HomeMy WebLinkAbout2015-3-12OpenSpaceCommissionMinutesPUBLIC ACCESS, OPEN SPACE & NATURAL RESOURCES
PRESERVATION FUND COMMISSION
REGULAR MINUTES
March 12, 2015
The regular meeting of the Public Access, Open Space & Natural Resources Preservation Fund
Commission of the County of Kauai was held at the Lihue Civic Center, Moikeha Building,
Meeting Room 2A /2B. The following Commissioners were present:
Patrick Gegen, Chairperson
Randall Blake
Theodore Blake
Linda Dela Cruz
Dorothea Hayashi
Absent and excused:
Joseph Figaroa, Vice Chair
Shaylyn Kimura
Karen Ono
(1 Vacancy)
The following Staff members were present: Planning Department Staff Nani Sadora and Duke
Nakamatsu; Deputy County Attorney Ian Jung.
CALL TO ORDER
Chair Gegen called the meeting to order at 1:10 p.m. with five commissioners present
constituting a quorum.
APPROVAL OF AGENDA
Ms. Hayashi requested taking new business regarding the presentation by the Kauai
Watershed Council first.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
Ms. Sadora congratulated Chair Gegen for being elected Chairperson and Mr. Figaroa as
Vice Chair.
Page 1 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
RECEIPT OF ITEMS FOR THE RECORD
There were no items for the record.
NEW BUSINESS
Presentation by Kauai Watershed Council, Kona Moku, on Salt Pond.
Rhoda Libre stated that the Kauai Westside Watershed Council was established in 1999
but started serving the County through educational media after the hurricane in 1992. They had
continuity for over a hundred years with over 50 natural cultural gatherers from the perimeter of
Waimea River to Hanapepe, and recently extended to Lawai Kai. She is the coordinator of the
Watershed Council, but she noted the konohiki of the Kona Moku of Salt Pond were present and
she relinquished her time to them.
The Commission received testimony from Wilma Holi. She descends from the Kali
family on her maternal side. She questioned what people are talking about and where they are
looking at Salt Pond. She represents her family to protect their interest in that area.
Chair Gegen stated that the last time Ms. Libre was here they understood there were
ongoing discussions with the County and the Commission said they would take a back seat until
there was some way they could offer their support.
Ms. Sadora added that this agenda item was requested by the Watershed Council.
Initially there were several items on the agenda; one was a buffer for the beach park, and another
was to address the cars driving and parking near Puolu Point. These were community concerns
asking what the Commission could do. The Commission decided to hold off until there was a
presentation by the families of that area. There were things happening and the Commission did
didn't want to delay or stop any progress that might have already been happening. The buffer
was regarding the State lands mauka of the park. They wanted to see what could be done to stop
any kind of run off that comes into the salt pans. Initially the recommendation was to do a park
expansion and buffer zone. With community input they weren't concerned about a park
expansion, they wanted to protect the salt pans. There hasn't been activity from the Commission
since last year, until they could hear more from the immediate families to see if there was
anything more they were requesting from the Commission.
Ms. Holi stated there was a community meeting several years ago at the beach park and
there was discussion about the salt pan area. There are two groups involved with the salt pans.
One has legal standing and the other does not. The more vocal group is the group that does not
have legal standing. Her concern is that the Commission is hearing from the group that has no
standing in that area. Her maternal grandfather was the last konohiki for that area. Since none of
her aunties and uncles are stepping up to the plate, it is her responsibility. They have had
meetings with the Mayor and disclosed their standing. As far as she is concerned, the
Commission should not be talking about it because they have no kuleana there. People need to
do their homework and due diligence. The State did their due diligence and found there are
Page 2 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
private owners. They had to step
back. There
are certain
areas that they
cannot have
jurisdiction.
She wanted to make
it very clear
where they
are all coming
from.
Chair Gegen stated that the Commission has a responsibility when the community asks
them to look at areas that can be for open space, such as mauka of the park. Their responsibility
is to look at it, but understanding there were discussions going on with the Mayor especially
regarding the salt pan area, they had no intention of doing anything that would impact it other
than making sure the area mauka and uphill would not be contributing to additional dirt or
runoff. Ms. Libre informed the Commission that there were ongoing discussions, so the
Commission stood back.
