Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutFebruary23,2017KHPRCAgendaPacketreducedMEETING OF THE KAUA'I COUNTY HISTORIC PRESERVATION REVIEW COMMISSION THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 23, 2017 3:00 p.m. (or soon thereafter) L-1hu'e Civic Center, Moikeha Building Meeting Room 2A/2B 4444 Rice Street, L-1hu'e, Kauai RECEIVED AGENDA A. CALL TO ORDER B. ROLL CALL C. SELECTION OF COMMISSION APPOINTED POSITION D. APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA 617 FEB 17 A 9 '09 THE t10011 a I f 101, Ci R1 i f OF. AUA,"t E. APPROVAL OF THE JANUARY 26, 2017 MEETING MINUTES F. PUBLIC COMMENT - Individuals may orally testify on items on this agenda during the Public Comment Period. Please call the Planning Department prior to the meeting or notify Commission Staff at the meeting site. Testimony shall also be accepted when the agenda item is taken up by the Commission. However if an individual has already testified during this period, additional testimony at the agenda item testimony may be allowed at the discretion of the Chair. Testifiers shall limit their testimony to three (3) minutes, but may be extended longer at the discretion of the Chair. Written testimony is also accepted. An original and twelve (12) copies of written testimony can be hand delivered to the Planning Department or submitted to Commission Staff at the meeting site. G. ANNOUNCEMENTS AND GENERAL BUSINESS MATTERS H. COMMUNICATIONS 1. Letter (2/3/17) to the Planning Department from Lloyd T. Sueda, Principal, Sueda & Associates, Inc. Regarding the Proposed New Roofing Material for the Existing Restaurant Building, Honolulu Ltd., TMK: 3-8-04:14, 4479 Rice Street, Lihue, Kauai.. February 23, 2017 K.H.P.R.C. Meeting Agenda Page 2 I. UNFINISHED BUSINESS 1. Garden Island Service Station (Aloha Petroleum. Ltd.) TMK: 3-6-006:089 3-3178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Kauai Proposed demolition of Gas Station Built in 1930 2. Discussion on the status of the Certified Local Government. J. NEW BUSINESS 1. Historic Lihue Post Office TMK: 3-6-05 :10 4441 Rice Street, Lihue, Kauai Disposal Action. a. Letter (2/2/17) to Jody Lowe, Real Estate Specialist, USPS Facilities Off -ice from Kaaina S. Hull, Deputy Director, County of Kauai Planning Department Opposing the Disposal Action of the Historic Lihue Post Office. b. Letter (2/8/17) to Mr. Lowe from Bernard Carvalho, Jr., Mayor, County of Kauai. 2. All Saints Episcopal Church TMK: 4-5-04:18 4-1065 Kuhio Highway, Kapaa, Kauai Reconstruction and Enlargement of Kauai's Only True Pipe Organ and Corresponding Sub Projects. 3. Ma's Kitchen (Umakoshi Enterprises, LLC) TMK: 3-6-009:016 4277 Halenani Street, Lihue, Kauai Replacement of Front and Rear Doors. K. COMMISSION EDUCATION COMMITTEE L. KAUAI HISTORIC RESOURCE INVENTORY UPDATE COMMITTEE 1. Update on the permitted interaction group (PIG) for updating the Kauai Historic Resource Inventory. February23, 2017 K.H.P.R.C. Meeting Agenda Page 3 M. HISTORIC PRESERVATION PUBLICITY COMMITTEE N. DATE AND AGENDA TOPICS (March 23, 2017) O. ADJOURNMENT EXECUTIVE SESSION: The Commission may go into an executive session on an agenda item for one of the permitted purposes listed in Section 92-5(a) Hawaii Revised Statutes ("H.R.S."), without noticing the executive session on the agenda where the executive session was not anticipated in advance. HRS Section 92-7(a). The executive session may only be held, however, upon an affirmative vote of two-thirds of the members present, which must also be the majority of the members to which the board is entitled. HRS Section 92-4. The reason for holding the executive session shall be publicly announced. Note: Special accommodations and sign Ianguage interpreters are available upon request five (5) days prior to the meeting date, to the County Planning Department, 4444 Rice Street, Suite 473, Lihue, Hawaii 96766. Telephone: 241-4050. KAUA'I COUNTY HISTORIC PRESERVATION REVIEW COMMISSION Lihu'e Civic Center, Mo'ikeha Building, Meeting Room 2Al2B MINUTES A regular meeting of the Kaua'i County Historic Preservation Commission (KHPRC) was held on January 26, 2017 in the Lihu'e Civic Center, Mo'ikeha Building, Meeting Room 2Al2B. The following Commissioners were present: Anne Schneider, Victoria Wichman, Larry Chaffin Jr. (entered in at 3:17 pm), Pat Griffin, Charlotte Hoomanawanui, and Stephen Long. The following Commissioner was absent: Althea Arinaga and Deatri Nakea. The following staff members were present: Planning Department- Myles Hironaka, Kaaina Hull, Shanlee Jimenez; Office of the County Attorney - Deputy County Attorney Jodi Higuchi Sayegusa; Office of Boards and Commissions - Administrator Jay Furfaro. CALL TO ORDER Commissioner Schneider called the meeting to order at 3:02 p.m. ROLL CALL Deputy Planning Director Kaaina Hull: Good afternoon Members of the Commission. The first item of business is roll call. Commissioner Chaffin (not here); Commissioner Griffin (here); Commissioner Hoomanawanui (here); Commissioner Long (present); Commissioner Schneider (here); Commissioner Wichman (here). Madame Chair we have a quorum. 90 DAY EXTENSION — PAT GRIFFIN Mr. Hull: Next agenda item is the 90 day extension for Commissioner Pat Griffin. Ms. Schneider: Do you need a motion? Mr. Hull: A motion is needed. Ms. Schneider: Do we have a motion to extend Pat's? Ms. Wichman: I move that we extend Pat Griffin's term another 90 days. Mr. Long: Second, Ms. Schneider: Any discussions? Ms. Griffin: I have a question. It seems like if a new commissioner can be brought on before that 90 days that would be preferable. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 2 Mr. Furfaro: I would think next at your next commission meeting I would suggest that you put on your agenda, since this nomination selection is made by your group for this position, that you put an agenda item on to open up discussion about a replacement commissioner. And so although I am hearing from Commission Griffin that she would be most kindly to excuse herself from the rest of the 90 days. The fact of the matter is the process won't even be posted for another 30 days. Ms. Schneider: We do have somebody that we... that's we have on the next month's agenda. Mr. Furfaro: It should be agenda accordingly. Thank you. Mr. Long: Madame Chair I have a quick question. Mr. Furfaro have you received any applications or petitions for nomination to the KHPRC from the public? Mr. Furfaro: Yes. We have received one but I understand this same candidate might be somebody that you are nominating as a group next month. So I am waiting to see the outcome of that. Thank you Madame Chair. Ms. Schneider: Any other discussion? Can we vote? All in favor? (unanimous voice vote.) Any opposition? (None) Ms. Higuchi Sayegusa: No opposition. Ms. Schneider: Motion passes. SELECTION OF CHAIRPERSON AND VICE CHAIRPERSON Mr. Hull: Next item on our agenda is selection of the new Chairperson and Vice Chairperson. So in order to move this forward essentially a motion is necessary for the 2017 Chairperson for the Kauai Historic Preservation Review Commission. Mr. Long: I would like to make a motion that we nominate Victoria Wichman as the next Chairperson for the KHPRC. Ms. Griffin: Second. Ms. Higuchi Sayegusa: I'm sorry just to clarify I suggest maybe if we open up nominations and so we can receive nominations and then we can go through it one by one going through there. So first I would think we need, so Chair you would just announce that the nominations are now in order and there is no need to be seconds. Ms. Schneider: We don't need a second for it. So we do have Victoria. Is there any other nominations. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 3 Ms. Higuchi Sayegusa: Ok if none then I would suggest that you receive a motion to close the nominations. Ms. Schneider: Can we have a motion to close the nominations? Ms. Griffin: So moved. I move that we close the nominations. Ms. Higuchi Sayegusa: You do need a second. Ms. Schneider: Anybody want to second? Mr. Long: Second. Ms. Schneider: Do we need discussion now? All in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) Any opposed? Nobody is opposed. Victoria is our new Chairman. Ms. Hi cgu hi Saye ug_sa: I'm sorry now we can move forward on any discussion on voting Victoria as Chair. So it would here this portion. Ms. Schneider: Are there any request for secret ballot vote? If not we will proceed on voting on each nomination. Mr. Hull: So the vote was to close nominations and now the official vote. Ms. Schneider: All in favor. (Unanimous voice vote.) Ms. Higuchi Sa. eregusa: Again, just to clarify we are voting on Victoria Wichman is the chair. Ms. Schneider: No one was in opposition. So it passes. Victoria you are the new Chair. Ms. Victoria Wichman, 21017 Chairperson: Ok good afternoon everyone. So now we need to select our Vice Chair. Do I have a motion... nominations are in order for the selection of Vice Chair. Ms. Griffin: I nominate Deatri Nakea in absentia. Ms. Wichman: Are there any further nominations? So if none can I have a motion to close nominations? Ms. Schneider: I make a motion that we close nominations. Ms. Griffin: Second. Ms. Wichman: Any opposed? (None.) Any opposed? (None.) And the motion carries. And the nominations are now closed. So Deatri Nakea is now our new Vice Chair. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 4 Ms. Higuchi Saye ug_sa: We have to vote on her. Mr. Hull: That was the motion to close. Ms. Wichman: So Deatri Nakea has been nominated as the Vice Chair and is there a request for secret ballot vote? (None.) if not we will proceed with the vote for her nomination. All those in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) Opposed? (None.) Ok Deatri Nakea is now our Vice Chair. I hope she agrees to it when she comes back. APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA Mr. Hull: Madame Chair the next item on the agenda is the approval of the agenda. The Department has 2 recommendations to take two items out of order. One being New Business, K.2. particularly to accommodate the consultant from off island as well as K.3. to accommodate a request from the applicant to move both of the agenda items after item G and before item H. Ms. Wichman: Ok so can may I have a motion to adjust the agenda? Ms. Griffin: I move that we approve the adjusted agenda. Ms. Schneider: I second the motion. Ms. Wichman: Any discussion? (None.) All those in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) All those opposed? (None.) Motion carries. APPROVAL OF THE NOVMEBER 17, 2016 MEETING MINUTES Mr. Hull: And the next agenda item is the approval of the November 17, 2016 meeting Minutes. Ms. Schneider: I make a motion that we approve the minutes as stated. Ms. Wichman: Ok. Do we have a second? Mr. Long: Second. Ms. Wichman: Any discussion? (None.) All those in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) Any opposed? (None.) Ok let the record reflect that Commissioner Chaffin has arrived at 3 :17. PUBLIC COMMENT January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 5 Mr. Hull: And the next agenda item is the Public Comment. So this agenda item is for individuals that would like to testify on any agenda item should they not be wishing to speak on the actual agenda items. Ms. Wichman: Ok would anybody from the public like to testify on any agenda item at this time? Seeing none. Thank you. NEW BUSINESS Re: Mr. Mary S. Rice Beach House Mr. Hull: Ok the next agenda item is K.2. Mrs. Mary S. Rice Beach House, TMK: 3-1-001:003, Kipu Road, Kipu Kai, Kauai. A proposed nomination to the Hawaii Register of Historic Places and the National Register of Historic Places. I believe there is a consultant here for the applicant. Mr. Don Hibbard: Aloha. My name is Don Hibbard and Cecile and Janelle are also here from First Hawaiian Trust, who administer the property for the trust. Excuse me, First Hawaiian Bank not trust. Ms. Higuchi Saegusa: Sorry could you step forward and speak into the mic please. Ms. Cecile Ching: Hi I am Cecile Ching with First Hawaiian Bank and First Hawaiian Bank is the corporate co -trustee for the John T. Waterhouse Trust, Mr. Chaffin.- Who are the other trustees? Ms. Cecile Chun: The individual co -trustees are Gary Wells, Sue Anna Wells, and Sandy Waterhouse. Mr. Hibbard: Ok so I was just going to go through the property with you quickly so you could see, I believe you have in your packet the photographs of the property. So I will sort of go through. The first one on top shows the property from looking down from the entry road. The area that is going to be registered is nominated is all right over here. And it will go out as far as this building right here and include this area all right there. Plus there are several buildings that you cannot see cause they are on the side of the mountain. They are actually structures, mainly the water ones. The second one shows the current buildings and everything on this map is being considered except number 1, which is further out and we don't have a date on it so I am not sure it's even historic. The ones over here are all utilitarian. It's the wells the water and electrical generators that support the homestead. Over here you have the house itself and then a number of other out buildings that were associated with the ranch. There is 3 more modern buildings that are non-contributing. They are number S, the manager's home which was built in the 1970's; and the photoelectric which is all new and put in a few years ago; and the third building... Mr. Chaffin: We have a number of photographs in our packet. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 6 Mr. Hibbard: I will go through those. And number 17 on top is also non-contributing it's new water tanks. Mr. Chaffin: Are you referring to other photographs that are not in our package? Mr. Hibbard: No this should be in your package. Mr. Hull: For clarification is that part of the submittal that was originally submitted? Or the subsequent submittal? Cause we have 2 submittals. Mr. Hibbard: Both it should be in. Mr. Hull: Sorry Don do you have the page on say the original submittal? Ms. Griffin: It's the last colored photo before you get to the drawings. Mr. Hull: Yes so it's the last colored before you get to the actual plot plans. Mr. Chaffin: Ok. Mr. Hibbard: Ok the following photo just shows the house as it looks in relationship to the ocean and to the mountains. This is a closer image of the house. The house itself was built in 1886. This whole front part is an addition to the lanai which is definitely before World War II and I suspect it's either the 20's or the 30's it was added. The main house is the gable roof structure here and then off to this side is going to be the kitchen wing and a guestroom wing. Here is the side view which show that better where you can see the gable is original house. The lanai that was added is off to the right. The house originally was board and batten/tongue and groove. They have subsequently put T-111 over it to reinforce the walls which is not the most sensitive put it preserves the house. The windows have also been changed unfortunately. The next picture in your group shows one of the few pictures we have of the house as it was in the 1890's. They had an Ostridge farm in 1896 so that's the one reason we can date the house, by the Ostridge. And you can see up there on top of the hill the house and the kitchen wing both being there. As I said, the integrity on the outside is not ideal, however, on the interior it is very much there. Here is what was the original front of the house with the front porch. This one side here is where that addition of the old lanai was made in, I suspect, the 20's or 3 0's but is very much all there. The original house. The typical style in the 19 century you will see 3 doors going in. One goes into a hallway, to either side is a bedroom. Here is just another view. You can see the chamfered posts, which is very common building finish at the time. They are still there as well as the walls and the floors are all original as well. So once you step in the house, you are definitely stepping back in time. