27, 2012 Page 7 SLJBJECT a 'osc of this E�xr,cutive, Session ACTION ICON p S on is to consider the evaluation, dismissal or discipline of an employee or officer of the County where consideration of matter affecting privacy will be involved, provided that if the individual concerned requests an open meeting,an open meeting shall be held; and to consult with the Commissions legal counsel on issues pertaining to the Commissions and the County's powers, duties, privileges, immunities, and/or liabilities as they may relate to this item, deliberate and take such action as appropriate: ES-24 Report from Chief Darryl ferry regarding the Disposition of Police Commission notarized complaints filed by citizens with the Police Commission for the period January I to April 1, 2012. "S-2 5 Report from Chief Darryl Perry regarding an overview of the Police Commission notarized complaints and Kauai Police Department Internal Investigations Overview on the status of investigation for the period January I to April 1, 2012. ES-26: KPC ')012-13 Complaint filed on 013/12112 alleging that officers and their superiors of the County are charged with the suppression and oppression of Native Indigenous Aboriginal I-lawaiian Human Rights, which is a violation of International Law. FS 27: KfIVC 2412-14 Complaint filed on 03/12/12 alleging that officers of the County illegally took the complainant's Ilawaiian government license plates and vehicle registration. Kauai Police Commission Regular Open Session April 27, 2012 Page 8 SUBJECT DISCUSSION ACTION ES-28 JKPC 2012-15 Complaint filed on 03/21/12 alleging that the conduct of an officer of the County was unprofessional during a traffic stop. ES-29:RPC, 2012-16 Complaint filed on 04/05/12 alleging that a 911 Dispatcher refused to send an officer to the location where the complainant needed assistance because the complainant only provided the location and no physical address. U_-N Communication dated 04/05/12 concerning the Department's lack of professionalism and disregard in the handling of a theft case within a reasonable timetrame. Chair Kanekoa called for the motion to enter in Executive Session. At 9:55 a.m. Mr. Iona moved to enter in Executive Session. Mr. Chiba seconded the motion. Motion carried 6:0 After the motion was made, public member Rob Abreu requested time to provide testimony pertaining to Executive Session item ES-23. Chair Kanekoa and the Commission members granted Mr. Abreu the opportunity to give testimony. Mr. Rob Abreu,member of the public, stated that he had a big problem with the Administration trying to take over the County. He expressed his frustration with the Administration for trying to take complete power over the County. He noted that according to the County Charter, the Mayor does not have the fight to discipline the Chief of Police and that he only has rights to suspend or discipline persons who he has direct control over. Mr. Abreu stated that matter needs to be resolved as soon as possible, and felt Kauai Police Commission Regular Open Session April 27, 2012 Page 9 SUBJECT DISCUSSION ACTICIN that the Mayor jumped the gun, when he should have come to the Police ---sornmission-first. Return E2eturn tcm Open The meeting reconvenes at 11:55 a.m. Session to Ratify the actions taken Chair Kanekoa called for the motion to ratify the action taken on Executive Mr. Iona moved to ratify the actions taken in in Executive Session. Executive Session for items ES-22 through Session ES-30. Mr. Nebre seconded the motion. Motion carried 6:0 Adjournment Chair Kanekoa called for the motion to adjourn the meeting. At 11:55 a.m. Mr. Nebre moved to-adjourn. Mr. Iona seconded the motion Motion carried 6:0 Submitted by: Reviewed and Approved by: Mercedes Youn, Staff Support Clerk Ernest Kanekoa Jr., Chair Approved as circulated (add date of meeting approval). Approved as amended. See minutes of meeting. COMMENDATION REPORT May 4, 2012 COMMENDATIONS: There was one letter of commendation and thanks received involving one personnel. This letter will be forwarded to the employee with my personal thanks, sent to the Mayor, and filed in his personnel jacket. DATE EMPLOYEE COMMENDED COMMENDED BY (1 Letter of Commendation) 03128112 Officer Aaron Relacion Jim and Regina Dunagan Wrote to thank Officer Relacion for his assistance with locating a family member and keeping them informed. ADMINISTRATIVE & TECHNICAL BUREAU MAY 201 KPC REPORTS . o MONTHLY TRAINING REPORT April 2012 The f0IWWIA8 tmink*assignments wen sdWuWd/conducted dud#W the month of Aprfl NO. TRAINING ORDER TRAINING DATES TRAINING ASSIGNMENT PERSONNEL HOURS TOTAL 1 12 04/23-24/2012 Remin ton 870 Shoff un Armor's Course-Honolulu 2 16 32 2 12-13 04/3D-05/04/12 L.EIU/ALiA-San Diego CA 2 40 80 3 12-16A 0414-s,12-13,17-18/12 Electronic Control Devise Eased Certifications 20 16 320 4 12-20 4/10/2012 Critical Incident Res onse Exercise 24 8 192 5 12-23 04/9-13/2012 Rolling Surveillance Course-Honolulu 1 40 40 6 12-24 04,/16-19/2012 Dis atcher training on the New Radio System 17 4 68 7 12-28A 0023-26/2012 Supervisory Training Regimen In Preparation and Education of Sergeants(STRIPES) 10 32 320 8 12-28A 4/23/2012 STRIPES training for newly promoted Lieutenants 6 8 48 9 12-31 4/27/2012 Vision Air Field Based Reporting Administrators Training 11 4 44 10 