Ms. Holi stated that when it rains the salt pans get all the water from mauka. If it doesn't
rain, there's no water. Mother Nature has a say and they can't make plans for it. They can't
build a reservoir because that would create other problems too to which Chair Gegen stated that
their concern was to make sure there wasn't agricultural activities occurring there that would
loosen more soil and make dirtier run off. The Commission took that same stance as they did
with Kaneiolouma. They are waiting for direction on how they can assist that group to meet
their needs.
Ms. Holi suggested that in the meantime somebody on staff do their due diligence and
find information on title and who really has jurisdiction over the lands. They are the decision
makers and stake holders. As far as she is concerned the Commission is the sideline observer.
Chair Gegen questioned her vision for the area to which Ms. Holi stated she sees a lot of
abuse there and illegal camping. Park rangers are not enforcing the law. There are a lot of dogs.
It would be good to monitor the campers and the people who bring their dogs. She noted that she
cares for a colony of feral cats but someone has been killing the cats so now the mice are coming
in to the park. She counts at least five mice coming from the fields each day. That park has
grown very popular with tourists. When there are mice, it doesn't make a pretty picture. The
County needs to take care of that. She has six cats and they are busy catching mice.
Chair Gegen noted that they will pass the information on to someone who can hopefully
do something about the enforcement and the mice.
Ms. Holi recommended the book "Who Owns the Crown Lands of Hawaii ". Decisions
about that area should be made by the heirs of the crown. There is abuse down there. People
treat it like a dog park and they don't clean up after themselves. There are tweekers in the
bushes, people dump their garbage in the brush, people in their truck lifts climb over the
boulders, and Hawaiians that plant their signs. When the time is right she is going to put up a
gate and lock everyone out so that her family can enjoy their property.
Ms. Libre stated that the Kauai Westside Watershed Council has a task force of ten and
they are very specific cultural gatherers. They have been working with the invasive species
committees, the County, and the State. The area has been inundated and turned into a garbage
scow with all illegal activities, visitors and locals from outside the ahupuaa. The State is slow
and now they are working with the new administration. They found that DOBOR has been
Page 3 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
writing permits to allow commercial operators to come into the area, but they have been chasing
them out because it is a very sacred area and historical fisheries which connect to the shoreline,
the estuary, and the waterfalls. They are working with the Mayor to restore this last area which
extends all the way to Kaumakani and Pakala. Illegal commercial vendors have desecrated Glass
Beach and there is no limu on the reef. The coral reef is dead. William Aila instructed Kauai
DOCARE to remove them and give new policies. She suggested that the Commission work with
the konohiki and the makaainana. They would like to stay in collaboration with the
Commission.
Chair Gegen stated that there is anything the Commission can do to assist they will,
otherwise there isn't any real ambitions to go in and do anything at this point.
Ms. Libre stated that she read something about subdividing in the last literature which
pulled up a big red flag to which Ms. Sadora replied there was never any intention by the
Commission to do anything with regards to subdivision. For the mauka parcel, it was always the
intent that it would remain open space.
Ms. Hayashi asked for clarification that the Commission makes recommendations based
on public input and after that the planning is out of their hands to which Ms. Sadora replied that
outside of the recommendation, the Commission wants to have some kind of plan so that there
can be movement. Any development or plans comes from whoever will be responsible to care
for the area. She noted Black Pot is now being managed by Parks and Recreation.
Chair Gegen noted that prior to his time
at park expansion. In his time, they have gone 1
property to keep as open space or a buffer. The
happening with other discussions and they have
stay in that holding pattern until something else
on the Commission, they were originally looking
rom looking at park expansion to just purchasing
suggestion was to wait and see what was
been in a holding pattern. He imagines they will
comes up.
The Commission received testimony from Belle Kaiwi. She expressed concern regarding
the kuleana properties in the Salt Pond area and she felt there should be some kind of
preservation in that area. There is a fish pond named Kuni Kaiawe across from the Salt Pond
area that belonged to her mother's father. When she was growing up, water used to go in there
and there was a home on Puolu Point where her tutu was born and raised. In 1959 when it
became a State they tore the house down and made a bon fire. There are two kuleana lands. One
where people are swimming with their babies. The other portion is the lighthouse area and the
runway is on it. She wants to preserve this area and she doesn't like seeing vehicles driving on
the sand all that way back digging up all the sand and bringing the red dirt into the sand. She
was baptized in that area. She doesn't mind kids swimming but she doesn't like when they
kapulu the area.
Chair Gegen noted that concern was brought up and unfortunately it's the Department of
Transportation who controls that area.