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 7 Here is the fireplace. This was added by John T. Waterhouse once he acquired the property in the early 50's. He acquired it between '48 and '51. The lanai was there already. This is now over 50 years old as well and historic. Mr. Chaffm: Did he then occupy the house? Mr. Hibbard: Yes. Here is just another view showing the porch relationship to the lanai and again you can see the doorways going in and the original windows are still in place as well. The middle door goes into what they now call the library but originally, I believe, it was just a hallway area which would have been typical at the time. As you can see it is pretty much intact still. Another view looking the other way. You can see all the original wood is still there. This is one of the rear bedrooms. The walls are all still intact. At some point, well beyond/before 1967 probably either in the 50's or the 30's they applied Masonite to the ceiling finish. Here is a view of just another one of the bedrooms. You can see it's a very modest single wall structure which is very much intact. As of typical in 19th century the kitchen was separate from the main living area and that's this wing going out this way. And it to, the dining room has all the original walls, the original floor, and you can still see the 5 panel doors that were used that area still intact. At some point, which I imagine is in the 50's the rear of the dining room had the wood sliding doors put in. Just from the style I am guessing that it is the 50's. The kitchen was remodeled at that time also. It still has its original cabinetry from the 50's as well as the wood counter tops. And then beyond the kitchen there was a series of 3 bedrooms which I believe was used for guests. Board and batten outside. The interiors are all intact in these rooms. They have canec ceilings, Masonite walls. These openings are just screens. Also on the property there is a number of utilitarian structures. After Jack Waterhouse got the property he started to improve it. He brought in water and electricity among other things. There is a reservoir on the property with 2 cisterns which is not being used right now. It's on the hillside when you first go up but it's still there and it still holds water. Mr. Chaffin: What is the source of water? Mr. Hibbard: They have a well and that's the next picture. This is the pump house for the well and the I beam structure behind it was what held up the drill when they drilled the well. They just didn't take it down afterwards. And until you go there, and I didn't stop to think about the difficulty of getting materials there especially before the road. The road was built by Mr. Waterhouse in the postwar period during the early 1950's. So before that it was only trail and the trail wasn't even big enough to accommodate a carriage. So essentially you went in by horseback. Also over on that side of the hill is a generator house. Another very simple corrugated iron structure. The generator is still inside and they have just gone over to photoelectric a couple of year and the generators are still there as backup. Right below the generator is a little house where they store the diesel fuel that runs the generators. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 8 Also on the property there are 3 other houses. One house the caretaker lives in it. It's from the 1970's so that is considered noncontributing cause it's too new. This home was built in the early 50's and still stands on the property and it is very much intact on the interior. It has all the red wood tongue and groove walls. The kitchen is intact. It has mahogany cabinetry and, I am sorry I don't have the picture but you can't really see but it has picture windows on 2 sides with wood louvers underneath for ventilation. You can find in a lot of subdivision houses as well. The other house is also there. They are both all cowboy houses and I think they are used for people living on the property. This one the tax office has 1896 as the date. I don't know if it is really that old but the next picture shows the interior which is all board and batten walls and so I said it could be '96. I am pretty sure it's at the latest 1929 or '30. And also the doors, they still have all the original doors which are 5 panels and actually I have another picture I just took today, there is also some 4 panel doors which I do associate more with the late 19'h century early 20h' century. So the house, I believe, if it's not 1896 it's pretty close. Also on the property at the far end is the big maintenance building. This was built in the 1950's and is all corrugated metal and they used that. The next picture shows the interior of that which is all a steel frame and they use it for equipment and storage. Also on the property are 2 other CMU buildings which date from the 1950's and for ranch use at the time. This building, I am sorry I couldn't find the building of the one across. There is 2 right next to each other and the other one was used originally as a milk barn and the has a tact house inside and they are now used for storage. And so that's essentially all that's encompassing the nomination. It's around 30 acres of land. So it's the house and the ancillary support structures that go with the house. I think it's an important building although it has been compromised in some ways and in many ways it's very much intact. When I was trying to get a count of building on Kauai from the 19th century. I could come up with 10 including this one and that's the next pictures. You have Waioli Mission and the mission houses next to it. You have Stone Church in Waimea. The Gulick -Rowell House in Waimea. Grove Farm here in Lihue. The Queen Emma's House in Lawai, which some people has questioned whether that's the original or not but I will give it as part of the 10. And the Wilcox Residence over in Hanalei, which is the beach cottage from the 1890's. The only other ones I don't have photos of and I have somewhere but I couldn't find them, the Robinson Homestead just before Waimea and I don't even know the Gay Residence which was out that side. I went looking for it the last time I was on Kauai but couldn't find it. So I don't know if that's still standing or if anybody else knows if that's standing any more. But that's the only 19th century buildings. The Russian fort if you want to call it a building but that's the only ones I know of on Kauai. So I think just in itself it's important as a reminder of the last century. The house we are nominating for its associations with the history of recreation. The fact that it was a beach house and its associations with being used as a retreat away from civilization and also for its association with ranching. It was part of the William Hyde Rice Ranch and then essentially when Waterhouse bought it, he broke it off and it became the Kipu Kai Ranch. And so for those reasons we are nominating it. Oh and one last picture which I liked a lot. I found this in one of the, they have little books for guests to sign but it showed the difficulty of getting in. It was called the trip over and they were going up the mountain and back down the mountain by horseback. And January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 9 that was essentially and it had it has a certain mystic about of its own, Kipu Kai, it is a very isolated place. It's a place that is relatively difficult to get too and I think it's part of the story of Kauai's history. Ms. Wichman: Ok thank you Mr. Hubbard, Hibbard sorry. I have a question please for you. You mentioned the 30 acres of land. Now is that to be included in the nomination as well? Mr. Hibbard: That is. Ms. Wichman: It is? Mr. Hibbard: Yes the buildings stand on that land. Ms. Wichman: I also understand eventually after the last Waterhouse passes, this would become part of the State? Mr. Hibbard: Yes that is correct. Do you want to talk about that subject? Ms. Ching: Yes there is a deed of open space easement that has already been executed with the State as the grantee and they will take over upon the termination of the trust. Mr. Hibbard: Which will terminate when the last of the nieces and nephews die. Ms. Ching: Right. Ms. Wichman: Does anybody else have questions? Stephen. Mr. Long: I have a couple of questions and comments. Is the 30 acres that the property sits on, is that the total extent of the lot of record? Mr. Hibbard: Excuse me? Mr. Long: The 30 acre lot that the home sits on, is that the total area of the lot of record? Mr. Hibbard: No. It's all one parcel at this time. So we are just taking a piece of that parcel. Mr. Long: Ok so that 30 acres is being taken out of the larger piece? Mr. Hibbard: Yes. It's a little over eleven hundred acres. Ms. Chin: It's actually, the total is 1,094 acres is the entire parcel. Mr. Long: I do have a comment about the drawings in the application and I see that they are hand drawn and noted not to scale. So at a very minimum it would be nice to have a graphic scale on the drawings. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 10 Mr. Hibbard: For nominations, the floor plans are not required. We put them in as a curtesy so that people can get a sense of the layout of the property. I had this discussion with the Review Board a number of times and to get them to scale, to get measured drawings is going to be way more expensive than the cost of preparing the whole nomination. Mr. Long: Right, I understand and are floor plans and exterior elevations really just a curtesy? They are not required as part of the application? Mr. Hibbard: Correct, Mr. Long: I just have a personal feeling that on such an important structure that dimensioned floor plans and exterior elevations would be informative as a documentary measure and an informative measure. Mr. Hibbard: Right. Nominations they are a form of documentation but if you want documentation then they have another whole program. The Historic American Building Survey Program which goes out and documents structures. They will do measured drawings. There is a number of buildings on Kauai that it has happened to already. But then they usually send out a team of 4 people, usually students, under the direction of an architect and that's a totally different process. But yes I agree it would be a good idea to have the house documented at some point. I think it's onerous to have it attached to a nomination cause essentially the nomination is just do we recognize this as historic or not. Ms. Wichman: Any other questions? Pat. Ms. Griffin: It is indeed one of the few properties that has amongst the structures pre 20a` century. We have run across a few smaller houses in researching the inventory but they are scares indeed. But I am troubled you know when we look at character defining features we start with the walls the windows and the roof, sometimes the doors and you have mentioned it a couple of times. And that's what most people in registered buildings, it's what most people would see is the exterior. So can you talk a little bit more on why you mention the interior is a substantially intact. Mr. Hibbard: Yes. I think it's the interior but for integrity there is seven. You have setting. You have feelings and associations. I find all of these are exceptionally strong and quite often we overlook setting. Here the setting is still pristine which many other places where the building itself is pristine but the setting is now gone. So I think that, that's part of it. The materials are all still there but you cannot see them from the outside. But same with the design. I think there is a lot to be learned from the building that does recall the past and yes ideally I would not want the wall, the T-11 I that has been clad on the building or the standing seam roofs but when I look at the whole building as a whole I can overlook that just on the grounds that it is here. It's been standing here for a t40 years. Is that right? 120 years and just that alone that there is this sense of that time allows me to overlook some of these detriments and I also look at it and say ok its keeping the building the way that it is and these are elements that can be remedied. You can go back and put a corrugated January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 11 room on the building. You can go back and remove the T-I I I cause the walls are all still there. So I feel that it is something, yes it's not ideal but I think that it is something that can be worked with. Ms. Griffin: Did the openings, the window configuration, do you know Don if that changed when they were replaced? Mr. Hibbard: No, not when they were replaced. It was prior to that and originally that front lanai looks like it was, I have one old picture which I didn't take a picture of but I just did today had rectangular openings so at some point they enclosed those and it was the same where you had big on one side and small on the other. So the fenestration as far as the placement of the openings are still all intact. At least from what I could see from the front elevation. The sides? Who knows. But I don't see in the building anywhere like on the interior between the front bedrooms and 2 back bedrooms there was originally doors connecting then and I can very easily see where they were infilled. I don't see any places along the exterior of the wall that there is infilling of windows and so at the most they could've made a new window but they didn't take out any old windows. Ms. Griffin: Thank you. Ms. Wichman: Any other questions? (None.) Any questions from the public? (None.) If there is any testimony from the public you are allowed to come up and speak now. Seeing none may we have a motion. Ms. Schneider: I make a motion that we support the proposed nomination to the Hawaii Register of the Mary S. Rice Beach House. Ms. Wichman: Ok. Second? Ms. Griffin: I second. Ms. Wichman: Any discussion? No discussion. Those in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) Opposed? (None.) Ok motion carries. Thank you. Re: Old Kealia School (Alakai O Kauai Public Charter School) Mr. Hull: Ok the next agenda item is also one of the agenda items that was moved is K.3. Old Kealia School, TMK: 4-7-003-006, Kealia, Kauai, a proposed reconstruction of the former Island School building. And I believe there is a representative on behalf of this application. Ms. Wichman: Ok would the representative for the Old Kealia School please step up. Thank you. Ms. Kristen Hoshino: Hi I am Krisen Hoshino. I am president of Hookala non-profit for Alakai O Kauai Public Charter School. It's a kindergarten through 81h grade school but we are going to start up smaller and build up our enrollment. We need a temporary site and after a lot of research we found the old Island School has an entitlement and it would enable to get our school started in time January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 12 for the next school year which we really need to start then. If we don't start next year we lose a lot of our base of support. If we don't follow the following year then we lose our Charter and we don't ever open the school. So it is very important that we get the school open on time. There is 165 families that have