12-32 4/26/2012 Vision Air Records managaement System Administration Training 6 4 24 99 171 1168 TOTAL ASSIGNMENTS: 10 PERSONNEL INSTRUCTO STUDENT KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMENT DATE OF ISSUE EFFECTIVE DATE NO. TRAINING ORDER 0312812012 03/28/2012 12-09 REFERENCE: T.N. 11-119 RECINDS: INDEX AS: Remington 870 Shotgun Armorer's Course The following personnel have been designated to attend the Remington 870 Shotgun Armorer's Course on April 23-24,2012 at the Honolulu Police Department's Training Academy. April 23-24,2012 Sgt. Randolph Chong Tim Ofe. John Mullineaux APPROVED: DARRYL D. PERRY CHIEF OF POLICE KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMENT DATE OF ISSUE EFFECITVE DATE INO, TRAINING ORDER 0212 012 02128/2012 12-13 REFERENCE: RECINDS: INDEX AS: LEIU/LALEIA Training Conference Officers and -- - have been designated to attend the LEITJJALEIA Training Conference from April 30 to May 4, 2012 at Loews Bay San Diego Ca, APPROVED: DARRYL D.PERRY 191 CHIEF OF POLICE KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMETNT DATE OF ISSUE EFFECTIVE DATE NO, TRAINING ORDER 03/08/2012 0310912012 12-16 A REFERENCE RECINDS-: 12-16 INDEX AS: Electronic Control Devise Certification The following personnel have been designated to attend the Electronic Control Devise Certification Training on the below listed dates, from 0745-1630 hrs.. All personnel are to report to the ISIS conference room. The Instructors for this training will be Sergeant Todd Tanaka and Officer David Banquel. Equipment Needed: Duty Belt Dress Code., Class D April 4-5,2012,0745-1630 firs April 17-18,2012,0745-1630 firs. Ofc. Ray Takekawa Ofc. Clyde Caires Ofc. Kaulana Renaud Ofe. Michael Buratti Ofc.Chad Cataluna Ofc. Arthur Caberto Ofc.Anthony Abalos Ofc. Isaiah Sarsona Ofc.Joel Miyashiro Ofc. Mackenzie Metcalfe Ofc. Matthew Kaluahine 0& Troy Sakaguchi Ofc.John Mullineaux April 12-13,2012,0745-1630 firs. Ofc. Vernon Scribner Ofc. Elliott Ke Ofc. Tyrus Contrades Ofc.Nelson Gabriel Ofc. Shelly Rodrigues Ofc.Kennison Nagahisa Ofc. Whitman McCallum APPROVED: DARRYLD.PE RRY CHIEF OF POLICE KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMENT DATE OF ISSUE EFFECTIVE DATE INCI. TRAEUNG ORDER 0312812012 OMW012 12-20 REFERENCE RECINDS: INDEX AS: Critical Incident Response Exercise -PMW The following personnel have been designated to attend the "PNIRF Citadel Pacific 2012" exercise on Pacific Missile Firing Range (PNIRF), April 10, 2012, 2012. Training will be from 1200-2045 hours. Report to the Kekaha Neighborhood Center at 12:00 for training in areas such as a KPD Command Vehicle orientation, light trailer set-up/operations and police radio channel switching to various repeaters. April 10,2012, 1200-2045 lira. LT. ION TAKAMURA LT. MICHAEL GORDON LT. RICHARD ROSA SGT. TODD TANAKA SGT. PAUL APPLEGATE SGT.BERNARD PURISMA SGT. RODERICK GREEN OFC. ALAN SANTELLA DET.BRYSON PONCE OFC. ALLAN ANDRES DET.KAREN KAPUA OFC. CHRIS CALIO OFC. PARIS RENSINTO OFC. ARNOLD CAYABYAB OFC. AARON BANDMANN OFC. BARRY DEBLAKE OFC. CHARLES DUBOCAGE OFC. LEN NITTA OFC. RANDAL NERO OFC. LUKE HAMBERG OFC. HANSON HSU OFC. DARIN IRMATA OFC. JOHN MULLINEALrX OFC. TWCHAEI,N`11 APPROVED: eltl—0 it DARRYL D.PERRY C OF POLICE KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMENT DATE OF ISSUE EFFECTIVE DATE 11*10- TRAINING ORDER 04103/2012 04104/2012 12-23 REFERENCE: RECINDS: INDEX AS: Rolling Surveillance Course Officery has been designated to attend the Rolling Surveillance Course from April 9-13, 2012 at the Honolulu Police Department Training Academy, Waipahu,M. APPROVED: -Poo DARRYL D.PE� CIIIEF OF POLICE KAUAI POLICE DEPARTNWM DATE OF ISSUE EFF 0 CITV'E DATE IN12-24 TRAINING ORDER OVOW2012 04/09/2012 REFERENCE EX AS: Dispatcher Training on the New Radio System The following personnel have been designated to attend the Dispatcher Training on the New Radio System on the below listed dates and times. This training will be held within the Kaua'i Civil Defense Media Room, Apfd J&2012, 0745:16 0 brs., in' or Traiging Kathleen Langtad Donn Taniguchi April 17,2012,0600-I000 hrs.. User Training Christina Chong Tim Alison Kane Kathleen Langtad Agri! 17,2012,1400-1800 brs.,User Training Norma Christian Nellie Bunao Donn Taniguchi Donna Takiguchi Cheryl Rego-Goo April 18.2012. 1000-1400 hrs.,User Training Brigitte Rivera Nancy Tanabe Alyssa,Dato Kristin Long ARM 19.2012.06 1000 bm.ner Training Kathy Ingrain Lavina,Taovao, Deborah Carvalho APPROVED.- J4 r- DARRYL D.PERRY C OF POLICE KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMENT DATE OF ISSUE EFFECTIVE DATE NO TRAVWNG ORDER 0411612012 04/22112 12-28A REFERENCE RECINDS: 12-28 INDEX AS: Supervisory Training Regimen in Preparation and Education of Sergeants(STRIPES)Course The following personnel have been designated to attend the Supervisory Training Regimen in Preparation and Education of Sergeants (STRIPES) Course on the below indicated dates and times. The training will be held at in the Kaua'i Civil Defense, Emergency Operations Center (EOC), Break Out Room. The Kaua'i Police Department will be sponsoring and conducting this training class. Dress Code: Class A April 23,2012,0815-1630 hrs. Lt.Paul Applegate Lt.Robert Gausepohl Lt.Karen Kapua Lt. Trent Shimabukuro Lt. Todd Tanaka April 23-26,2012,0745-1630 