Page 4 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
Ms. Hayashi questioned the wording on the recommendation: continue discussion on
Salt Pond Beach Park expansion mauka and west and whether a buffer area for protection of
Hanapepe salt pans could be acquired.
Ms. Kaiwi questioned if they want to acquire property to build a buffer to which Ms.
Hayashi replied that a buffer not to build anything, just to leave it open.
Ms. Kaiwi stated that she didn't find a problem with the wording. She told her family
that if they don't want to do anything with the property, maybe they should turn it over to
historic preservation and just close off the area, then nobody can go in an trample all over the
place.
Ms. Libre added that she concurred with Ms. Kaiwi. She met with DOT heads and they
took a walk in the area. She finds them quite indifferent. They cleaned the area and they put
more sand. DOT knows it's not their kuleana but they are unwilling to collaborate with the
konohiki. DOCARE and the police cannot be there all the time. Only the konohiki and
makaainana are there all the time. It would be advantageous to support their efforts and
continue. She spoke with SHPD, but not all the information is given. They are waiting to work
with the Ige administration to minimize the negative impact. Tours, divers, paddle boards, and
wind surfers are starting to go there.
Ms. Hayashi asked Ms. Libre about the language of the agenda item: continue discussion
on Salt Pond Beach Park expansion mauka and west and whether a buffer area for protection of
Hanapepe Salt pans to which Ms. Libre stated it needs to be more comprehensive as to which
parcel they are talking about.
Ms. Holi stated that the Commission needs to do due diligence. She noted those lands do
not belong to the Robinsons either. There are owners of the crown lands. They need to talk to
the owners of the crown. This is not a County matter. Kingdom law and Kingdom property
doesn't belong to lawful government people and it doesn't belong to Atooi. There are heirs to
the crown. She told the Commission not to go looking at property that they don't own and the
State doesn't own.
Chair Gegen stated that the intent from their view point is that the State is saying that
they own the property. The Commission is concerned that if it stays like that, the State could do
something else that they would have no jurisdiction over. If the property were purchased, legal
or illegal, from the State and were put in the hands of the County, the Commission feels it would
be much easier to do the things that people feel would be right. Right now, understanding the
frustration of the government, and working with the Ige group, there is no continuity. If the new
DLNR decides to develop, the County has little control over that. The Commission is looking to
get more local control. He is not going to argue whether it is owned by the County, the State or
crown lands. All he knows is the way it is today, they have little jurisdiction to maintain a buffer
there. He understands the legal claims, but the Commission can only look at property and ensure
that it stays in open space. He did not feel they were at odds by any means and they are not there
to debate the rightful owner.
Page 5 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
Ms. Holi stated that at a meeting she and her sister had with the Mayor, they told the
Mayor that the lawn size at Salt Pond has reached its capacity. There's a parking area outside
the park, and by the salt pans. People have been parking along the shoulder. The bottom line is
the size of the park and the size of the parking has reached its capacity. West of the parking area
are a lot of historical and cultural sites. The State did their due diligence and found there are
private property owners in the ocean front. The Commission needs to do their due diligence to
which Chair Gegen replied their lawyers will do the due diligence and identify that information,
but at this point, they aren't looking at doing anything without direction. If they did do anything
it would just be to enhance the capabilities of the groups who have control there.
Mr. T. Blake asked if Ms. Libre considered starting a makai watch to which Ms. Libre
replied they opted not to do makai watch. She asked the kupuna and they will not go under the
State. They have already been doing self - governing all these years. She found some problems
with the makai watch. There are so many designations in the DLNR and sometimes they don't
talk to each other.
Mr. T. Blake stated that under makai watch they are trained by DOCARE, they collect
information that is recorded, and it is the easiest way to get that information into the State and
they don't get questioned about it because they are doing it by their means. The main thing is to
have the information.
Ms. Libre stated that she is on the Marine and Coastal Zone Management advisory and
there were a few caveats. She is trained for the same biological testing and data gathering and
disseminating the information. She has given makai watch all of the information. It wasn't her
call. For her, personally, it would be easier to work under makai watch, but she cannot do any
decision making, she is just the coordinator. Cultural protocol are the laws of nature that are
already instilled. She stated that the word "acquire" is kind of spooky, but she understands what
Chair Gegen stated about not being able to control it if it is in the State jurisdiction
Ms. Hayashi stated that their only concern is that area they are trying to acquire for open
space. She cannot understand why they cannot communicate on that. If they ignore it, it may be
given to something else to which Ms. Libre stated she has seen that happen many times. She has
also seen the County sell off remnants. That's the caveat that the kupuna are leery of She
suggested a stewardship agreement or lease of 99 years.