pledged that they want to enroll their children there. It's a tuition free school. It is funded by the State and we also, through the non-profit, are pursuing grants which are also from the State. So ultimately the school is going to be paid for by the State and through our lease payments and things like that we would like to keep our cost down. We found this building and the owner's representative has been working with us. They have a contractor and an architect and so there is already a design for this building and we just came along at the right time and they said well we actually don't need to use the building for the next 3 to 5 years which is the amount of time that you need the building but we could go ahead and renovate it now then you can use and we can have it restored and not a crumbling building on the side of the road anymore and increase the property values and give the place for the kids to have their school. After an extensive search we have found nothing else. So we are really hoping for this. It looks like it was built in 1919 and was part of the sugar plantation. It sat empty since 1991 and it's falling apart completely. So I have pictures from the site. These are pictures taken in the past month. Pictures outside you can see there is holes in walls, holes in the roof It look like the sub floor was pretty decent. The inside of the school was a lot of dry rot and just not really salvageable to anybody's opinion that has seen it. So we would really like to do whatever we can most efficiently and that is keeping with the historical standards for a building of this type. The need is there for the children to have a school as quickly as possible. We would just like to find out the best route to that. The building design by John Underwood is like Kapaa Town. The facade, the elevations are similar to that. It wasn't design to replicate the old Island School but we are open to going back to that design if it's felt that it is needed. Some of the changes were made because of the cost. The roof, the shed roof would be cheaper for the Charter School to be able to afford and the deck was added for extra space. We will have a lot of kids and having some extra room to run around would be great but I am not sure if that's going to be permitted with the Planning Department. We have to stay in the same footprint. That is kind of outside of that. So that might be in addition later on if we have to go through the permitting process. So we are not trying to build a modern building but we are trying to build something quickly for these families in Kapaa who need this school. Ms. Wichman: Are there any questions from the commissioners? Ms. Schneider: So the building that you are showing that is in the rendering is not actually the building that you are going to build? Ms. Hoshino: Well we have some flexibility at this point. This is just conceptual and then our architect, John Underwood, is here listening in to the recommendations. It's what we have right now but we could go back to the old design. It might take a little longer to build with that type of roof and it might cost more. But you know there is lots of different design elements that we could keep or not keep and we are here to kind of find out what we need to do. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 13 Ms. Wichman: Stephen. Mr. Long: So what's the purpose of you coming before our commission? Mr. Hull: So to give a little background. So kind of in a nutshell what this charter school is looking for is they have a fairly narrow window to get open school to facilitate children under the application that was approved by the Charter Commission. So they started knocking on the Planning Department doors to see what the process is to entitle a schools site for which any new school site requires, in any zoning district, a review by the Planning Commission a Use Permit so to speak. Which is from application acceptance is a 5 to 12 month process which basically did not meet their window of opening a school to children. So The next option they essentially began entertaining was looking at places that already had the entitlement, ie the permit to operate a school on the grounds that school operations are no longer occurring but had the land use entitlement. So they had been looking at a few sites and this is one of the sites that popped up essentially as having the entitlement for the school, ie Use Permit for a school operation and they could utilize that existing use permit to run their charter school. They would have to operate within the parameters that, that use permit was given but they could utilize it essentially. Now this is a historical structure. It's not on the registry but it's an historical structure. So because of that they are here essentially before the KHPRC for the review of the application. Ms. Schneider: But they have to stick to that footprint? The existing building's footprint? Mr. Hull: For the land use entitlement, correct. Ms. Griffin: So has there been a demolition application? Mr. Hull: At this point there hasn't been a demolition application. I think what the applicant is essentially saying is that when they knocked on this landowner's door they had design already in place for a future tenant to one day build there. This essentially is the design and as I understand it, correct me if I am wrong, is that the kind of agreement is they have monies to build and they could potentially build the structure and utilize it for 3 to 5 years for the charter school and they have plans to later on relocate to a much more larger ground to accommodate larger capacity. But that's an original plan from a tenant that in the future is looking at building. So they are proposing saying can we construct this building on this site essentially in our discussions with the applicant and their contractor/architect the structure costs more to essentially salvage and renovate it then it is to demolish it and put up a new structure. So essentially that is what they are here for your review of. Correct me if I made any... Ms. Hoshino: No that was is. That was great. Thank you. Ms. Griffin: Yea and I have to say I was a little confused when I was reading this because our job is with the historic structure and like any group words mean things a little differently in preservation circles than they do elsewhere. So when it was talking about reconstructing, I brought the Secretary of Interior Standards and reconstruction it talks about depicting by means of new January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 14 construction. The form, features, and detailing of a non -surviving site, landscape, building for the purpose of replicating its appearance at a specific period of time and its historic location. So this proposed looks really attractive and I can imagine hearing the little feet running across that lanai. But it doesn't really fulfill that term of reconstruction with would then simply take us to demolition. But I understand now the pinch you are in, in needing to have the same footprint and that seems to is a little beyond our scope. Mr. Hull: Well essentially you are correct, Commissioner Griffin, that the building that they are proposing to construct at least on these preliminary doesn't replicate and doesn't reconstruct under the Department of Interior Standards of a historic structure. Whether you want to comment, whether this body wants to comment on the proposed new structure or not comment is essentially, it's at your will if you will. Ms. Griffin: Personally, I think if we were to comment about the new structure we would be guided by personal taste rather than historic standards. So I don't feel comfortable. I don't know how the rest of the commissioners feel about that but it doesn't seem to be within our kuleana to discuss a new design and a new structure. Mr. Long: Except that's what I would like to do. I understand from looking at the photos and the description that the existing buildings is beyond use and demolition is appropriate. Attractiveness is a personal thing and I don't feel, like Pat feels that we can't really comment on personal attractiveness. I will make this comment, it's that the proposed new building as presented to us has virtually nothing to do with this scale, the design, or the architectural detailing of the existing historic structure. So just as a personal comment you know it's sort of nice to pick up on those local, historical, architectural aspects of what was there before. Ms. Schneider: Is the reason for using this design because they had it and it was available? Ms. Hoshino: Pretty much. We've already opened enrollment application period and we can't change our timeline and also you know we are not going to be there forever. So I don't know if we are the ones to decide what's going to sit on that land forever. We are open to building the way it was but if there is not a need to do that, you know something that would be a little more functional. I don't know cheaper rent for us too but mainly the speed in which it can be constructed is my concern with the roof and drawings. Ms. Wichman: Is there any more discussion from the commissioners? Ms. Sandra McCloskey: My name is Sandra McCloskey. I represent the contractor and I also represent the future tenant of the property. That is how JM Pacific Construction got involved with this project is that we are cacao farmers also and this is part of the whole Kealia project. Having a place to grow our cacao as a leasehold and then going in to this building as a future tenant we thought we had 3 years down the road and the owner really wasn't familiar if it was going to have to go through all of the different protocols that it has to go through with it being historical or not. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 15 So what we did as part of our business plan we submitted this drawing that we had in front of you with all the decks and you know we were making it really nice and enticing for the owner when we got approached about the charter school, the charter school superseded what we really wanted for ourselves and the future we realize that Kauai, we got to put more time and energy into our keiki and we are willing to build a school in the very short amount of time. So time is of the essence and we are willing to take away, our architect is here today to support this project, basically all we would have to do is take away those decks and exchange that roofline back into the gable roof that it is. You know that it is right now with just the way the structure is right now. We are will to do that. The architect is going to push up trying to help us so that we can get the school built anyway possible. It needs a stamp of approval somewhere down the line because it's supposedly an historical building. We met with Anna today at the site and even though you can see how badly dilapidated the building is. It's terrible, you know we will save whatever we just need instructions. Save the foundations. Save whatever it takes and then build the structure but time is of the essence and we need just need to know what do you want us to do there because we are willing to do it and sacrifice the design that we had done already by our architect. So get away from what you are seeing in the picture. That it was a hope and desire to take over a building 5 years down the road but it is not necessarily what has to be right now. We need to know what you want from us and that is the only thing that we are trying to do is accomplish right at this moment is to try to get a charter school there. And so anything that you can do to help us to that would be awesome. Ms. Wichman: Any comments from the commissioners? Mr. Chaffin: It seems to me that you are asking us to approve something and if the building inspector during construction says no you come back and say this is what the commission approved. You are caught in a difficult place. Ms. McCloskey: Well we have to conform. I am sure that there are certain things like ADA access. It's not on the old school. It has to be on the new one. It's single wall construction. It's not on the old school but it has to be on the new one. We are willing to make the building conform granted we have a great source to do this but we don't know how long that option is going to be out there for us. We will conform. There is no doubt about it. It's just getting past this process so we can do what we always do in construction is to build a nice building that Kauai will be proud of. Our children will have a school. And you know Mayor is wanting to cut the ribbon on it so we would really like to have, at least the opportunity and not just shut it down right here. If there is something that needs to be approved I can't stress to you enough this is just a small window of opportunity that we are able to do this. Ms. Higuchi Sayegusa: So one of the duties of this commission is to provide assistance and advice to the respective government agencies that may have to oversee any other part of this project and the applicant does seem to be coming here under own accord to get your input and your advice on any of your experience and expertise in the area of historic preservation and so I think if there is any input that you guys could afford them then that might be what's relevant. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 16 Ms. Schneider: Is it easier for us to recommend something if it was reflective of the old building. It's not. We are asked to look at a new building that really isn't old and really isn't our purview. Mr. Hull: I think what Jodi is getting at is essentially that along the lines of what Commission Long was saying if there are certain historical elements you want to comment that should be incorporated into the building. Or if there is an outright opposition against the building or if there is outright support against the building and also to Commissioner Griffin's point if it there is no comment there is also to that effect there would be just a motion to receive essentially. We have received this report and essentially have no comment. You folks have an array of different opportunities. It is ultimately what the will of the commission as a body is. Ms. Griffin: It sounds. I mean we are advisory and certainly the regulations within the Planning Department trump any advice of ours and it sounds to me that the school, to keep that entitlement, there is a fairly rigid requirement that is beyond us in terms of the footprint and the reconstruction rather than a redesign. I think the issue for us isn't the school. It sounds like you all are great partnership together and all. I am grappling with what the Planning Department regulations are and what kind of input that is left for us. Mr. Hull: So ultimately the Planning Department would sign off on amendment to their Class IV Zoning Permit and Use Permit. If in so far as they presented it and it keeps within the original proposal. There wasn't, in reviewing their original Class IV and Use Permit, there wasn't any design standards imposed by the Planning Commission so there is latitude for them to have a different design for that. However, in administering the zoning permit the Department would look at input that this body gives as to whether or not it would be a requirement to sign off on their building permit. And so like all zoning permits that you folks are advisory to the Planning Department, the Department takes your input and determines if it is going to incorporate it as a whole, all of the recommendations, in part, or not at all into our conditions of approval as we sign off on their permit. So whatever comes out of this body, if anything does, the Department intakes that and determines what extent it we'll enforce it, essentially. And for clarity that goes for the over the counter zoning permits when is a new Class IV Zoning/Use Permit your recommendations go to the Planning Commission and they go through the same calculus of do we incorporate the KHPRC recommendations as a whole, in part, or not at all essentially. Ms. Wichman: Anne? Ms. Schneider: I make a motion that we just receive for informational purposes only. Ms. Wichman: Ok a motion has been made. Is there a second? Ms. Griffin: Second. Ms. Wichman: Any discussion? Ok, hearing no discussion we shall vote. How many are in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) Any opposed? None. So this passes. Thank you. Thank you very much. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 17 ANNOUNCEMENTS AND GENERAL BUSINESS MATTERS Mr. Hull: The next agenda item is announcements and general business. The Commission is in receipt of, excuse me where did it go? So for clarification items K.2. and K.3. were adjusted to be handled before announcements in the adjustments to the agenda. So now we continue on the agenda as established. So the next one is agenda item H, which is announcements and general business matters. The Department submitted an addendum memorandum that you folks should in front of you which has an email from Communications Officer Mary Daubert for the County of Kauai that gives notice of the US Postal Service to end service at the Lihue Post Office which is a structure on the State and National Registry. The proposal appears as not to demolish the structure but just to end service there and they are taking public comment until February 8a'. So this announcement here is essentially for the dissemination to the commissioners because the comment or the publication was only made aware to us within the past 2 days we couldn't put it on the agenda for an actual agenda item for this body to take action on but we felt it prudent indeed to have it here as an announcement. If there is some sort of discussion, I am sure Jodi is going to (laughter in the background). Ms. Wichman: Is there any discussion? Mr. Hull: Jodi may allow, I think to a certain extent, informative statements to be made. Ms. Higuchi Sayegusa: Any other announcements? Mr. Hull: Or announcements. Ms. Griffin: I think this doesn't, it's worth in this commission noting that the building is on the State and National Registers of Historic Places and you can read more in a book called "Lihue", pages 100 to 105. Mr. Hull: But yes it is there for comment. Like I said because we couldn't agenda this no official comments can come from this body but for informative purposes any member of the public, including yourselves as public members, can comment on it of course. The next agenda item. Oh I am sorry. Mr. Long: I have an observation comment. That is I understand the Postal Service and Governmental Agencies needing to reshuffle their workforce and their facilities. As someone that professionally has experience in historical post office renovations and adaptive reuse projects and feel that US Post Offices are particularly well suited to that type of adaptive reuse development and we saw that in Washington DC with President Trump's renovation of the post office there. So it would be nice to see the Federal Government pursue a sale and acquisition program as opposed to a demolition program. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 18 UNFINISHED BUSINESS Re: Proposed draft Rules of Practice and Procedure of the County of Kauai Historic Preservation Review Commission Mr. Hull: The next agenda item is Unfinished Business items J.1. Proposed draft rules of practice and procedure for the County of Kauai Historic Preservation Review Commission. So at the last meeting in November the Department submitted to you folks a draft of potential administrative rules for you folks to operate under. Currently this body does not have any rules in which it operates in a de facto manner under Roberts Rules. So to just take care of that we have submitted a draft to you folks and essentially you guys were taking it home to see if you had any comments or recommended edits or changes to be made. So that's what it's back here for. Ultimately, if there are no edits or if the edits are made and adjusted the Department with the County Attorney's Office is required to submit it to the Small Business Regulatory Review Board over on Oahu for a public hearing there prior to holding a public hearing official for the rules with the body. Ms. Wichman: Pat. Ms. Griffin: I made some comments last month and I see that they had not been. So chapter 2, 121 organization still shows that a the. regular September meeting of each year the Commission shall elect a chairperson and vice chairperson and I am not sure of the rest but it's in the minutes. Mr. Hull: My apologies. You did make those recommended changes and we had intended to make those adjustments and I didn't. Sorry, I apologize but we do intend to put those in. Ms. Wichman: Ok thank you. Any other comments, discussions? Ms. Higuuchi Sa. eregusa: Perhaps a motion, suggestion for a motion is to I guess I don't know if ordain is the right word but to approve Kaaina and I to go ahead and make a submittal to the Small Business Regulatory Review Board so that they can cause under State Statute, HRS Chapter 201m, any effects on small business has to be reviewed by the board. So they are reviewing again for the small business effects on the rules create. I jumbled that up but in any case we have to go to Oahu, go before the board and they have to review it and make comments if there is any. So, again, it would be a motion to allow I guess Kaaina and myself to go and take it before the Small Business Regulatory Review Commission. Ms. Wichman: Ok do I have a motion? Ms. Schneider: I make a motion for Kaaina and Jodi to go the SBA to have the rules approved with Commissioner Griffin's amendments as stated. Ms. Wichman: Ok do we have a second? Mr. Chaffin: Second. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 19 Ms. Wichman: Ok any discussion? (None.) Ok will there be any public testimony to this? Ms. Griffin: We have a motion on the floor. Ms. Higuchi Sayegusa: We do. There is a motion. No second yet. There is a motion. No second yet. Ms. Griffin: Larry second it. Ms. Higuchi SUegusa: Sorry. You can withdraw that and then open it to public testimony if there is any. So sorry withdraw the second and then withdraw your motion. Mr. Chaffin: I withdraw my second. Ms. Schneider: I withdraw my motion. Ms. Wichman: Ok is there any testimony from the public? Ok not at this time. So may I have a motion? Ms. Schneider: I'll restate the motion that Jodi and Kaaina should go to the SBA to have the rules approved with Pat's amendments. Ms. Wichman: And a second? From Larry thank you. Any discussion with the Commissioners? (None,) Ok can I have a vote, those in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) Any opposed? (None.) Ok therefore it passes. Re: Discussion on the status of the Certified Local Government Mr. Hull: Ok the next is agenda item J.2., Discussion on the Status of the Certified Local Government. I believe there is a representative from State Historic Preservation Division. Ms. Anna Broverman: Hello Madame Chair and Commission. I am Anna Borverman. I am the Architectural Historian with the State Historic Preservation Division. First, I wanted to update the Commission on the status of the 2016 CLG Grant funds. Our grants administrator just put forth the project notification for the Hanapepe Bridge Nomination Project to NPS. So it's currently for review there and I will let you all know through Myles and Kaaina whenever we hear back from NPS on that approval. Secondly, the fiscal year for 2017 has started and I have discussed with the planners from all 3 Certified Local Governments about splitting up the grant funds evenly between the 3 CLGs to help everybody plan better to know how many funds they can expect every year and so it's roughly about $19,000.00 for each CLG every fiscal year. I would like to know if the Commission has any comments on that? January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 20 Ms. Wichman: Commissioners? Ok no comments. Ms. Broverman: Ok secondly, I am currently writing the policies and procedures for the CLG program and as part of that I am laying out the process for the Commission to review National Register nominations, all the things the Commission is legally required to do per Federal laws and it's almost like a guidance document for the Commission. It will also help explain the grant process better and as part of that I am removing the requirement where the CLG has to match the Federal grants by 40%. So I am hoping by taking away that 40% grant requirement it will allow more projects to be done. So does the Commission have any comments on that? Ms. Wichman: Commissioners? Ms. Schneider. Sounds good to me. Ms. Wichman: Ok no comments. Ms. Broverman: Ok and lastly, I have received the final draft from Mason ,Architects for the Statewide Architectural Survey of Hawaii for our first year. So I am currently reviewing that and I will make sure to give a copy to the Commission whenever it is complete. Ms. Wichman: Thank you Anna. Stephen. Mr. Long: I have a question. Was that for the historic districts? Ms. Broverman: Yes, that was the study that was created with the legislative funds that we received in 2015. So that survey took part last year and now we are starting the second round this year. Mr. Long: I have an additional neighborhood that I would like to nominate to have taken a look at on the second round. Ms. Broverman: Ok. Mr. Long: I believe it's Kaohe Road off of Kalihiwai Road looking into Kalihiwai Bay with a number of Hickey Homes that were built immediately after the ' 57 tsunami that wiped out the general store and the gas station down in Kalihiwai Bay. Those homes were built by Amfac and Hickey overlooking Kalihiwai Bay and a number of prominent Kuleana families like the Akana family still have homes up there and they are still really intact. It really a lovely neighborhood so I think we want to take a look at it. Ms. Broverman: Great. Thank you very much. Does the Commission have any more questions for me? Ms. Wichman: Commissioners? Pat. Ms. Griffin: When do you think you will have the rules together? January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 21 Ms. Broverman: So the policies I just finished writing I think it was yesterday and I have sent it to National Parks Service for a preliminary review. They said they were looking at it this weekend so I am hoping I will have a copy by March at the latest. I would like to get it to the Commission for the February meeting if possible. I am trying to do it quickly so that the ' 17 grant projects won't need that match. Ms. Griffin: Great. Thanks. Ms. Wichman: Any other discussion, questions? Ok thank you very much Anna. Ms. Broverman: Thank you. Mr. Hull: So there would need to be a motion to receive Anna's testimony for the record. Ms. Wichman: Ok. Do we have a motion to receive Anna's testimony? Mr. Chaffin: I make a motion to receive Anna's testimony as given. Ms. Griffin: Second. Ms. Wichman: Any discussion? Ok all those in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) Any opposed? (None.) Motions passes. Thank you. NEW BUSINESS Mr. Hull: The next agenda item is agenda item K.I. Garden Island Service Station, TMK: 3-6- 006:089, 3-3178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Kauai. Proposed demolition of gas station built in 1930. I believe we have a representative for the applicant. Mr. Jon Lucas: Hi I am Jon Lucas from Palms Hawaii Architecture. I am here just to hear your comments and field them for the owner as I am just representing the Owner's agent from Palms Hawaii Architecture. Ms. Wichman: Any questions from the Commission? Mr. Hull: Just some background for the Commission if you are not familiar. The structure, the Shell Gas Station in Lihue has been before this body before for a demolition permit. There was considerable discussion had when that application was brought last year some time, or the year before. Ultimately after the discussion at some point a month or 2 after the applicant decided to withdraw the demolition application. Since that time they have decided to reup the demolition application so that is why it is back to you folks again. If you feel like this is de ja vu. It is because it has come here before. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 22 Ms. Wichman: Commissioner any comments, questions? Mr. Chaffin: Where is the right of way in relation to that structure? Mr. Hull: The State highway you mean? Mr. Chaffin: Right. Mr. Hull: It is directly adjacent to it. So you can see in the photos, so you drive down the highway here and you will run right into it on your right hand side driving toward Hanalei. Mr. Chaffin: Run right into it, then it's in the... Mr. Hull: It's directly on your right has you drive down the highway. Right next to the No. 1 cafd. Ms. Wichman: Any other questions, comments, concerns? Ms. Griffin: I have some questions. I notice that the application, the demolition, is dated 2015. Was it not updated? Oh and the response from the State Historic Preservation was 2015 as well. Mr. Hull: Sorry, for the Commission's edifications we included the old application as well as the comments that SHPD made to that original demolition application. But to be clear, SHPD hasn't commented on the renewed demolition application. Ms. Griffin: But it's the same? Mr. Hull: It's the same plan essentially to demolish. Correct. Ms. Griffin: I noticed in the zoning permit application that Shell is saying that they have at least a 75% property interest but then further on it says that it's joint owner with the Weinberg Foundation and I wondered about that relationship. Mr. Lucas: I am not aware of the exact allocation of the percentage of ownership but I can take that request and find that information and get back to you. I am not aware of that information at current time. Ms. Griffin: You know I do find, this is such an important building in town and it's a little frustrating not to have somebody who can talk and respond because the building shouldn't come down. It is an integral part of that block and it's in our Lihue District Community Plan that was finished last year or so. It is listed on page 33 as one of the historic places that exist Kuhio Highway Commercial Strip. In our town, well so I would like to have more of a discussion about finding ways to retain the building and I don't know how we can do that. Is there a time limit that we can come back next month? January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 23 Mr. Hull: Yes there is no, the zoning permit hasn't been intaken and as such there is no time limit as this point. As a condition of acceptance of the zoning permit we require that comments from this body to be made first and received by the applicant prior to intaking their zoning permit. Once we intake their zoning permit there is a clock, there is a 21 day clock that we have to either deny or appove and essentially there is not much we can do with the zoning permit to actually deny it though. Ms. Schneider: Is it possible to have the applicant's representative rather than the architect but somebody from Shell come and speak to us why they want to demolish it. Mr. Hull: I think you can ask Jon that very thing. Mr. Lucas: I could ask the applicant to come forth and... Ms. Schneider: So that we can make some kind of presentation about why we would like to retain the building if possible. Mr. Lucas: Sure. I totally understand. That makes sense to me. Ms. Griffin: Cause even the demolition assumes another building there and the plans that we were given show a building that doesn't conform to the Ordinance that follows the Lihue Town Core or Urban Design Plan and it certainly doesn't, specifically in the keeping with the context of the historic structures around it. And I don't want to shoot the messenger, Mr. Lucas, but I feel like it would be unfair to try to put you in a position to answer these and have a reasonable discussion about such an important building. Mr. Hull: Yes so ultimately if that request is being made for the applicant to have somebody specifically from Oahu come over here and have the discussion, I think that request can be made and essentially you would defer until the next meeting to have that request either be met or not essentially. Ms. Wichman: Anymore discussion Commissioners? Ms. Schneider: I make a motion that we defer further discussion on this application till we get a chance to speak to somebody from Shell if possible. Ms. Wichman: Do we have a second? Ms. Griffin: Second. Ms. Wichman: All those in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) Any opposed? (None.) This motion passes. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 24 KAUAI HISTORIC RESOURCE INVENTORY UPDATE COMMITTEE Mr. Hull: The next agenda item is the Kauai Historic Resource Inventory Update Committee. An update on the permitted interaction group for updating the Kauai Historic Resource Inventory. Did the group meet since the last meeting? Ms. Wichmann: No. Mr. Hull: Then my apologies in setting up the agenda. If the group hadn't met then we shouldn't have actually had that agenda item. So I guess there is no report to give at this time. Ms. Griffin: Is it possible to set another date now since it is an agenda item? Mr. Hull: Yes. Ms. Griffin: I look at you because if it is possible to set another date. Ms. Wichman: The date would be up to Myles. Ms. Griffin: For the inventory? Mr. Hironaka: Yes. Ms. Wichman: So Myles would you send an email to us so we can discuss which date we might? Ok thank you. Mr. Long: I have a comment. We would like to put this back on the fast track schedule. We had the holidays and people sick but I think as a P I G and also with Commissioner Griffin we would really like to move forward in an expeditious manner. Ms. Wichman: Any other discussion on the P I G? On the inventory? No. HISTORIC PRESERVATION PUBLICITY COMMITTEE Ms. Wichman: Ok we move on to Historic Preservation Publicity Committee. The update on the permitted interaction group for publicizing historic preservation efforts and has that group met? Mr. Hull: I don't believe that, that group has met but the reason we placed it on the agenda was in discussions with Commissioner Long the desire to at least provide the Commission or begin the discussion on incentive packages that property owners have for preservation efforts particularly for the State Registry and National Registry. So in your packet at the very end you have an array of different exhibits that list the County ordinances as well as the Federal tax incentives for placement on the historical registry list and essentially, in a nutshell, the County Real Property January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 25 Ordinance will waive, if it's non-profit organization that owns the structure it will waive 100% of its assessment of that structure that is on the list from taxation or tax assessments. If it's just a regular individual, not non-profit but a typical homeowner the County of Kauai Real Property waives 75% of the assessment. So it's a substantial amount that is waived in your real property taxes for placing on the State or National Registry. There is only a residential structure exemption under the County of Kauai Tax Code. In our research there is no commercial or other type of structure tax incentive. That is the tax incentive for the County of Kauai Real Property. Do you have any questions on that particular issue? Mr. Lonz: Yes I do have a question. I have read this ordinance and my recollection is that for State Register of Historic Places that are residences occupied by the homeowner is what would be considered is what would be considered a home... Mr. Hull: They have a homeowners exemption as well. Mr. Long: Would qualify for a homeowners exemption. Not have the homeowner's exemption. If those real estate taxes could be kept at $150 a year and if it was not their primary residence then it's discounted. Mr. Hull: For homeowner occupied there is, I don't know the specific rate it is done at but there is a specific reduction and cap for the assessment on those properties where the primary occupancy of the dwelling. Mr�Lon_g: Right. So these are number, so it's this type of question and clarification that I believe the public is really looking for. So I have a number of those questions from the public that would like to get that information and would like to have a format in which to ask the questions and obtain real specific answers. Mr. Hull: Well, I mean for the homeowner's exemption this would not be the appropriate forum. If you want to discuss the historic registry tax assessment, indeed this would be the forum for it. But things like various incentives for the waiver or caps on tax assessments, ultimately that has to be coordinated with the Real Property Division. You have a whole array of different types of waivers and caps on assessments. Everything 'from affordable housing, to a homeowner occupancy, primary homeowner occupancy, to the age bracket categories of the homeowner that's occupying the dwelling unit. There is an array but as far as this being the forum for that discussion, quite frankly, I got to say Commissioner this isn't the appropriate forum. For a specific discussion on like I said the historic exemptions are given which are fairly substantial at least for residential further discussion can be had. But that's the only, under the real property code, that's the only historical exemption that they have right now. We can talk off line about the other things. (Laughter in the background.) Mr. Long: Thank you for the clarification. And I can tell you that there are members of the public that have gone to the assessor's office and asked them certain questions and they have been referred to the Planning Department. So there is a miscommunication and a lack of coordination and the information that is being provided to the public on these programs. So just asking for a forum for January 26, 20 t 7 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 26 clarification and if this is not that specific forum then so be it. But we are in, our P I G, has responsibility of informing the public about various incentives for their State Historic Preservation tax exemptions, and the prorated allocations for nonconforming properties, and whether the TVR Ordinance is overlapped, and has impact from that tax exemption are all real questions that are all driven by the historic preservation registration. So I don't what the forum is. Mr. Hull: No, no that is what I was getting at Commissioner. That if it is singled out specifically under the historic preservation platform and the various incentives available, indeed this is the appropriate forum and that is why I essentially provided the documents that you are in receipt of. So you have the County of Kauai Real Property tax waivers as well as I have also attached the Transient Vacation Rental Ordinance which basically states that transient vacation rentals outside the visitor destination are strictly prohibited with exception of those properties listed on the State Historic Registry or the National Historic Registry. That doesn't mean those on the State Historic Registry can automatically operate a TVR. It just means that they can apply for a use permit to operate a transient vacation rental and it's the only way now you can essentially look at pursuing a land use entitlement for a TVR here on Kauai on those properties outside of the VDA. In the VDA they can run amuck but outside the only way is through a site that has been recognized for historical preservation on either the State or National Registry. Mr. Lona: This may not be the format for this particular question and if so please just defer it. But a question that has been asked is if you place your structure on the State Register of Historic Places and you obtain the historic tax incentive through the County of Kauai and then you go and through a use permit successfully obtain a TVR permit for that historic structure then there is a catch 22 such that you have got a residential structure that is now... Mr. Hull: Not being used for a residential purposes. Mr. Long: It is being used as a resort. Does that then negate your historic real estate tax exemption? Mr. Hull: Correct so you would, Commissioners, what Commissioner Long is pointing out is that under the tax code you get that waivered of 75% to 100% of your assessment if it's on the registry and among other things. There is another set of criteria including maintaining the site on an annual basis and recognizing that with the Real Property Division but in particular it also states that the residence will be used for residential purposes and homeowner occupancy. So you get the waiver of assessment with registry. On the other hand you can operate a transient vacation rental in an historically registered site but the second you operate that transient vacation rental you lose out on the tax assessment waiver. So the residential use is gone. So indeed you cannot have both scenarios of a TVR and a tax waiver. You would essentially, for a historically registered site, you have to pick one or the other. Mr. Long: Thank you. That's excellent clarification. I have another question. Ms. Higuchi Sayegusa: Are these a lot of hypotheticals? I just want to make sure we were just sort of tied into this, an update on the P I G. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 27 Mr._ Long: No I think this is a pertinent observation and statement I am about to make. Mr. Hull: Jodi I think what the Commissioner is getting at is, that is why those documents were attached to the agenda, was if there is a desire for the... initially the P I G for publicity purposes and then the. commission to utilize these documents in some publicity fashion. I am not sure what it might be. In a public notice. In a pamphlet. In a piece of social media. I am not sure. So the documents were attached for this discussion. Mr. Long: Thank you. Ms. Wichman: Any other discussion? Ms. Griffin: I have a quick question. Do you know what the thinking was about adding historic properties to the possibility of utilizing it in TVRs? Mr. Hull: I actually don't Commissioner. I was surprised to find out that, that entitlement is there. I am not sure. I would be curious to look back in the minutes of the Council's discussion at that time. I know there is some hesitancies and we have had applications or applicants come forward interested in applying for it but nobody has ever actually gone to the Planning Commission. Cause at the end of the day the entitlement to have a TVR in a registered site is not a ministerial entitlement. It's not permitted over the counter. It's a discretionary entitlement. It goes before the Planning Commission. The Planning Commission in their discretion will decide whether or not to award that entitlement to the applicant. Given that, I'd say much of the issues of nuisance and complaints that have been generated from transient vacation rentals on this island any application would have to ultimately thread fairly carefully as they go through because at the end of the day when they are applying for a use permit what they are applying for is to meet a compatibility standard. Is this higher up zoned use? This transient vacation rental, which is not an outright permitted use in the residential district, is it going to be compatible with its surrounding residences. So that would be litmus test that they would have to meet should they apply for a use permit. Mr._Long: I have a question. All of the major counties have this historic preservation tax exemption for residential use. Oahu also includes commercial buildings and what would it take for Kauai to adopt a similar ordinance. Mr. Hull: Ultimately an action by the County Council. Now this body can initiate that type of proposal quite frankly and if that is the desire to begin looking at proposing a commercial tax credit, or tax exemption, or tax waiver for historically registered sites that is in the purview but ultimately it would have to be moved up to the County Council for review and take action. Mr. Long: Thank you. Ms. Wichman: Any other comments? (None.) Do we have to move to accept this? Mr. Hull: You would just, just a motion to receive essentially. January 26, 2017 KHPRC Meeting Minutes Page 28 Ms. Wichman. Ok may I have a motion to receive? Mr. Chaffin: I make a motion to receive. Mr. Long: Second. Ms. Wichman: Ok so we have made a motion to receive and second. All those in favor? (Unanimous voice vote.) Any nays? (None.) Ok so passed. DATE AND AGENDA TOPICS Mr. Hull: The next agenda item is the date and agenda topics for the next meeting. So the date set for the next KHPRC meeting is February 23, 2017 and it will be here in this room next month. That's all we have for the agenda. ADJOURNMENT The meeting was adjourned at 4:45 pm. Ll, .. Sueda ". Sueda & Associates, Inc. / Architects and Planners February 3, 2017 Planning Department County of Kauai 4444 Rice Street, Suite A-473 Lihue, Hawaii 96766 Attn: Kauai Historic Preservation Review Committee Re: Proposed New Roofing Material for the Existing Restaurant Building Honolulu Ltd. TMK: 3-8-04: 14 4479 Rice Street, Lihue, Kauai After receiving this memorandum, regarding the denial of the metal standing seam roof. The owners, Honolulu, Ltd. has reconsidered and is proposing to use this simulated shake roof material in lieu of wood shakes that will not weather well in the Lihue climate. This material looks very close to a real shake roof material. See attached brochures on the specification of this proposed material. If you have any questions, please call me at (808) 949-6644 or email me at lloyd@suedasai.com. Thank you Lloyd T. Sueda Principal . I. ' FEB 2 3 2017 905 Makahiki Way, Mauka Suite Honolulu, Hawaii 96826-2869 Telephone (808) 949-6644 Fax (808) 949-6707 EMai I: lloyd@suedasai.com Bernard P. Carvalho, Jr. Mayor Wallace G. Rezentes, Jr. Managing Director PLANNING DEPARTMENT County of Kauai, State of Hawaii 4444 Rice Street, Suite A-473, Lhu`e, Hawaii 96766 TEL (808) 241-4050 FAX (808) 241-6699 MEMORANDUM DATE: November 10, 2016 TO: Lloyd T. Sueda, AIA 905 Makabiki Way, Mauka Suite Honolulu, Hawaii 96826-2869 FROM: Kauai Historic Preservation Review Commission SUBJECT: Honolulu, Ltd TMK: 3-8-04:14 4479 Rice Street, Lihue, Kauai Proposed New Roof for Existing Restaurant Building. Michael A. Dahilig Director of Planning Ka`aina S. Hull Deputy Director ofPlanniog This is to inform you that the Kauai Historic Preservation Review Commission (KHPRC) met on October 27, 2016 to review and discuss the proposed plans to install a new "standing seam" roof to replace the existing roofing consisting of a wood shakes on mansard roof and hardi-plank shingles of other parts of the Restaurant Building. Based on the plans submitted, the KHPRC voted to recommend that the applicant use roofing material similar to the original cedar shake type roof that was used in the original building and/or cedar shake type roof