hrs. Sgt. Darla Abbatiello Sgt Christopher Calio Sgt. Christian Jenkins Sgt Elliott Ke Sgt. Anthony Morita Sgt. Len Nitta Sgt. Daniel Oliveira Sgt. Jason Overmyer Sgt.Mark Ozaki Sgt. Scott Williamson APPROVED: r DARRYLPERRY CHIEF OF POLICE KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMENT DATE OF ISSUE EFFECTIVE DATE INO. TRAINING ORDER 04120112 04/20/12 REFERENCE RECINDS: INDEX AS: VisionAir Records Management System Administration Training The following personnel have been designated to attend the VisionAir Records Management System Administrators Training on April 26, 2012,0800-1200 to be held in the KPD headquarters lunch room. The Visionair staff will be the instructors for this training. April 26,2012, 0800-1200 hrs. Lt.Paul Applegate Audrey Silva Joni Arakaki Michele Albarado Scott Yamaguchi Susan Oakley A APPROV DARRYL D. PERRY CHIEF IIIEF OF POLICE KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMENT DATE OF ISSUE EFFECTIVE DATE NO. TRAINING ORDER 04120112 04120112 12-31 REFERENCE RECINDS: INDEX AS: Vision,FBR 4.3 System Administration Training The following personnel have been designated to attend the Vision Field Base Reporting(FBR) 4.3 System Administrators Training on April 27 from 0800-1200, to be held in the KPD headquarters lunch room.The Visionair staff will be the instructors for this training. Aprfl 27,2012,0800-1200 hrs. Lt. Randolph Chong Tim Lt. Robert Gausepohl Lt.Paul Applegate Sgt. Kenneth Curnmings Sgt. Roderick Green Sgt. Anthony Morita Sgt. Jason Overmyer Ofc.Jesse Guirao Audrey Silva Joni Arakaki Michele Albarado APPROVED: 7 DARRYL D. PERRY CHIEF OF POLICE Crime Trends March 2012 CALLS FOR SERVICE March 2012 February 2012 %Chang CALLS FOR SERVICE 2,452 2,325 5.46% PART I CRIMES BY DISTRICTS 12W Hanalei Kawaihau Ltj& KqLqq Waimea Current Part 1 209 39 49 74 28 19 February 2012 197 20 52 85 25 15 % CHANGE 95.00% -5,77% -12.94% 12.00% 2&67% PART 11 CRIMES BY DISTRICTS j2W Hanalei Kawaihau Lihue Koloa Waimea Current Part 11 710 59 92 397 90 72 February 2012 864 44 112 582 54 72 % CHANGE 34,09% -17.86% -31,79% 66,67% OM% TRAFFIC OFFENSEIVIOLATIONS CRIMES BY DISTRICTS Total Hanalei Kawaihau Lihue Koloa Waimea Current Traffic Offense/Violation 34 5 6 11 8 4 February 2012 32 0 9 15 5 3 % CHANGE -33,33% -26,67% 60,00% 3333% 413012012 11:47:37AN Page 1 of 2 E"1Projects\RMS\REPORTS\MONTHLY\CRIME TRENDS v6 v2008.rpt Crime Trends March 2012 TRAFFIC ACCIDENTS CRIMES BY DISTRICTS 12W Hanalei Kawaihau Lihue Koloa Waimea Current Traffic Accidents 209 21 57 81 36 14 February 2012 189 25 49 76 29 10 %CHANGE -16.00% 16,33% 6.58% 24,14% 40.00% TRAFFIC ACCIDENTS mgia Minor !2!9 Major—1C Non TC Minor TC Non TC Current Traffic Accidents 209 29 5 91 84 February 2012 189 38 3 98 50 %CHANGE -23.68% 66,67% - 7,14% 68.00% SUMMARY REPORT This Month This Month This Month %Cleared Last Month Last Month Last Month %Cleared Reported Actual Rpt Cleared This Month Reported Actual Rp#Cleared Last Month Part 1 224 209 80 3828% 211 197 62 31,47% Part 11 797 710 467 65,77% 925 864 597 6910% Traffic OffenseNiolation 35 34 33 97.06% 34 32 28 87,50% Traffic Accidents 212 209 159 76.08% 196 189 160 84.66% Miscellaneous Report 1,202 1,103 1,098 99-55% 1096 990 964 9T37% TOTAL: 2,470 2,266 1,837 81.10% 2,462 2,272 1,811 79.71% 4130/2012 11 Page 2 of 2 EI\Projects\RMS\REPORTS\MONTHLYICRIME TRENDS v6 v2008.rpt 2012 Bench _Warrant Tracking All Outstanding Warrants Records Outstanding Month Intake (Active) ,. ,felony_ Mlsdemeanor January 165 531 91 440 February. j 195 _520 81 439 March (_ 218 571 90 _ _ 481 April 175 578 101 i 477 May 1 - - June July - - -- August September October:�. November, -- - - December Year Total 4 753 2200 363 1837 Records Intake shows the total number of Warrants received for each month. Outstanding shows the total number of Active Warrants currently in KP©Records Management System. PERSONNEL STATUS AS OF 04-30-2012 CLOSE OF BUSINESS: AUTHORIZED ACTUAL VACA�T APPOINTED 2 2 0 SWORN 148 122 26 County General Fund 143 122 25 Grant Fund d U 0 CIVILIAN 75 58 17 County General Fund 71 57 14 TemporaLy&Grant Fund 4 1 3 TOTAL 225 182 43 VACANCIES: Position Title Appointed Sworn: 1 Police Captain 1 Detective S Police Sergeant 19 Police Officer Civilian: 1 Account Clerk 1 Police Records Clerk 1 Pol Equip Maintenance Coordinator 1 Public Safety Worker i S Radio Dispatcher I County Fund(3) State Grant Fund[Emergency Medical Services Systems](2) 1 Secretary 1 Clerk[Off Duty] 6 School Crossing Guard[Part-time] Kapaa King Kuumualii Chiefess Kamakahelei(2) Hanalei Kilauea Nate t (9)Police Services officers effective 0510112012 K 'a 1EGi*tU1T111 STATUS,UPCATE Recruitment Status Comments " 1. POLICE SERVICES OFFICER(82nd Referred(on 12/22/10) 57 All 9 candidates have been approved by Department of Recruit Class) Personnel. (Referred List Expires:0 413 012 0 1 2) Not Interested/No response 19 Withdrew/Discontinued 29 Start Date for 82nd PSO Class: May 1,2012. Processing 9 POLICE SERVICES OFFICER(83rd Referred(on 2/24/12) 116 Physical Readiness Standards Test is scheduled for 518112. Recruit Class) (Referred List Expires:0 212 312 0 1 2) Not Interested/No response 0 PHPs were mailed to applicants and intake meetings will take Withdrew/Discontinued 21 place through 519112. Processing 95 Pre-Offer Psych Tests will be administered in May. Clarifications will be done pending Professional Svcs Contract for Psychologist. 