Ms. Hayashi noted this is a continuing discussion to which Ms. Libre noted that "acquire"
can mean to purchase or to encumber and manage. She felt it needed to be more succinct to make
them a little more comfortable.
Ms. Hayashi stated that they even had problems with the word "buffer" to which Ms.
Libre replied that the word "buffer" and "conservation zone" and "greenway" and "spillway" are
all within the same thing, but are quite succinct.
Ms. Hayashi stated that she wanted to make sure they were comfortable with that word to
which Ms. Libre replied that until they can find a better word that will be suitable. She believed
that they all have a common goal; the integrity.
Page 6 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
Ms.
Hayashi noted
that
area has always been threatened with
all
kinds of development.
She is also
concerned as a
west
sider because of what could come up
in
that area.
Ms. Libre stated that Syngenta has fired a lot of our people and they want to use that area
to retrain and recertify and give our people new hope. They would like to reforest the area. She
thinks a stewardship agreement would be a good start.
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Update on recommendation to Countv Council for condemnation resolution for a portion
of TMK (4) 2 -6- 003:017 to obtain a pedestrian public beach access easement to Kukuiula Bay
through the former Hoban property and discussion on alternative pedestrian public beach access
options to Kukuiula BaL
Ms. Sadora noted that there was no update since the last meeting and it is still with the
administration.
Ms. Higuchi - Sayegusa noted there was no update from Ian Jung.
Discussion on
request
by
Malama Koloa to consider purchasing a 4.860 -acre archaeological
parcel in Poipu located
at
TMK:
(4) 2 -8- 031 -199.
Mr. T. Blake stated that to his knowledge the Deputy County Attorney and staff was
preparing acquisition documents.
Ms. Sadora questioned if the Commission wants to go forward with this recommendation.
Mr. T. Blake stated that his is involved in Malama Koloa. They had this idea five years
ago when he and Hal Hammond finished the Hapa Trail walk and Mr. Hammond noted this was
the last preserve of the five at Kiahuna. At that time he stated if they get ahold of it, he would be
a 50% financial partner and turn over their research. He asked the County Attorney if he needed
to recuse himself from this project and he was told it wasn't a problem as long as presentation
would be done by Hal Hammond. He questioned if the agenda item being listed as a request
from Malama Pono was a problem since he is the executive director.
Ms. Sadora noted that was the way it was initially presented as an agenda item but it can
be amended. She thinks that prior to the field trip they said they were going to do an acquisition
plan, but the Commission was going to decide how they were going to move on any of the items
during the field trip. She questioned if the Commission wants to move forward with the
acquisition plan.
Mr. R. Blake suggested that Mr. T. Blake may want to recuse himself from the voting.
He suggested that since they only have a minimum quorum today, they may want to defer until
Page 7 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
more members are present.
Ms. Higuchi - Sayegusa noted that they want to avoid the appearance of conflict, so in the
abundance of caution it may be best to defer to which Mr. T. Blake agreed.
Chair Gegen noted that if they ask for an acquisition plan, it would still come to a vote
whether or not they want to make a recommendation.
Mr. T. Blake stated that it would be easiest to recuse himself.
Chair Gegen deferred the agenda item to the next meeting. It is his personal thought that
it is an interesting property and he would hate to see anything happen to it and not be preserved.
Update on vacant commissioner position.
Ms. Sadora noted that due to the traffic situation today, the newly appointed
commissioner was not able to make it from the east side. As for the remaining vacancy, there is
still no replacement.
Mr. T. Blake questioned the name of the new commissioner to which Ms. Sadora replied
Shaylyn Kimura.
Chair Gegen questioned the whether the remaining vacancy is a Council or Mayor
appointee to which Ms. Sadora replied it is the Council at -large position.
Review and discussion on east recommendations and prioritization of the Commission's
work plan/timeline of events and activities including spreadsheet of Commission's task list.
Ms. Sadora noted the spreadsheet has not been updated since January. The only addition
would be for the Evslin parcel with Mr. R. Blake's task of meeting with the Parks Director.
Chair Gegen questioned number 11, the letter to OHA to which Ms. Sadora noted it may
have been regarding Salt Pond.