that may be still substantially in place. Please feel free to contact us if you have any questions regarding this matter. Mahalo. - i� cc: State Historic Preservation Division Planning Department, County of Kauai An Equal Opportunity Employer Replicates the rustic beauty of natural cedar shake that will last a lifetime • to", 7-1/2", and 5" widths • Mixed widths and staggered exposure for non -repeating pattern • Natural wood grains and color • Costs LESS than natural cedar shake • Fire resistant - Class A Fire Rating • Low -maintenance • Lifetime warranty • Never replace your roof again! INSPIRE® MITI Learn more about Arcella Shake Rustic Cedar today: 8OO-971.4148 InspireRoofing.com HEADWATERS Getup info@inspireroofing.com YiY Roofing �rw��r =016 Headwaters. All right rnerved. Areella Shake I Synthetic Cedar Shake Shingles I Inspire Roofing https://www.inspircroofing.com/areella-shake 6 ROOFING ING PRODUC" S ArcellaTM Shake ArcellaTNl Shake Is designed to replicate the rustiw appearance of cedar shake, while offering many color options to customize your home, By providing a thick cedar shake look and using a weli-tested polymer composite material, our synthetic shake won't rot, crack, split, warp, or need wood's chemical upkeenp. Authentic colors and subtle shade variations create an Inviting, natural lock in every piece. Arcella mitigates fire risk, torn from it's Mass A Fire components, fitting harmoniously into communities that prohibit wood shake roofing or require Mass A fire rated roofing. Each piece is 24" long and has standard widths of 5", 7.5% or 10" - each bundle is premixed for easy installation. Arceila can be installed at 9.25" exposure or 10.25" exposure and is injection molded For optimal control and performance. Ask about our 50-rear Limited Lifetime Warranty that is provided on all Inspire roofing products. Fleperding, on flghi co dlbim our roofing reflects varying laver ar c0t0r intensity. Actual calars May vary from those,howri on screen. Products Architects - �16�f u (P J Why Inspire Contractors Case Studies w Contact Us M Special Features & Superior Performance Q Q Inspire Roofing tiles molds are an exact replica of duality natural roofing slates. Stone clevage and unique edges are replicated exactly under intense prensure when manufacturing onr durable roofing slates and shingles. Q Inspire Roofing Products has 5pecificatlon listing with ARCAT, to include. CAD drawings and SIM Nadeling Q Inspire proofing Products provides Technical Bulletins for certain roofing applications Q Inspire offers custom mixes thit feature a variety of beautifully balanced color Q Homeowner Insurance discounts through State Farm insurance Company 1 of 5 1/30/2017 10.33 AM Arcella Shake I Synthetic Cedar Shake Shingles I Inspire Roofing https://www.inspireroofing.com/arcella-shake Realistic Replication &Authentic Looks Q inspire Roofing tiles molds are an exact repolc� of quality nat! ra( njQfing slates. Stone clew ige and unique edges aro replicated exactly render intense pressure whr� t manufacturing our durabie roofing slates and shingle:,_ Frequently Asked Questions Q Q. How Does Inspire Slate Compare With "Real" Slate On Price? A. The answer to this question is ..."what type of slate'?" Most slate sold in the US is imported from China with a minimal warranty and of variable quality. Inspire Slate is similarly priced to a good quality guaranteed Spanish slate, but has many inherent benefits. One extremely relevant and cost -saving advantage is that fixing times are vastly reduced. Please see the Features and Benefits section of this site for further details. Q. How is The Matedal Fastened To the Surface? A. Galvanized steel nails driven through the slate, either manually or by nail gun. No drilling, clipping or hooks required. Q. What Is The Minimum Roof "itch Inspire °Files Can Be Ibstallecl ran? A. 14 degrees (on a fully -boarded roof). This is very useful for extensions and other applications where the available roof slope may be limited. 2 of 5 1/30/2017 10:33 AM Arcella Shake I Synthetic Cedar Shake Shingles i Inspire Roofing https://www.inspireroofing.com/arcella-shake A. This is intentional. The induced camber flattens and creates a tight fit when nailed in place. A. Yes. Standard slating principles apply. A. Nailed and overlapped. Dry -fix system much more secure than a bedded ridge. Cement does not adhere well to Inspire Slate. A. No, Inspire Slate is UV stable with the same color through -out. It will weather, as does any roof covering, depending on location and exposure. -�AN Vol Cut A. Fine-toothed saw, disc cutter, or scored with a utility knife. A. Once again, this depends on the location and exposure of the site. Algae grows better on a laminar material, Inspire Slate is not laminar. To deter growth, string a copper wire across the length of the ridge. of 5 1/30/2017 10:33 AM Arcella Shake I Synthetic Cedar Shake Shingles I Inspire Roofing https://www.inspiroroofing.coun/arcella-shake Product? What's it Made From? A. It's not recycled... but it's RECYCLABLE. Inspire Slate is made from limestone and virgin resins. Consequently there is greater control over the mix and the manufacturing process. The main problems experienced with using reclaimed inconsistent raw materials are due to the lack of control in the manufacture which can result in splitting, curling, etc. There are no such problems with Inspire Slate. Q. Flow Are The Tlies Pack. ed/DeliveredT A. Individually strap -banded bundles of 25 slates... 1600 per pallet (or less). There is a delivery charge depending on location. Q. Can The Material Be Used For Vertical Cladding? A. Yes. FEATURES & BENEFITS: 0 9 1141, & 1(11 `E /4" Exposure Options 0 Non -repeating,, wt-iggered or stra4ght application 0 BunOes pre-sorted for cc for and shade width variations O Class A m- Class C dire Rating. 10 Class 4 ImroCt Rating 0 110 NIiPH 110 nd Uplift Rating APPLICATIONS: 4 of 5 1/30/2017 10:33 AM About Inspire At Inspire, we place innovation above all. This has allowed us to deliver artistically beautiful, authentic and durable roofs over the years, Our industry -leading color palette and unmatched quality is the secret behind our success, We craft roof tiles that mirror the natural detail of slate and cedar in all their charm, delivering rnernorable elegance, stunning color and Contact Us [j Inspire Roofing Products `- 29797 Check Road. Wixom, full 48393 -P '1.800.971.4148 Z-3 info@lnspireRoofing.com Headwaters Roofing Aledora Slate Classic Slate Arcella Shake Cool Roofing OO 2015 Headwaters. All rights Mixed Colors reserved. KAUAI HISTORIC RESOURCE PROFILE Name: Garden Island Service Station Tax Map Key Location: Kuhio Highway, Lihue State Site No.: Owner: SLU District: Original Use: Service Station County G P: Present Use: Gas Station & Restaurant County Zoning: Condition: Good Date -Original: Integrity: Doors & windows changed, garage bay enclosed Date(s)-Altered: Historical Information: Contractor was Shizuka Kuraoka, built for Charles E. Rice. - Distinguishing Features: One-story, T-plan building. High-pitched hip roof in concrete, but designed to look like thatch, with slight curve at bottom edges. Lava rock pillars support roof. Leg of the T covers two gas pump lanes, while other portion of the building is enclosed with new horizontal wood siding & windows. Large chimney with modern exhaust added for restaurant tenant. Major Sources: Spencer Mason Architects, Kauai Album, & KHS files. sm, 1, 'FEB 2 3 2017 Urban c. 1930 r_JA O17 DEPARTMENT G, JL4NNING- STANDARD ZONING PERMIT APPLICATION One (1) original; If providing plans, five (5) sets, including original, required. Fees vary based an permits required and range from $30 to over $1000. Proof of 75%fee ownership rights orauthorized agent must be attached. Check One: My Paper Plans Electronic Pans M This application shall be filled out by all seeking Zoning, Use, Variance, SA Use or PDU Pernits pursuant to the Kauai County Code, Hawaii Revised Statutes Chaptei 205A and all relevant rules and regulations of the Planning Commission and Department. Supplemental information may be attached to form. SMA applications may also require additional SMA assessment forns. I' 6 TrM MI ax, Map Key Numbeir (4) 3-6-006:089 . Applicant Name ALOHA PETROLEUM LTD. Property 3178 KUHIO HIGHWAY,.LIHUE, I(AUAI 96766 Address Mailing 1132 BISHOP STREET, SUITE 1700, HONOLULU HI 96813 Address Parcel Size 30,000 SQ.FT.. Zoning MU-C Contact Phone 808-246-0676 Designation Applicant Dreclarations (incorrect responses may slow your permit review) A. PIease place an " X" under Yes or No under the following: Yes No Staff Verification 1 Isis property located in the Special Management Area (SMA)`? X 2 Is this property part of a Condominium Property Regime (CPR)? X __.._... 3 Is this property within $50 feet of the shoreline? X 4 Is this property within the Agriculture Zoning District? X re 5 Fs there a structuon the property, that is 50 years old or older? X 6 Do you have an Additional Dwelling Unit Certificate? X 7 Is this a pbrmit for an after -the -fact construction or activity? 8 1 hold at Ieast a 75% property interest in the property. X 9 Are you an agent for the property owner? 10 Has a similar application been previously denied? X 11 Is this an application for an agriculture structure under 200. sq. ft. x B. PIease fill in a response to the following: 1. If you have previous zoning permits, please state the peinait number(s): Applicant Dreclarations (incorrect responses may slow your permit review) A. PIease place an " X" under Yes or No under the following: Yes No Staff Verification 1 Isis property located in the Special Management Area (SMA)`? X 2 Is this property part of a Condominium Property Regime (CPR)? X __.._... 3 Is this property within $50 feet of the shoreline? X 4 Is this property within the Agriculture Zoning District? X re 5 Fs there a structuon the property, that is 50 years old or older? X 6 Do you have an Additional Dwelling Unit Certificate? X 7 Is this a pbrmit for an after -the -fact construction or activity? 8 1 hold at Ieast a 75% property interest in the property. X 9 Are you an agent for the property owner? 10 Has a similar application been previously denied? X 11 Is this an application for an agriculture structure under 200. sq. ft. x B. PIease fill in a response to the following: 1. If you have previous zoning permits, please state the peinait number(s): B. PIease fill in a response to the following: 1. If you have previous zoning permits, please state the peinait number(s): TOTAL FEE: Jo �-,NN 2 6 2017 2. If this is not the first dwelling unit on the subject property identified on this application, please state how many dwelling units presently exist: 3. What is the proposed construction and/or intended use of the structure or parcel (inay attach additional info)? Submittal Checklist Please initial under "Yes" or not applicable "N/A" regarding eacli of the statements: 1. All plotplans I have submitted are drawn to scale. Yes NIA Staff Verification X. 2 I have ensured all TMK numbers are visible on all Ian sheets. X 3 Any plans I Kaye submitted clearly show all structures and setback dimensions. X 4 My plans provide lot coverage calculations. X 5 I have ensured kitchens are marked with the 8' radii required by Planning Dept, Administrative Rules X Because this application involves a CPR, the plot Ian shows all existing structures. X ,munuwiea emenTs - Ylease xnmal next to eaca of the statements: I understand: initial Here Additional fees and/or the submittal of other application forms may be necessary to complete this application for acceptance and processing. Tender of fees by the County does not imp!imp!y acceptance of this a lication. Errors in self -declaration or missin.- or incomplete information will delay acceptance and processing of your applicition. Any purposeful misrepresentations in this application may result in delay, denial, permit revocation, violatio s, fines and even criminal prosecution. The owner and/or authorized reoresentatire is hereby made aw&c that the construction, work, use or activiiy approved in this permit shall be subject to inspection by Planning Department personnel. The applicant is advised that inspection may occur prior to or during construction and use to ascertain the activity is conducted in compliance with she law. Further, I am a duly authorized agent or have 75010 ownership rights, OWNER/AGENT SIGNATURE: DATE: FOR PLANNING DEPARTMENT USE ONLY (THIS CONSTITUTES PERMIT IF FILLED OUT BY DEPT.): APPROVED DENIED BY: DATE: UAL i U1C" L-5 I.UIN011WIN b UP ArrKU VAL (statfto initial next to applicable conditions): This perinit sball expire if no building permit is issued within one (1) year following approval date and/or if construction does not start within one (1) year of building errnit issuance. Director's standard conditions for non-residential agricultural structures (attach) Additional Conditions (State): RAVED Y. iGE GOVERNOR CM EAWAu September 16, 2015 Ca`SK95p any STATE OF HAWAH DEPARTMENT OF LAND AND NATURAL RESOURCES STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION DIVISION KAKUHIHEWA BUILDING 601 KAMOKIL.A BLVD, STE 555 KAPOLEI, HAWAII 96707 Palmer W. Hafdahl, AIA Palms Hawaii Architecture LLC 2970 Kele Street, Suite 115 Lihue Hawaii 96766 Email: palmet@palmshawaii.com SUBJECT: Chapter 6E-42 Historic Preservation Review Kauai County Zoning Permit 3178 Kuhio HWY — Demo of Kihue Shell Kalapald Ahupuaa, Puna District, island of Kauai TMK: (4) 3-6-006:089 Owner: Aloha Petroleum suzMPB D. CAEE CHAYRERM HOARD OPLAND AND NATURAL REIGURCM COM► ILLMM ON WATER REIGURCE HANAGEMENr KEKOA KA(UMMA PHIH'rDM%W W. BOY HARDY ACIIM DEIUrY DHIRCM, WATER AQUATIC ILMURCRI BOAMEM ANDOCEAN R97LFATTON 1vAHAUOPOONVEYANCn CORII MIM ON WATER RHIGURCE MANAWMENT CONETRVA7= AND CDAWALLANDR CON36RVA'GON ANDRHIOURLES HNRORC79 MU BERM FORBITRY ANO WRDLHM NCTORCMU RYAMON EAVOOLIWRMLAND AB RRVECOMMMION LAND SrATATARR.S LOG NO: 2015.02747 HOC NO:1508MB02 More Information Required Oo Not Issue Permit On July 15, 2015, the State Historic Preservation Division (SHPD) received the submittal for Section 6E-42 Historic Preservation Review. The Area of Potential Effect (APE) is TAW (4) 3-6-006:089 which is located along Kunio Highway in Lihue. The project scope of work includes demolition of the gas station built in 1930. The submittal included photographs, historic photographs, and historic context regarding the gas station. Based on this submittal, the gas station, formerly Garden Island Service, is eligible for the State and National Register of Historic Places. A demolition plan and information regarding the depth of required excavation associated with underground tanks is not provided in the submittal packet. The Kauai Historic Preservation Commission must review this project; their recommendation will inform our review. Our records indicate that we do not have an Archaeological Inventory Survey on file for the subject property. In order to determine the need for archaeological monitoring, please provide information regarding the depth and extent of ground disturbance. *SHPD requests the following actions to be completed before Permit issuance: ® other: Reccommendation from the Kauai Historical Prevation Commission and Demolition Plans including Underground Tanks SHPD looks forward to receiving the recommendation from the Kauai Historic Preservation: Commission and demolition plans indicating the depth of excavation for the demolition. SHPD will notify you when the requested material has been reviewed, accepted, and SHPD's part of the review process is complete. SHPD acceptance of requested material is required prior to issuance of the permit. Any future work outside of the proposed scope identified in this review may be subject to additional SHPD review. Lihue Shell 9/21/2015 Page 2 of 2 For Architecture questions, please contact Anna Broverman at (808) 692-8028 or at anna.e.broverman@hawaii.gov. For Archaeology questions, please contact Mary lane Naone at (808) 271-4940 or at maryjane.naone@hawaii.gov. Mahalo, Alan S.Downer, PhD Administrator, Deputy State Historic Preservation Officer cc: County of Kauai Planning Department 4444 Rice St A 473 Lihue, HI 96766 In the event that historic resources, including human skeletal remains, cultural layers, cultural deposits, features, artifacts, or sinkholes, lava tubes or lava blisters/bubbles are identified during construction and/or other activities, cease all work in the immediate vicinity of the find, protect the find from additional disturbance, and contact the State Historic Preservation Division (SHPD) immediately at (808) 271-4940 (Kauai) I', I sere rue —,o-� EXISTING OFFICETO PALMS REMAIN I' EXISTING RETAIL TO —_—_ _— _— _ �Fl� I REMAIN 1-TJ — — Foundamion � — r— P-T, FI ! =I -I I FI I =III III-111-11 FJ I -III -I I Lrll�ll-1�„I�l; II��,,I� T IE1-T;-III=iI�-III=ll1��-�h�l_I-1T� s z west ARCHITEC, LTnv'c Fbnhtle„ 6�Adlnp i8�8 Ksh Streo! SiateA 115 Roo! Lhu'e, Naxei i, sszss T!F (9S9}246-4�96 Email W Grre,�palrmM1exeil.mm �Tw a rt H SERVICE ', �oRuwaircsur•rae Y --- r- STATION 5 "CONVENIENCE--e— ---- S70RE TO 1 , 4� r�t Frao, b � __ -DEMOLISH I T- -fr+'-TT�IT-f- EM- 5-ICI 1T—i �E1=ilr=—III—III�111��1=1i�ll�ll�=11f—III=III=;ill=i 1=111�1�11'r�I�IHII—III-11»11=if11! ��� n sa m Mvi I FJCI571NG — I I I nu- Roar -- - ---- 1a'� I RETAIL REMAIN TO I J I I Aloha patrol®um — - — ` adTro I i AP_Uhue TMK (4)3-6-66:08S I I Ervte, address here Fw aato = r -"_ . - - - -I I _T I F mai l 1 s Ill�li II-11-1iH 1I TFIII�1-IFI�I�L=l=iIH-111�1F-11[711-IIHI�II-IlE-1I 1 �I=1II��I I- I LHII�`I �EIFfIIJI1=1�IIHIF��IrF-IiF,I��F[-1Ii-IIFII I First I st Floor Plan ,� ungse�ew� a Ch.1k,1 1 Frs, F[eer Al a:maKa�e y ME' ! PALMS EXISTING SERVICE STATION ROOF AND PUMP STATIONS TO BE "�='• DEMOLISHED =ter ��. HAWf ARCIIITEC� _ �� -- r� _ i - Pyndtion aeda�ne 29N Kele Shee[9WeC i15 Lstu n. Himl'1. 