3. RADIO DISPATCHER(5 vacancies) Referred(on 9/28/11) 13 Background investigations are being routed for (Referred List Expires:0513112012) reviewldetermination. Not Interested/No response 5 Withdrew/Discontinued S Estimated date for conditional offers is the week of 517112. Processing 3 4. POI CE EQUIPMENT MAINTENANCE Referred(on 9/21/11) 6 Background investigations have commenced and are in- COORDINATOR(1 vacancy) (Referred List Expires:5130112) Not Interested/No response 1 progress. Withdrew/Discontinued Backgrounds should be completed by the end of April.Estimated 3 date for conditional offers is early May. Processing 2 S• POLICE RECORDS UNIT SUPERVISOR Referred(on 3/8/12) 1 A Records Supervisor has been hired effective 3123112 on an 89- Revised: 04/30/12 Page 1 of 2 Recruitment status Comments (1 vacancy) Not Interested/No response p day appointment. (Referred t ist Expires:617112) Withdrew/Discontinued p Processing 1 6- SCHOOL CROSSING GUARD- Position was re-advertised in the Garden Island on 3121112. Kapaa Elementary(1 vacancy) SCHOOL CROSSING GUARD- Position was re-advertised in the Garden island on 3121112 King Kaumualii(1 vacancy) SCHOOL CROSSING GUARD-- Position was re-advertised in the Garden Island an 3121112. Chiefess Kanmakahelei (2 vacancies) 9. SCHOOL CROSSING GUARD- Position was re-advertised in the Garden island on 3121112. Hanalei Elementary(1 vacancy) 1CI. SCHOOL CROSSING GUARD-k Position was re-advertised in the Garden Island on 3121112. Kilauea Elementary(1 vacancy) 11. PUBLIC SAFETY WORKER Position was posted from 03114112 to 03130112. A total of s0 (4 vacancies) applicants have applied. Applications are currently being reviewed by the Department of Personnel. KPD has not requested for the list yet; but will do so immediately following the DPS written test so that the Psych tests con be administered concurrently with the PSO class. 12. RADIO DISPATCHER(anticipated Position was posted from 03114112 to 03130112. A total of 41 vacancies) applicants have applied. Applications are currently being reviewed by the Department of Personnel. Revised. 04./30/12 Page 2 of KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMENT Notes to Budget Summary For the Period March 2012 The Budget Status Report for March 2012 is submitted for your review and perusal. The department's total expenditures plus encumbrances to date is 66`x, below the 75%budget to date. The breakdown of the year-to-date expenditures for the department is Chief's Office 65%, Administrative and Technical Bureau 69%of budget expended, Investigative Service Bureau 51%of budget expended and Patrol Service Bureau 70%of budget expended. Kauai Police Department(KPD)'s Budget Nearing with County Council on April 12, 2012 went very well. KPD's proposed Fiscal Year 2013 Budget request was well received and supported by the County Council. For the duration of the FY2012, KPD will continue with daily operations and meet procurement deadlines of May 9`°'for purchases under$15,000 and June 8`h for purchases under$5000. KAUAI POLICE DEPARTMENT BUDGET SUMMARY ESTIMATE MARCH 2012 EXPENDITURES ENCUMBRANCES BALANCE %of BUDGET AURE& pullrREI IQJLA-IF !QJLAJE 3/1112912 MR Chiefs Office $24,283,364.00 $15,840,218.89 $63,687.55 $8,379,457,56 65% Administrative&Technical Bureau 1,673,486.00 656,071.53 493,460.35 523,95412 69% Investigative Services Bureau 338,66100 135,702.18 35,261.61 167,698.21 50% Patrol Services Bureau 486,148,00 156,58160 184,877,93 144,686.47 70% Police Commission 36,868.00 10,478.05 3421 26,35534 29% TOTAL-GENERALFUND J26,818 528.00 06 799 054.25 7321.65 _$,9 242 152.10 66% Asset Forfeiture Funds $5126800 .0 53,77154 $14775.00 $444 131.46 13% Monthly Recap Investigative Services Bureau Lieutenant Daniel J. Fort K-112 ' APRIL 2012 INVESTIGATIVE SECTION SEXUAL ASSAULT: A 47 year old male subject reported his 2 daughters' ages 7 and 9 were inappropriately touched by an 11 year old boy at a hotel swimming pool in Lihue. (All parties involved were visitors staying at the hotel) Forensic interviews were conducted and the 2 girls disclosed they were touched on their genital areas. The I I year old boy was questioned and completely denied the incident. Case forwarded to the Prosecutor's Office for further review. The mother of a 13 year old girl reported nude videos of her daughter were being spread via cell phone messages. A forensic interview revealed that the 13 year old girl was sexually active and sent the photos herself. Interviews with various subjects resulted in the arrest of 2 adult males ages 19 and 23 who reported having consensual intercourse with the girl. The adult males were additionally charged with Promoting Child Abuse in the I"Degree. DEATH REPORT A 4 month old infant taking a nap was found face down in his crib and unresponsive by his parents. Attempts by the child's parents, grandparents, Fire and Ambulance personnel and E-/`R Staff to resuscitate the child were met with negative results. An autopsy was conducted and the cause of death is"undetermined"although the Doctor related that"positional asphyxiation"could not be ruled out. After a complete and thorough investigation, Detectives concluded there was No foul play involved. FAMILY ABUSE/ASSAULT