Chair Gegen questioned the status of the Somers project to which Ms. Sadora noted they
are scheduled before the Planning Commission. Staff Planner Jody Galinato will report back to
the Commission on any updates with the P 1 easement and the Quarry Road. Michael Mitchell
replaced Shannon Smith. She is in discussion with him regarding the construction of the road.
Mr. T. Blake questioned the proposed times for access through the road to which Ms.
Sadora noted it's just the planning stage; anglers would have 24 hour access, but everybody else
would be 6:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m.
Mr. T. Blake stated that the most important part of the 24 hours to Hawaiians is at night.
Page 8 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
He noted that surfing is not recreational, it's cultural. If the tide is coming up at 5:00 p.m. the the
waves are better at 6:00 p.m. He also likes to pick limu. If the tide is low at 6:00 p.m. he is not
going to go there at 3:00 p.m. He felt this process is backwards. They're on third base and now
asking for comments.
Ms. Sadora pointed out the Kilauea Neighborhood Association had stated they would be
willing to negotiate a certain time to go there rather than have no access at all to which Mr. T.
Blake noted that Ms. Kallai never did any cultural practices when she was young. They are
closing it off to people that do cultural practices. It should have been on the table from the start
and automatic. He feels they should have talked to the Open Space Commission first and then
put out their proposals for rules.
Ms. Hayashi questioned if the Commission is allowed to go down that road to which Ms.
Sadora advised that they keep the nine criteria in mind when they decide how to move to which
Mr. R. Blake noted that culture is within the guidelines.
Chair Gegen stated that his concern is that they haven't gotten any responses from the
letters they have sent. If it is coming back to the Planning Commission he was not sure if they
should do something to make sure that before anything additional is done, the requirements to do
P1 are completed to which Ms. Sadora noted there is ongoing dialog between her and the planner
for that project.
Chair Gegen stated that if they are coming back for things, the three things the
Commission is concerned about is the quality of the road, the P 1 access that is supposed to be in
place already, and access to the waterfall to which Ms. Sadora noted they are still on the table.
Chair Gegen suggested to not let them do anything until we get those three things to
which Ms. Sadora stated that because it was referred to the Open Space Commission for review,
they are involved in the process until the outcome is final.
Mr. T. Blake stated that his concern is that the comment period ends on March 27. By
the time they get to do anything, they lost their chance to talk. He questioned if Fish and
Wildlife owns the road to which Ms. Sadora stated that the part that goes to the beach is Fish and
Wildlife.
On the motion by Theodore Blake and seconded by Randall Blake to send a letter to
DLNR stating that the Open Space Commission would like to have the ability to comment
regarding their concerns specifically in regards to cultural practices and access to the area,
the motion carried by unanimous voice vote.
On the motion by Theodore Blake and seconded by Dorothea Hayashi to have the
chair review the correspondence prior to sending, the motion carried by unanimous voice
vote.
Review and discussion on CGB /Evslin properties further identified as Tax Map Key (4)
Page 9 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
1 -3- 005:040, 053, and 054.
Mr. R. Blake stated that at the previous meeting he mentioned the possibility that this
parcel should be acquired for a skate park. He met with the Director of Parks and Recreation,
Lenny Rapozo, on Monday afternoon and discussed the concept of maybe having the State
transfer the adjacent property over to the County also. He took it under advisement and
discussed it with the Mayor. He liked the idea but didn't think it should be a high priority
acquisition for the Commission at this time.
Ms. Hayashi questioned comments from the community to which Mr. T. Blake stated
there is a letter of support from the West Hawaii Homestead Association. It hasn't been
executed yet, but the letter is coming. Basically even if the State doesn't turn over the land, you
have a five acre park for $1 million. He feels that if you can buy beach front property for that
price and get 5 acres, get on it.
Ms. Hayashi stated that her concern is that there was an archaeological survey.
Mr. R. Blake stated that that if the County acquired it, they could go before the Burial
Commission to look at it. They could also restore the fishpond.
Mr. T. Blake stated that they found three iwi in proximity, but not on the parcel. The test
digging didn't find anything. If they do find something, the Burial Council has protocol to
follow. The three that were found were moved to the Hawaiian graveyard.
Ms. Sadora stated that an acquisition plan has been drawn up and is with the Deputy
County Attorney. She can provide it at the next meeting.