961E9 IIF (ece7 xgssiss Ercmlf Falmci�axlnchawail.ccm C win u YME i,3AwmeY1� wuNcei,n®,asmPk l � r T e�ddm 1 Room — AS Aloha Petroleum AP_Lihue TMK (4)M-06:089 Roof demo \ <• _,' �• Plan --�_�� o?rzsrzots EXISTING TO REMAIN 2WO Kd� S�..t 011 5 M., % 7w 71FSKfl) —7s Small pafmar®paLrrshaysiiwm Aloha Patralatim AP_LihuL- TMK (4)3-6-06-069 Enter aad�ese here Cover Sheet Ocs-1 ,�_ .� � � �_ .� Q J� t� .� - �_ — . _ _ ... ..��-�`��. a 1 �� ���� v /r t i�?\'.1 _`� k Aft i �(. M iI'1 0 .� ; T , .; tv "� lif HUE A i tit �4 a • 74 s r, N: n_ ®r _e4 ;4I12 I�j r From the Collection of Kauai Historical Society 2 i L. yr_ �, •h�i From the Collection of Kauai Historical Society GUY ROTHWELL ARCHITECT (was 1944 President of AIA Honolulu) opened Oahu office 1922. File contributed for use in USGenWeb Archives by: J. Orr jessicanorr@gmail.com December 21, 2011, 3:37 pm Source: The Story of Hawaii and Its Builders, Honolulu Star Bulletin, Ltd. Territory of Hawaii, 1925 Author: Edited by George F. Nellist GUY NELSON ROTHWELL; Architect and Consulting Engineer. After spending six years on the mainland at the completion of his course in architecture and engineering, Guy N. Rothwell in 1915 returned to Honolulu, the city of his birth, and is now one of the most active builders and consulting engineers in the territory. Mr. Rothwell has served variously as engineer and designer with the Honolulu Iron Works, the Pacific Engineering Co., the Hawaiian Electric Co., Bowler and ingvorsen, as consulting engineer for the City and County of Honolulu and is now handling the designs of several projected bridges for the city and county, Among the local buildings which Mr. Rothwell has designed are the Griffiths, J. B. Castle and Boys' Athletic halls at Punahou, the new Palama Settlement and the new Oahu Railway and Land Co. depot. He also supervised the building of the First National Bank building, Harris Memorial Church and many other public and commercial buildings and private residences, and the King St., Moanalua, Haleiwa and Wahiawa bridges. During the World War Mr. Rothwell served 17 months in the Construction Corps of the Navy and one year with the overseas transport and cruiser force. He is a member of the American Legion, a past commander of .the Veterans of Foreign Wars, and holds memberships in the Commercial and Myrtle Boat clubs. Born in Honolulu, Nov. 9, 1690, Mr. Rothwell is the son of John George and May (Haley) Rothwell. His education was received in the public schools of Honolulu, followed by a two-year collegiate course. In 1917 he married Mary Louise McCarthy, daughter of former Governor C. J. McCarthy, and they have three children, Frank Nelson, Robert McCarthy and Mary Louise Rothwell. File at: http://files.usgwarchives.net/hi/statewide/bios/rothweII52,ibs.txt This file has been created by a form at http://www.poppet.org/hifiles/ File size: 2.4 Kb This is a summary of his life from -the Rothwell genealogy. 1911: Assistant Draftsman, Navy Yard, Puget Sound, Washington July 11, 1911 to October 26, 1912. Letter of reference in family file. 1912: Draftsman in Public Works Department from November 1912 to January 1914. Letter of reference in family file. 1914: In charge of the structural steel and reinforced department of Honolulu Iron works from August 1914 to May 1917. Letter of reference in family file. 1915: Serial No. 42181, File No. L.910, Issue Number 1.1., Department of Commerce and Labor, Steamboat Inspection Service License to operate/navigate vessels not exceeding 65' in length or 15 gross tons, motorized carrying passengers for hire. Valid for 5 years in Steamboat Inspection District of Honolulu, Hawaii. Dated August 12, 1915. License in family file. 1917: Ship draftsman at Navy Yard, Pearl Harbor. Furloughed without pay from December 26, 1917 for duration of war. Letter of reference in family file. Appointed Carpenter (Temporary) U.S.N., Assigned to United States Navy Yard, Norfolk, VA. Orders in family file. 1918: Orders to Carpenter Guy N. Rothwell, U.S.N. from Commandant's Office, United States Navy Yard, Norfolk, VA, April 22, 1918. Detached from Navy Yard, assigned to U.S.S. Hancock to relieve Assistant Naval Constructor E.L. Bass, U.S.N Orders in family file. 1924: Registered Professional Engineer & Architect by Territorial Board of Registration for Professional Engineers Architects and Surveyors within the Territory of Hawaii May 13, 1924. Registration No. 109 in family file. 1967 renewal in family file. 1933: Appointed Lieutenant Commander in United States Naval Reserve January 31, 1933. Appointment paper in family file. 1932: Elected to 'Member' of the American Institute of Architects, Hawaii Chapter letter dated January 23, 1968, signed Howard M.Y. Wong, Secretary, Hawaii Chapter, A.I.A. Letter in family file. 1968: Appointed OMember EmeritusO of the American Institute of Architects, Hawaii Chapter letter dated 23 January 1968, signed Howard M. Y. Wong, Secretary, Hawaii Chapter, AlA. Letter in family file. Misc: Attended Oahu College (Punahou College, not to be confused with Punahou Preparatory). Graduated University of Washington, architectural engineering. Major buildings: Our Lady of Mystical Rose Chapel, Chaminade College; Damien High School; Roosevelt High School; ARMCO, first all metal pleasure craft made in Hawaii, 35' loa; Honolulu Hale (City Hall); Honolulu Stadium; King Street, Moanalua, and Wahiawa Bridges; Oahu Railway and Land Depot; Harris Memorial Church; Boys Athletic Hall at Palama; Hilo Armory; First National Bank Building; Charles H. Atherton House (dormitory) University of Hawaii; original gymnasium at U. of H.; Beretania, Kalihi and Kaimuki pumping plants for Sewer and Water Commission. Appointed Board of Hospitals and Settlement (Kalaupapa Leper Colony) 1931. Was present for disinterment of Fr. Damien De Veuster. Life member of the Honolulu Elks Lodge 616. Charter member of Waikiki Yacht Club, commodore 1958. Member Waikiki Beach Improvement Panel. Member Board of Harbor Commissioners 1957-1963. First captain of the Outrigger Canoe Club, 2nd dues paying member (1908). Ethnicity/Relig.: Roman Catholic Personality/Intrst: Fishing, boating (above from Eileen Richardson) Notes on Guy Nelson Rothwell--Source FWB 3rd I've put a few remarks here that weren't brought out in his obituary . The first thing one would notice about Guy Rothwell would be that he was short but feisty. From about the beginning of the war until he retired, I don't think there is any doubt that he was the most successful architect in the islands. However, I think what he would like to be remembered as is a man of the sea. He loved his boat, fishing, taking charter parties --just being on the water. He was a good instructor. I didn't know much about running boats when I went to live with him, but he changed that quickly. His philosophy of life was tied closely to his seamanship. One of his themes was that there are some things that you have to avoid because if you fowl up, you don't get a second chance. His first example was falling overboard at night. You avoided that by giving one hand to the boat and one to yourself--- always hang on. Another was that if the boat broke down in the Molokai channel and you couldn't fix it you might never be heard from again. So he taught me to fix anything that might break down even before I could properly steer the boat. As soon as I could dock the boat and pull out of the dock without causing damage, I was in charge of running it. From then on he entertained the fishing parties or his friends and I was the designated driver. On the boat or anything else in life he believed in letting a person make mistakes -- and paying the penalty (except in the things you don't get a second chance on). One of his ancestors was Lord Nelson (what they said at the time but may not be true) and his grandfather was a sea Captain who settled in the islands. One of his duties as the Naval Aid to the Governor was to participate in the Navy's 'attack' on Hawaii during the maneuvers that took place every few years. In these maneuvers the Navy tried to capture the islands, and the Army defended the islands. The army was judged to win in all but one of the maneuvers. The navy's only victory came on an attack that he helped plan, and it was executed exactly like the attack that the Japanese made on December 7, 1941. The navy had waited for a cloudy day (the Japanese were just lucky that it was cloudy), it was a surprise, the planes attacked from the windward side of the island and hit the same targets He visited us in Seattle on his way to a meeting back east for Chaminade College. He was 90 years old and acting like he was 20. Dorothy, Gail and I went up lake Chilan to Staheken with him and had a really good time. Gail was 9 or 10 years old. Louis died of a long term illness within a year. He was his usual self at her funeral, then died of a heart attack about a week later. The following obituary from the Honolulu Advertiser does a good job of describing him and his life. Kamaaina Guy Rothwell dies; was 80 Guy N. Rothwell, kamaaina architect, businessman and public servant, died Friday. He was 80. Services for Mr. Rothwell are pending. Burial will be at National Memorial Cemetery of the Pacific. Mr. Rothwelll is survived three sons, Frank N. , Robert M. and Guy N. Jr., all of Honolulu; a daughter, Mrs. Mary Louise Lloyd of Pitsfield , Mass,: a sister Mrs. Thelma Rogers of Berkeley, Calif.; 19 grandchildren and one great-gandchild. Mrs. Mary Louise Rothwell, Mr. Rothwell's wife of 53 years, died March 2. WITH MR. ROTHWELL'S death, Hawaii lost another of its "true" Hawaiians. Or as Mr. Rothwell said in an interview early this month with Advertiser columnist Sammy Amalu: 'I was born in 1890 when Hawaii was still a monarchy. I was born a Hawaiian...... 'My family were imprisoned and exiled because we supported Queen Liliuokalani. We were royalists. We fought for Hawaii's last Queen. 'We were indeed truly Hawaiian, and without a drop of that blood in our veins.' SAID AMALU of Rothwell's comments: OAnd of course, Guy Rothwell was telling the truth. He told the stories of that band of haoles who were loyal to the Hawaiian Kingdom, the royalists. And who else is left to tell their story, one that has never yet been told? 'When Guy is gone, how bare indeed will be the marketplace.' M.R.. ROTHWELL was born in Honolulu on Nov. 9, 1890, the son of John George and May Haley Rothwell. His maternal grandmother was Charlotte Brown Haley, daughter of the English seaman, Capt. Robert Brown, who once owned Kahuku ranch in Kau, Hawaii, and came to the Islands in 1838. He attended Punahou School here during 1899-1900 and 1904-1909, then went to high school in Seattle, where he also continued his education at the University of Washington. AFTER GRADUATION from the University of Washington in 1911 with a degree in architectural engineering. Mr. Rothwell returned to Hawaii to do engineering with the United States Navy at Pearl Harbor. From 1915-1917, he worked with the Honolulu Iron Works Co. Also in 1917 on May 7, he married the former Mary Louise McCarthy, the daughter of Charles W. McCarthy, the governor of Hawaii from 1918-1923. From 1920 to 1923, he worked as an engineer with various construction contractors here, but in 1923 he went into private practice. IN 1925 HE formed a partnership with John H. Kangeter and Marcus Lester and designed and constructed some of the major buildings in Honolulu. Mr. Rothwell is credited with the construction of many buildings built during the time Hawaii was still a territory. He was one of the group of architects that designed Honolulu's City Hall, Honolulu Hale. Among other buildings planned by him were the Palama Settlement, Oahu Railway Passenger station and office, several buildings at Punahou School, the Hilo Armory building and the Kin Street, Moanalua, Haleiwa and Wahiawa bridges. He also supervised construction of the Bishop Trust building, Harris Memorial Church, the original gymnasium and Atherton House at the University of Hawaii, Roosevelt High School and the Beretania, Kalihi and Kaimuki pumping plants for the Sewer and Water Commission. IN ALL, Mr. Rothwell designed more than 1,000 structures on Oahu. In a newspaper interview in February, 1960, Mr. Rothwell said of Honolulu's turn -of - the century days: 'I first lived in Waikiki where the Moana Hotel now stands. The area as we know it today did not exist at the turn of the century. 'There were fish ponds, duck ponds and rice fields. Kalakaua Avenue was a winding road through the soggy ponds. They used to call Kalakaua 'Waikiki Road' then. It was an easier time to live. 'It used to take two hours by horse and buggy to get from Waikiki to downtown Honolulu, so only the wealthier people lived there' IN THOSE EARLY days, Mr. Rothwell was close to Hawaii's royalty. 