A 49 year old female reported being assaulted by her husband at their campsite at Russian Fort. The male subject was arrested for Family Abuse. During the course of the investigation it was discovered that the female assaulted her husband with a diving spear ,d causing injury. She was subsequently arrested for Assault 2 PROPERTY CRIMES: A male subject reported observing smoke coming from Christ Memorial Church in Kilauea. Fire and Police units responded and it was classed as an Arson case. The fire appeared to have been intentionally set. Investigation conducted and the reporting party who was acting suspicious and was heavily intoxicated was arrested for Disorderly Conduct and Resisting arrest. Detectives questioned the suspect who admitted to starting the fire. The man was then charged with Arson. A Grand Jury Indictment has already been handed out and the suspect is currently awaiting trial. A 54 year old male subject was observed walking out of Sears with a flat screen television and home theatre system. Although he left the scene,his vehicle was identified and he was found at the Lihue McDonalds. A search warrant of his vehicle resulted in the recovery of the television and theatre system along with other stolen electronic equipment not previously reported. YOUTH SERVICES SECTION: APRIL 2012 SUMMARY: TRAININGS: 1. Sgt. Ozaki attended 32 hours of Stripes Training 2. Officer Lucas Hamberg 8 hours of SST Training(PMRF) 3. Officer Barry Deblake 8 hours of SST Training(PMRF) MEETINGS: 1. Officer Stulpe attended two Shattered Dreams Meetings 2. Officer Stulpe attended two CORE Group Meetings at Waimea HS 3. Sgt. Ozaki attended two meetings with John Martin from Parks and Ree's 4. Sgt. Ozaki attended two meetings with Anti-Drug Coordinator Theresa Koki 5, Sgt. Ozaki attended the Drug Enforcement Committee Meeting 6. Sgt. Ozaki attended 10 K-PAL Program Meetings T One Unit Meeting 8. Sgt. Ozaki and Sgt. Carvalho,attended a Meeting with Lt. Chong Tim and Jessica Fletcher for updates on Juvenile Contacts and Case Management. 9. Officer Barry Deblake attended one East Kauai Coalition Anti-Drug Program Meeting 2 ADDITIONAL CLASSES: • Officer Deblake Cyber Bulling(l Class) Wilcox Elementary IOParents • Officer Deblake Cyber Bulling(I Class) KCC 10 Students MISCELLANEOUS FL7NCTIONS: • SRO Unit attended the Shattered Dreams Mock Crash event at Waimea High School • Officer Mark Stulpe and Sgt. Mark Ozaki attended the Overnight function for the "Living Dead" from the Shattered Dreams Mock Crash event. • Officer Barry Oeblake, Officer Lucas Hamberg and Sgt. Mark Ozaki participated in the Familiarization of Potential KPD Recruits with Agility Coarse training. • Officer Barry Deblake, DARE Graduation at Kapaa Elementary School, 5 classes, 120 Students. • Sgt. Carvalho, Officer Barry Deblake& Officer Lucas Hamberg DARE Graduation at Wilcox Elementary School, 150 Students. • Officer Barry Deblake,DARE Graduation at Kilauea Elementary School, 2 classes, 50 Students. • Officer Barry Deblake, DARE Graduation at Hanalei Elementary School, 2 classes, 50 Students. • Sgt. Mark Ozaki assisted Vice with a warrant. • Sgt. Mark Ozaki assisted Gina Kaulukukui at Kauai High School, Suicide Prevention classes, 6 classes, 150 students. K-PAL: Wrestling Kapaa Youth/Lihue Vet Center 4 Tournaments 100 Juveniles Boxing Lihue&Hanapepe I Tournament 100 Juveniles Kickboxing Lihue&Hanapepe 50 Juveniles Sea Scouts Kapaa Youth Center 25 Juveniles Jujitsu Self Defense Kapaa Youth Center 25 Juveniles Fitness Kapaa Youth Center 25 Juveniles North Shore Basketball 84 Games 300 Juveniles Flag Football Waimea to Anahola 500 Juveniles VICE NARCOTICS SECTION OVA RRANTS SERVED: The Vice Narcotics unit applied for and served I I Search Warrants during the month of April; 6-Vehicles,4-Houses and I parcel. During the service of these Warrants 10 Adult males and 2 Adult females were arrested. Of the 10 men, 2 -were transferred into the custody of the Drug Enforcement Agency to face Federal Charges. DRUG BUYS: Vice officers conducted 24"Controlled Buys" from known suspects during the month of April. Recovered in 21 purchases was Crystal Meth Amphetamine and in the other 3 purchases Vice officers recovered Cocaine. During subsequent months,Officers will apply for Search/Arrest Warrants to Arrest the individual sellers as well as seize drugs, currency and paraphernalia. VICE SPECIAL OPERATIONS: In a joint investigation conducted by KPD Vice officers and Agents from the Drug Enforcement Agency(DEA), I Male and 2 Females were arrested. Recovered at the time of the arrests was approximately 502 grams of Crystal Meth Amphetamine. FORFEITURES: 3 Asset forfeiture cases were filed by the Kauai Police Department's Asset Forfeiture Officer. He requested the forfeiture of$7,296 of illicit monetary gains. A SUBMITTED BY: Lr-barfifel J. Fort R-102 4 INVESTIGATIVE SERVICES BUREAU MONTHLY REPORT FOR APRIL 2Al2 A/Capt Daniel J. For K-1121 - VICE SECTION Self Referred Carry-Over Total Average Cases % Cleared Initiated Cases Cases Assigned Per PFD Cases Arrests Cleared 56 56 11 0 15 56 100% 5 Investigators GENERAL INVESTIGATIONS Self e e r ry v ni verage ° e % Cleared Initiated Cases Cases Assigned Per PFD Cases Arrests Cleared 197 529 726 104 108 19 69 9.50% 7 Detectives SPECIAL FOCUS INVESTIGATIONS