Chair Gegen stated that they can look at the acquisition plan and make a decision at the
next meeting.
Review and discussion on access to Lawai Kai beach.
Mr. T. Blake stated that he thinks there needs to be an access. There is access along the
rocks next to the water, but if you go in at low tide and it gets to be high tide, you're not getting
out. There are two land owners. Kukuiula owns all the land from Spouting Horn to the valley.
They already have a sea side path that the Allertons used to use. The problem would be with
NTGB. One way or another, the people go down. The guards used to tell people to use the
rocks, but if people get hurt, they would get into trouble. At his age, he is not able to traverse the
rocks, but he has seen 120 to 150 people at the beach and they all go down the same way. At
some point in time it's a lawsuit waiting to happen. Something has to be done.
Mr. R. Blake noted that more tourists will show up if they make the access too easy.
Ms. Hayashi noted that they have to weigh it.
Page 10 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
Mr. T. Blake stated that tourists show up at Kauai Coffee to get down there. They know
exactly what to do. They read about it in the books.
Ms. Sadora asked the Commission what they want to do. It is still under NTBG's policy.
Mr. T. Blake stated that the access from Kauai Coffee is not really an access, they just
never stop people except during harvesting.
Ms. Sadora stated that she will check the subzone as to what was approved, but that
would be for the west end only. Outside of that, she did not know if there was anything that can
be done about the illegal access that is being used.
Chair Gegen stated that they want to know what the special subzone says and also
NTGB's plan to which Ms. Sadora stated that it sounded like they are trying to deter people from
going there.
Mr.
T. Blake stated that
there
was secondary information
that they were considering a
fence from
the road all the way
to the
rocks to which Ms. Sadora
stated that
may happen.
Mr. T. Blake stated that the rocks are not private property so it would be a matter of
going around the fence. He stated that we have to find a solution that is good to both sides.
Somebody will get hurt.
Ms.
Sadora
noted that even with
a solution, people will continue to
do what is the
easiest.
Even if it is
a legal
access coming from
the west side, people will continue
use the illegal
access.
Ms. Hayashi noted she likes the concept of Hanauma Bay to which Ms. Sadora noted that
part of the special subzone allows for that. You can kayak in and boats can only come in one at a
time. They want to allow access, but they don't want to make it too easy because of what they're
trying to protect along the beaches.
Mr. R. Blake noted that it is not their beach to protect.
Mr. T. Blake stated that Allerton used to own from point to point. The State got the
konohiki rights to the ocean. They tried to deter the boats from coming in because there were
very few coral heads. People would need permits to land kayaks at the beach.
Ms. Hayashi recommended making it a sanctuary.
Ms. Sadora stated that she will provide the access conditions of the special subzone from
the website.
Review and discussion on Kaha Kai Condominium parcel located at TMK: (4) 2 -8-
017:016.
Page 11 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes
Chair Gegen
stated that it
sounded like
Rupert Rowe has
already started some discussions
and his recollection
was that they
may or may
not be in favor of
selling.
Mr. R. Blake requested the assessed value of the property so they have some idea of
future budgetary allowance to which Ms. Sadora replied that Mr. Rowe's intent is to look at
other means of funding as well. He is working with the Hawaii Islands Land Trust and Jennifer
Luck may be used as the spokesperson for getting that started. Mr. Rowe will let the
Commission know when there is further action to be taken.
Mr. T. Blake noted there are other parties interested in purchasing portions of that land
for parking, and maybe the business itself. The restaurant was just purchased but they don't have
parking. The west side is County and the east side is Knudsen.
Ms. Sadora stated that the Commission will move at whatever direction that is received
from the Hui to which Chair Gegen stated that he would love to assist them in any way possible.
NEXT MEETING DATE AND AGENDA TOPICS FOR DISCUSSION
Chair Gegen noted the next meeting date is April 9, 2015.
Ms. Hayashi requested discussion and information on the access to Alexander Dam.
Chair Gegen requested keeping the Evslin property on the agenda, Lawai Kai, Kaha Kai,
the spreadsheet, and Malama Koloa.
ADOURNMENT
Chair Figaroa adjourned the meeting at 3:29 p.m.
Respectfully Submitted by:
Duke Nakamatsu, Commission Support Clerk
O Approved as circulated on
() Approved as amended on
Page 12 of 12
V: \2015 Master Files \Commissions \Open Space\ Minutes\ 201 5- 3- 120penSpaceCommissionMinutes