Self Referred Carry-Over Total Average Cases % C eared Initiated Cases Cases Assigned Per PFD Cases Arrests Cleared 10 133 143 143 3 2 2 1.30% 1 Detectives OFFICERS IN THE SCHOOL 5elt Reterred Cc2rry- ver I otal Average Cases /o Cleared Initiated Cases Cases Assigned Per PFD Cases Arrests Cleared 103 0 103 34 5 82 99 96% 3 Officers DARE / GREAT Drug Cadiseations DARE Classes 28 Marijuana Plants 2 DARE Students 241 Marijuana Processed 277.4 SRO Activities 35 Cocaine 35.9 Students 8471 Heroin 101 Methamphetamine 5881 Teen Court Amphetamine Pills/Tablets 28 DVIC Ecstacy Abuse/Household Member 15 Hash Oil T RO/Protection Order Cases Vehicles 2 Domestic Related Cases Current $6,486.00 Verbal/ Domestic Arguments lWeapons 3 Total DV Related Cases i Restraining Orders Bureau Actions Served O`5 Infa Char2ing 4 Served Protection Orders Arrest Warrants Dissolved/ N5 Orders Search Warrants 4 Unserved Orders Citations Foreign Orders Person{s}Arrested ra��118 CPS Orders Total Restrainin2 Orders PATROL SERVICES BUREAU QUARTERLY REPORT FOR: JANUARY,FEBRUARY,MARCH 2012 Following are statistics compiled by the Patrol Services Bureau: 2012 2011 CITATIONS 3949 5410 Attached information sheets details the Patrol Activities during the First Quarter of the current calendar. PATROL SERVICES BUREAU REPORT FOR THE Ist QUARTER OF 2012 ACT I"TIES. In addition to the daily Bureau responsibilities during this quarter,Patrol Services were involved in the following personnel movements and activities: PROMOTIONS NEW HIRE TRANSFERS Effective Sunday,March 4, 2012: Officer FROM TO Ofc.D. Mendiola ISB Admin PSB Admin The following transfers are effective Wednesday, March 21, 2012: Officer FROM TO Sergeant Vicki Fonoirnoana Patrol Services Bureau Investigative Services Bureau Sergeant Karen M. Kapua Patrol Services Bureau Investigative Services Bureau ASSIGNMENTS TO/IN PATROL Effective Sunday, February 19,2012: Officer TO FROM OTC Shawn Hanna Hanalei OIC Squad 3 Lihue OTC Squad 3 OTC Damian Loo Lihue OTC Squad 3 Hanalei OTC Squad 3 Effective Sunday,March 4, 2012: Officer FROM TO Ofc. J. Matsuoka PSB,Admin Lihue Squad 2 Ofc. T. Contrades Lihue Squad 2 Lihue Squad 3 Effective Sunday, March 18,2012: Officer FROM TO Ofc. Damien Mendiola P Admin Waimea Squad 2 ASSIGNMENTS TWIN PATROL Effective Sunday, March 18,2012: Officer FROM TO Ofc. Jason Scalzo Waimea Squad 2 Hanalei Squad I MILITARY LEAVE APPOINTMENTS RETIREMENTS RESIGNATIONS Officer Christina A. Soltren will resign from the department at the close of business on March 31, 2012. TERNMNATION OTHER TRAINLNG: JANUARY 2012 11-103 01/13/2012 FBI-LEOKA OFFICER SAFETY AND SURVIVAL PROGRAM LT. RICHARD ROSA 11-105 01/17/2012 TO 01/1912012 THE REID TEC14NIQUE OF INTERROGATION AND INTERVIEW SGT, ROBERT GAUSEPOHL OFC. BRUCE NANCE OFC.ALLAN ANDRES OFC, TROY SAKAGUCHI OFC.JASON OVER.MYER OFC. VERNON SCRIBNER OFC.RAY TAKEKAWA OFC, AARON RELACION OFC, WHITMAN MCCALLUM OFC. MATTHEW KALUAHINE OFC, JESSE CASTRO SGT. RODERICK GREEN OFC. ELLIOTT KE OFC. JASON MATSUOKA 12-01 01106/2012 FA,S.T, TEAM TRAINING ACTING LT. TRENT SHIMABUKURO OFC. JASON MATSUOKA OFC. BRUCE NANCE OFC. SCOTT WILLIAMSON OFC. TYSON RELACION OFC. AARON RELACION OFC. DANIEL MILLOY OFC. JOSEPH HLMONGALA OFC,ARTHUR CABERTO OFC. MAKANA RIVERA 12-02 01/12/2012 SPECIAL SERVICES TEAM/CRISIS NEGOTIATION TEAM TRAINING LT.JON TAKAIMURA SGT. TODD TANAKA SGT,RODERICK GREEN OFC. HANSON HSU OFC. ON BANDMANN OFC. LEN NITTA OFC. ALLAN ANDRES OFC. DALL NERO OFC.MICHAEL NIT OFC. DA RIN IRIMMATA OFC, JOHN MULLINEAUX 12-03 01/11/2012 AND 01/12/2012 SEG'xN"AY INSTRUCTOR TRAINING OFC. CHAD CATALUNA OFC. BRUCE NANCE Can't JANUARY 2012 12-07 01/3012012 TO 02/0102012 PRACTICAL HOMICIDE INVESTIGATION TRAINING SGT. TODD TANAKA A/SGT. LEN NITTA A/SGT. DAMIEN MCCALLUM LT. RICHARD ROSA A/SGT. BRIAN SILVA A/LT. TRENT SHIMABUTKURO A/SGT. ALLAN ANDRES A/LT. SANDY NVAKUMOTO A/SGT. JESSE GUIRAO SGT. RODERICK GREEN OFC. MICHAEL MARSHALL SGT. KENNETH CUMMINGS OFC. ANTHONY MORITA SGT. SCOTT BREDE FEBRUARY 2012 12-10 02117/2012 SPECIAL SERVICES TEAM-MONTHLY TRAINING-FEBRUARY SGT. TODD TANAKA OFC. HANSON HSU OFC. LEN NITTA OFC. ALLAN ANDRES OFC. RANDALL NERO OFC. MICHAEL NII OFC. DARIN IRIMATA OFC. JOHN MULLINEAUX MARCH 2012 12-06 03119/2012 TO 03/23/12 CLANDESTINE LABORATORY PROCESSING OJT OFC. JASON MATSUOKA 12-14 03/12/2012 TO 03/16/2012 BASIC SRO TRAINING OFC. MARK STULPE 12-15 ELECTRONIC CONTROL DEVICE RECERTIFICATION 03/02/12 .A.,'LT, KENNETH CUMMINGS SGT. RODERICK GREEN OFC. DARIN IRE\4ATA 03/05/12 OFC. ALLAN AND OFC, GEORGE LACCONT OFC. JESSE CAS OFC, LEN NITTA OFC. DEREK LORITA OFC. ARNEL PUTRISIMA OFC. BRIAN SILVA C'an't INIARCH 2012 Can't 12-15 ELECTRONIC CONTROL DEVICE RECERTIFICATION 03/09/12 SGT. SCOTT BREDE OFC. AARON BANDMANTN OFC. DAMIAN LOO OFC. CHRISTIAN JENKINS OFC. JAMES KUROWSKI OFC. JOSEPH HfNIONGALA OFC. DAMIEN MCCALLUM 03/16/12 AjLT. SANDY WAKUMOTO OFC, CHITO GARDUQUE OFC. JASON MATSUOKA, OFC. JASON OVERMYER OFC. RITCHAEL CARIAGA 03/19/12 OFC. TYSON RELACION OFC. JONATHAN BONACHITA OFC. COLIN NESBITT 03/29/12 OFC. SCOTT WILLIAMSON OFC.AARON RELACION OFC. MARK STULPE OFC. SHAWN HANNA OFC. RANDALL NERO 12-18 03/2012012 SPECIAL SERVICES TEAM—MONTHLY TRAINING—MARCH SGT. TODD TANAKA OFC. LEN NITTA OFC. ALLAN ANDRES OFC. RANDALL NERO OFC. DARIN IRIMATA OFC.JOHN MULLINEAUX 12-21 03/19/2012 TO 03/21/2012 VISIONFBR 4.3 SYSTEM ADMINISTRATION TRAINING T. ROBERT GAUSEPOHL SGT. KEN=NETH CUMMINGS SGT. RODERICK GREEN OFC. ANTHONY MORITA OFC, JASON OVERiMYER OFC. JESSE GURAO MICHELE ALBARADO 12-22 03/27/2012 TO 03/29/2012 VISIONAIR RECORDS MANAGEMENT SYSTEM ADMINISTRATION TRAINING MICHELE ALBARADO PATROL SERVICES BUREAU MONTHLY ACTIVITY REPORT April 2012 --------------------.------------------------- , i 1 3 1 , i 1 i 1 , A. FELONY 137 1 i B. MISDEMEANOR 282 i 1 C. DUI 11 , E � j 1 _---_---_------_-__--------------_--.---_----- j 1 x � r , CE 1 ( 1 . EBENC WA .RANT N .._.._.._._..._..._._._._.-..._._._._._........._._._.._._.._ Revised 06/01/2011 MONTHLY TRAFFIC REPORT APRIL 2012 TRAFFIC COLLISIONS VIOLATIONS FATAL FATAL INJURY SEAT DISTRICT COUNT T/CS T/CS MOVE PARK misc BELT TOTAL LIHUE 0 0 6 134 8 92 11 245 WAIMEA 0 0 0 54 2 46 17 119 KOLOA 0 0 3 163 28 94 40 325 KAWAIRAU 0 0 3 89 is 105 4 216 HANALEI 0 0 2 46 138 48 0 232 TOTAL 0 0 14 486 194 385 72 1137 TOTAL YEAR 1 1 72 2170 867 1768 281 5086 MONTH P YR 0 0 21 1187 124 912 217 2440 TO DATE P YR 3 3, 841 36061 560 1 3209 4751 78501 Community Oriented Policing Report Traffic Safety Unit TO: DARRYL PERRY, CHIEF OF POLICE VIA: MICHAEL M. CONTRADES, DEPUTY CHIEF 4 ALEJANDRE QUIBILAN, ASSISTANT CHIEF, PSB FROM: JON TAKAMURA, LIEUTENANT,TSU SUBJECT: COMMUNITY ORIENTED POLICING REPORT FOR APRIL 2012 I. ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS Platoon/Sergeant Parking I Misc. Seatbelt Moving OVUM T.S.U. 1 10 6 41 0 TOTALS 1 10 1 6 41 0 SPECIAL OPERATIONS The Traffic Safety Unit conducted Speed enforcement on the Wailua Stretch and in the Lihue Construction area. TSU continued to work on forensic sketches for ongoing investigations. In addition we continue to work on investigating cases of Negligent Homicide. MEETINGS A. 04/11—Attended "Shattered Dreams' Meeting at round building Lihue. B. 04/24-Attended the TRCC meeting on Oahu. Page I of 2 IV. COMMUNITY ACTIVITIES AND INVOLVEMENT A. 04/18-19—Traffic Safety Officers participated in the"Shattered Dreams" event at Waimea High School. Submitted for your review and approval: Jon Takarrt&a K-103 Lieutenant TSU 05-03-2012 0805 hrs Page 2 of 2 Community Oriented Policing Report Lihue District TO: DARRYL PERRY, CHIEF OF POLICE VIA: MICHAEL CONTRADES, DEPUTY CHIEF OF POLICE 41' ALEJANDRE QUIBILAN, ASISSTANT CHIEF, PS13 FROM: SCOTT KAUI,LIEUTENANT, PSB SUBJECT: COMMUNITY ORIENTED POLICING REPORT FOR APRIL 2012 I. ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS Platoon Parking Misc. Seatbelt Moving Speeding OVUII 1 34 109 0 73 8 5 11 35 19 2 16 6 1 111 83 11 0 17 3 0 TOTALS 152 139 1 2 106 17 1 6 Ii. SPECIAL OPERATIONS A. None III. MEETINGS A. None IV. COMMUNITY ACTIVITIES AND INVOLVEMENT A. All Hanalei Platoons (I, II and II) participated in donating to the Food Drive. B. 04/11/2012 Officer and Supervisor from Platoon 2 and one Platoon 1 officer attended Kilauea Senior Citizens meeting held at the Kilauea Neighborhood Center. The officer spoke about Id Theft "Scams" and how to keep their personal information safe. Submitted by: k Sc tt Kau' K-111 Lieutenant Hanalei 05/03/2012 1415 hours Page 1 of 1 Community Oriented Policing Report Lihue District /? TO: DARRYL D. PERRY, CHIEF OF POLICE VIA: MICHAEL M. CONTRADES, DEPUTY CHIEF OF POLICE ALEjANDRE QUIBILAN, ASSISTANT CHIEF, PSB FROM: TODD TANAKA, LIEUTENANT, PSB SUBJECT: COMMUNITY ORIENTED POLICING REPORT FOR APRIL 2012 I. ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS Platoon/Sergeant Parking Misc. Seatbelt Moving OVUII I/ P. RAMSON 3 13 0 11 0 II/ C. JENKINS 12 44 1 41 0 III/J. GUIRAO 3 31 4 43 1 ITOTALS 18 88 5 1 95 1 II. SPECIAL OPERATIONS A. None III . MEETINGS A. None IV. COMMUNITY ACTIVITIES AND INVOLVEMENT A. Officer John MULLINEAUX is an assistant coach with the Kauai High School track and field team. B. Officer Clyde CAT RES is a Hawaii Youth Soccer Association (HYSA) coach, and coaches the U10 and U12 acre groups. C. Officer Randall NERO participated in the Relay for Life on April 28w�'. Officer NERO assisted at the children' s activity booth. D. The following officers participated in the 2012 Troy Barboza Law Enforcement Torch Run: Michael NII Randall NERO Russell HIMON,13ALA Scott WILLIAMSON John MULLINEAUX Hanson HSU Todd TANAKA Jesse GUI RAO Len NITTA Page 1 of 2 V. INDIVIDUAL PERFORMANCE A. Coe officer issued a total of 27 citations . Submitted,f,jr your review and approval: TODI}4tANAR'A K-105 Lieutenant Lihue 5-03-2012 1630 hrs Page 2 of 2 Community Oriented Policing Report Waimea District TO, DARRYL PERRY, CHIEF OF POLICE a 6- VIA: MICHAEL CON7RADES,DEPUTY CH F OF POLICE ALEJA-TN-DRE QUIBILANN ASSISTANT CHIEF, PSB ie4 f-�-4eo- FROM: RICHARD W. ROSA, LIEUTENANT, PSB SUBJECT: COMMUNITY ORIENTED POLICING REPORT FOR-APRIL 2012, 1. ENFORCEMENT EFFORTS Misc. Seatbelt —Moving OVUII 1 3 40 25 78 0 F— If 6 .52 25 83 0 = 111 14 54 8 68 2 TOTALS 23 146 58 229 2 11. SPECIAL OPERATIONS A. 04110-Active Shooter Exercise at PT'v1RF B. 04/21 -Squad I OVUM Check Point C. 04123-Squad I Traffic Enforcement/Cell Phones &Seatbelt D. 04125-Squad I Traffic Enforcement/Cell Phones&Seatbelt E. 04127-Squad 2 Traffic Enforcement/Cell Phones &Seatbelt R 04/28-Squad I Traffic Enforcement/Cell Phones &Seatbelt Ill. MEETINGS A. Met with contractors for the Temporary Waimea Substation throughout the month of April. B. 04124-Office space at the Hanapepd Armory operational. C. 04124-Waimea Theater-Mayors Alcohol Awareness Meeting IV. COMMUNITY ACTIVITIES AND INVOLVEMENT A. 04128-Relay for Life at Hanapzpe Stadium Page 1 of 2 Submitted for your review and approval: /rAd Ri and W. Rosa IZ--11_0 L' utenant Waimea -03-12 1020 Hrs Page 2 of 2 POLICE DEPARTMENT COUNTY OF KAUAI 3990 KAANA STREET. SUITE 200 LAHUE, HAWAII 96766-1268 BERNARD P.CARVA1,140,JR. FFLEPHONE (808)241-1600 DARRYL D.PERIVIV Mayor FAX (808)241-1604 Chief of Police www,kauaipd.org dperrvz'a kAuai.eov GARY K.HEU MICHAEL N1.CONTPLADES Managing Director Deputy Chief mcontradtVa kAUAi.ZO May 2, 2012 MAY 72012 Chairman Ernest Kanekoa, Jr. and Commission Members C i:�.S ION KAUAI POLICE COMMISSION 4444 Rice Street, Suite 150 Lihue, HI 96766 Re: Kauai Police Commission Complaint KPC-2012-03 Dear Chairman Kanekoa and Commission Members: After careful review and consideration of the following Kauai Police Commission complaint, I concur with the Commission's findings that there is insufficient evidence to prove the allegations as stated. KPC-2012-03 Therefore, this complaint shall be closed and no further action will be taken. Should you have any questions or require further information, please do not hesitate to contact me at 241-1600. Sincerely, D. R L 1). PIER C ief of Po,ice cc: Internal Affairs, Kauai Police Department KPC 2012-17 AN EQUAL OPPOR 7TINITY EWPI Of ER POLICE DEPARTMENT COUNTY OF KAUAI 41M • 3990 Kai:NA STREET. SUITE 200 _-:1 LIHUE, HAWAII 967766-1268 BERNARD P.CARVALHO.JR. TELEPHONE (808)241-1600 DARRYL D.PERRY 'Bator F,VX (808)241-1604 Chief of Police www1auaipd.org dperrv'a kauij." GARY K.HEU MICHAEL 11.CONTWADES Managing Director Deputy Chief incontradc" .0 k2uai.pov May 2, 2012 MAY _ 72012 Chairman Ernest Kanekoa, Jr. and Commission Members LPj KAUAI POLICE COMMISSION 4444 Rice Street, Suite 150 Lihue, HI 96766 Re: Kauai Police Commission Complaint KPC-2012-10 Dear Chairman Kanekoa and Commission Members: After careful review and consideration of the following Kauai Police Commission complaint, I concur with the Commission's findings that there is insufficient evidence to prove the allegations as stated. KPC-2012-10 Therefore, this complaint shall be closed and no further action will be taken. Should you have any questions or require further information, please do not hesitate to contact me at 241-1600. Sincerely,, D,� RY D, PER Chl if of Poll cc: 6 KPC 2012-18 4N fQUAL OPPORTCVfY FVP1,0YFR POLICE DEPARTMENT COUNTY OF KAUAI 3990 KA-ANA STREET.SUITE 200 LIHUE. HAWAII 96766-1268 BERNARD P.CARVA1,110.JR. TELEPHONE (808)241-1600 DARRYL D.PERRY Mayor F,,VX (1808)241-1604 Chief or Police w- •w.kauaipd,org tipyrryta kAuai.go GARY K.HEU 811CHAELM.CONTR-ADES Managing Director Deputy Chief mcontrades(a kAuai.Lov May 2, 2012 M AY - 72012 Chairman Ernest Kanckoa, Jr. and Commission Members KAUAI POLICE COMMISSION 4444 Rice Street, Suite 150 Lihue, HI 96766 Re: Kauai Police Commission Complaint KPC-2012-11 Dear Chairman Kanekoa and Commission Members: Amer careful review and consideration of the following Kauai Police Commission complaint, I concur with the Commission's findings that there is insufficient evidence to prove the allegations as stated. KPC-2012-11 Therefore, this complaint shall be closed and no further action will be taken. Should you have any questions or require further information, please do not hesitate to contact me at 241-1600. Sincerely, A D. RR PER Chief of P4ice cc: now Internal Affairs, Kauai Police Department KPC 2012-19 AN EQU4L OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER Ernest Kanckoa Jr. roti > Members: Chairman Charles Iona Alfredo Nebre Jr. James O*Connor Bradley Chiba Vice-Chair Randall Francisco Donald Okami Sr. KAUXI POLICE COMMISSIONCOUNNTY OF KAUAI C/o Office of the Mayor 4444 Rice Street. Suite 150 L-thu'e. HI 96766 May 7, 2012 PUBLIC ANNOUNCEMENT Complaint KPC 2012-15 Complaint filed on 03112112, alleges that an officer of the County conduct was unprofessional during a traffic stop. Based on the information received, the Commission found that there was sufficient evidence to sustain the complaint and has forwarded the complaint to the Office of the Chief for further review and investigation. This officially concludes the Commission's review of complaint KPC 2012-15. Ernest Kanekoa Jr. Chairman, Kaua'i Police Commission KPC 2012-20 Ernest Kanekoa Jr. Members: Chairman Charles Iona Alfredo Nebre Jr. James O'Connor Bradley Chiba Vice-Chair Randall Francisco Donald Okami Sr. KAUAI POLICE COMMISSION COUNTY OF KAUA'l C/0 Office of the Mayor 4444 Rice Street, Suite 150 Llhu'e, HI 96766 May 7, 2012 PUBLIC ANNOUNCEMENT Complaint KPC 2012-16 Complaint filed on 03112112, alleges that a 911 Dispatcher of the County refused to send a patrol car to the location where the complainant was physically abused because the complainant did not provide a physical address. Based on the information received, the Commission found that there was sufficient evidence to sustain the complaint and has forwarded the complaint to the Office of the Chief for further review and investigation. This officially concludes the Commission's revi f complaint KPC 2012-16. Ernest Kanekoa Jr. Chairman, Kauai Police Commission