'Queen Liliuokalani's mansion was downtown at Washington Place. I remember her well. She was a gracious lady, the best of her race. She had a beach house at what is now Kuhio Beach. It was a great place for the gang. She was a fine woman. Of course, there were those against her, but that was for political reasons' Of Prince Kuhio Kalanianaole, he said: 'Prince Kuhio--his nickname was Prince Cupid --was a fat, brown, jolly fellow --a very friendly man who typified the very finest. He was greatly interested in fishing. But he was a fantastic politician. He made a wonderful delegate congress. He was a fine gentleman. He always paid his bills. Prince Cupid was something of a poker player, but not much: his uncle, King Kalakaua, was the real poker player.' AND OF THE FIRST days of the Outrigger Canoe Club, a club which he helped found: OIn the midst of all this the Outrigger Canoe Club was built by Alexander Hume Ford. He was an author --and I guess something of a crackpot. The club was originally organized for the boys of Honolulu. But that didn't last long. Their mothers and fathers took over and I guess never let go. I was the first captain of the Outrigger in 1908, and its second dues -paying member in history. The first, of course, was Alex Ford.' DURING THE FIRST World War, Mr. Rothwell served 17 months in the U.S. Navy as an officer and one year with the Overseas Transport and Cruiser force. In 1930 he was appointed by Gov. L. M. Judd as special naval aide with the rank of Lieutenant, Naval Militia, Territory of Hawaii. He served in the capacity though JuddOs gubernatorial term, and later, on the staff of Gov. J. B. Poindester, served as an aide with the rank of Commander. Mr. Rothwell, as a reporter once commented was 'never ..... a man to suppress his gripes.' IN 1932 HE WENT on public record as saying that the City-County's handling of building projects was 'hideous and bungling.' In 1934 he'pot- shotted at the theater code' here, and in 1945 he called the Territorial Building Code'outmoded, ineffective and contradictory.' And in 1953 when he challenged a sweeping theory of city master planning, he was , according to a news report, 'believed to be the first private citizen ever do so.' OTHER POSTS held by Mr. Rothwell over the years included a four-year term (from May, 1935) of the Territorial Board of Hospitals and Settlements, membership in the American Institute of Architects and the Engineering Association of Hawaii and a regentship at Chaminade College. He was also a life member of the Honolulu Elks Lodge 616; a charter member and former commodore (1956) of the Waikiki Yacht Club; a member of the Waikiki Beach Improvement Panel; a member of the Harbor Commissioners Board (1957- 1958); and a past president of the Hawaii Chapter, AIA. Arrangements for Mr. Rothwell's funeral services are being handled by Borthwick Mortuary. This is an article that was in one of the Honolulu newspapers when Guy died. It is about Guy and Flora Rice who died on the same day. they lived lives of grace By Sammy Amalu (He wrote 'the world of sammy amalu') Chill winds blow across the bay, and the night birds cry along the cliffs. The night is dark tonight, and there are clouds over the face of the moon. There are no more dreams to be dreamed, for the hour of dreaming is done. There are no songs to be sung, for the time of singing is no more. Death has walked upon the shore tonight, and he walked not alone. IT IS NOT ENOUGH merely to live. One must do more. A man must walk tall over all the land. A woman must walk with grace. A man must erect monuments, that the earth will remember him after he has departed. A woman must walk with tenderness and gently, that the earth caress her feet and flowers blossom where once she trod. So did they walk, they who are dead this hour. So did they live their days. Nor did they take from earth more than they gave. They replenished the deserts and fashioned gardens out of the wilderness. They planted green trees where no trees had grown before. They brought forth new blossoms out of an and soil. They left the earth a better place. Better because they had lived here. Better because of them. They brought forth new blossoms out of an and soil. They left the earth a better place. Better because they had lived here. Better because of them. THEY BOTH LOVED Hawaii. They loved her mountains and her seas, her skies and her rainbows. They loved the people, the simple people, the gentle people, the kindly people. And because they were simple themselves, gentle and kindly, the people loved them too. Perhaps this is after all the true measure of greatness. The only scale to weigh the worth of a life. They each walked their own way, but they both walked with a grace unmatched. He was a gentleman. She was a lady. Perhaps these two words describe them best.... HIS WAS A FAMILY that never failed in its loyal support of the Hawaiian throne. They had been ministers to the Crown. They had long served the sovereigns of Hawaii. And when there was rebellion over the land, their allegiance never wavered. They stood beside their monarchs. They were royalists, among that brave band of haole families who chose not to rebel against Hawaii's Queen. He was born on the very lands where SO years later he was to die. He grew up in the days of the Monarchy, of the Provisional government, of the Republic of Hawaii, and the first years of American rule. HONOLULU THEN was a sleep town but a gracious one. And I think he loved it better the way it used to be even though he did as much as any to build a new city on these shores. For he was a builder. He reared mansions where there had been naught. but wilderness. He was a native-born Hawaiian, a true Hawaiian. And I doubt that anyone ever loved Hawaii more than he. He was a Kamaaina, a child of the soil indeed. I have often wondered what were the elements necessary to fashion an Hawaiian. What ever they be, I think he had them. SHE CAME TO the Islands near 60 years ago and married a boy from Kauai. She never left. Instead, she weaved her own pattern into the fabric of her husband's family, one that had given to these Islands, and especially to Kauai, 150 years of devoted service. She was one of those women, peculiar to her own generation and perhaps peculiar also to these Islands, one of those women who knew how to be gracious.... THEY LIVED their days through and hour of great miracles. Bom into the age of the carriage and the buggy, they lived to see man walk the face of the Moon. What more can anyone ask?.... Guy Rothwell was a gentleman, Flora Rice was a lady. No epitaph can better describe them. No words can tell more than these what they were. Ua like no a Ike me ka mele a ka makeke. O yes indeed, the marketplace is made more bare. And they who were lovely in their day are no more. THE CHURCH The church building was designed by Honolulu architect Guy N. Rothwell, who also designed the Gyre (orignally also used as the Parish Hall) and Memorial Church School Building. It was completed on December 6, 1925, and contains many items of historical interest. The building utilizes the native lava rock stone in its structure, and features magnificent stained glass windows. Click HERE to read about the different stained glass windows, altar and other historical features of the church. APPLICANT: PALM 5 H AWAI ARCHITECTURE PROPOSED DEMOLITION OF LIHUE SHELL ALOHA PETROLEUM 3-3178 KU H I O H WY LIHUE, HI 96766 AUTHORIZED AGENT: PALM'S HAWAII ARCHITECTURE 2970 KELE STREET #115 SCOPE OF WORK: Demolition of existing roof canopy and convenience store. PROJECT DESCRIPTION: A. Historical Background: The Highway vicinity in Lihue is home of the historic Garden Island Service station. It is positioned at the Poinciana street access to Kuhio Highway, Adjacent to the north is the historic Lihue Theater which has been repurposed as Senior Housing with the historic highway facade maintained. On the other side of the Service Station is a Not Chinese Restaurant (previously Wendy's Circ.'84 Jack in the Box Circ.'85) and 7-11" on the same parcel. Further South along the Highway is the Garden Island Publishing and Garden Island Motors (1923) buildings. Across the highway are additional roadside services including a "Mc Donald's" and 76" station. Directly across the Highway on the Poinciana corners are "Pizza Hut" and the Chevron service station followed by a warehouse facility converted to various retail enterprises. On the subject parcel in addition to this service station are offices and retail enterprise located in the remodeled previous lube and paint facilities once associated with the service station? The complex was developed in the early 1930's by then reigning business interest as an extension of "Garden Island Motors". Record (see accompanying) shows the facilities were designed by arch itectleng ineer Rothwell & Lester with the service Station and its unique roofing and rock work as the roadside feature in front of the garage area. The structure was completed in 1930. It featured a waiting room and thematic landscaping to compliment the rock work and fauve thatch roofing. That roof once colored tan has since returned to its original cement grey before being painted green more recently. The rock -work once natural with green tinted mortar has also been painted apparently to cover damage and increase waterproofing. B. Description of Proposed Addition and surroundina areas: As graphically represented on Sheet SP1- Site Plan, the existing Service Station is placed front center on the lot. It involves approximately one third of the property with another third parking and the remaining third retail/office facilities to remain. The parking area is paved and will remain as such. Minor landscape area exists adjacent to the "theater" property on the north. The current facility serves this busy intersection as a Shell gas outlet and associated convenience store. Its immediate neighbors across the Highway and to the north are also transit oriented businesses, serving the Highway. The operator, Aloha Petroleum as joint Owner with the Weinberg Foundation proposes an updated facility to continue the long tradition of Shell gasoline in this location. New facilities will include a steel flat roof canopy over new pump positions. The COK planning department has encouraged a canopy supported by rock veneer columns with mansard style roof edge. The convenience store facilities will be excluded. The applicant will work with the COK Planning Department to accomplish street front and pedestrian access in keeping with the intent of the Lihue Town Core Urban Design Plan. All functions will be located on one level and will be fully handicapped accessible. Following, please find a few photos of the existing property. e �0,2 �f Yii�.� L� F-LIj rill I �71 (Tirl /r diOV i i�/ a 'EL Nk 'a 6yA � eta �.� .,gym 1:i1 ICI;1' '�+1I wvrww"� ff — - .ter .. ...._ f r c 4ry` _ , �. G�q.�� ey�.Y '► �•�idu� f._y! � *, �� - i..*��y,���� �'�x� � 'i'��t..T Tl oil 7� f- Y' i� �` {;��- 'ry .II'y Y`_n• tom} _ ... F '.;1� � ``• . _ Present soffit condition at Rock wall veneer Signed- Palmer W. Hafdahl, AIA AUTHORIZED AGENT 4/10/.2015 Date HAWAII STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION DIVISION Chapter ISE Historic Preservation Review Submittal Form For projects affecting buildings more than 50 years old. TMK: (4) 3-6-006:089 YEAR BUILT: 1930 STREET ADDRESS; 3-3178 Kuhio HNY Island: TOWNIAREA: Lihue ZIPCOOE: 96766 PROPERTYNAME: Lihue Shell HISTORIC NAME; Garden Island Service OWNER- Aloha Petroleum ARCHITECT(if known) ; Guy Rothwell OWNER TYPE: )0 PRIVATE p PUBLIC CONTACT # : (808) 246 - 4796 EMAIL @ pSubmittal Checklist: Allsubmittals must include the following Is] IXPLANS Plans must illustrate the building before and after the proposed work. Avery detailed project description will suffice for small projects. Any plans larger than 11X17 must be submitted in a digital format. PLANS WILL NOT BE RETURNED! Share your knowledge (Optional) Is the property associated with: significant historical events; Examples: A building that once housed an early school. - An old commercial dlstrict that represents a town's growth over time. -A building that once housed an important social organization. ❑ an exemplary design or construc- tion method; Examples: A representative work of a master architect. - The oldest brick building in the state. - A small farm house with exceptional examples of Japanese carpentry. - A military facility that illustrates cold war technology. PHOTOS Include clear photos of each elevation as well as photos of the specific locations of the proposed work. Digital photos are ac- cepted and encouraged. - ❑aprominenthistoricatfigure; Examples: The office of an important labor leader. - The halau of a prominent kumu hula. - The boyhood home of a president or world leader. The studio of a locally significant artist. an archaeological site Examples: An important pre -contact habitation site. - The site of an important battle. - A plane crash site. Describe this association: Include any other important historical information you may know. Feel free to use multiple pages The service station is part of a robust development of early Lihue along then "government road", now Kuhio Highway. It is adjunct to Garden Island Motors and representative of the growing commitment to automobile transportation and service to private vehicle ownership on Kauai. The station is unique for its "hawaiian" theme including imitation thatch roofing. Rev, 3/13 lit MKE ASSOCIATES LLC Structural Engineers Aiea Commercial Center Suite 205 99-205 Moanalua Road Alea, Hi 96701 1 Phone: (808) 488-7579 Fax: (808) 488-7818 E-Mail: rake@mkellc.com May 14, 2015 Mr. Dan Lyman Aloha Petroleum P.O. Box 500 Honolulu, HI 96809 Subject: Structural Assessment of Aloha Petroleum Lihue Station 33178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Kauai Dear Mr. Lyman: At your request, we had the opportunity on May 7, 2015 to review the condition of the Lihue Aloha Petroleum Station located on 33178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Kauai. This review was requested to assess the structural integrity of the station with regard to deterioration of the structural framing. This letter reports our findings, The station is a one-story structure, T-shaped in plan, with a steeply sloped (approximately 12.12) hip roof (Photo 1). The structure is constructed of a wire mesh reinforced mortar topping roof cast on wood plank roof sheathing that is supported on 2x6 rough framed rafters spaced at 17 in. The rafters span to 2x8 ridge, hip and valley framing. Ceiling joists spaced at 17 in. support a metal lath and plaster ceiling. The front portion of the structure over the pumps is supported on wood beams spanning to stone masonry posts while the rear portion of the structure is supported on stone masonry walls. Our scope of work consisted of a visual observation of the structure as could be viewed from the exterior and interior ground level and from the attic space. Hidden conditions such as those covered by roof, ceiling, wall and floor coverings were not reviewed during our visit_ From our review, we have the following observations: • Extensively termite and dryrot deteriorated roof plank sheathing (Photo 2), roof rafters (Photos 3 and 4) and valleys (Photo 5) were observed over large portions of the roof. It is estimated that 50% of the roof sheathing and framing is deteriorated, with the deterioration located primarily at the bottom half of the roof and at the valleys. The presence of a bent vertical brace indicates that the roof may also be sagging (Photo 6). • At some areas, the roof plank sheathing was deteriorated to the degree that it had fallen away, exposing the mortar topping above (Photo 7). Exposed wire mesh reinforcing at the bottom of the topping was observed to be severely corroded and the mortar was observed to be cracked. Daylight was visible through some of the cracks. • It is estimated that 25 to 50% of the ceiling joists are termite deteriorated with much of the deterioration located at the ceiling perimeter (Photo 8). • The majority of the eave soft plaster around the perimeter of the building is cracked and delaminated (Photos 9 and 10). This deterioration coincides with the deterioration in the supporting eave framing above. From our observations, it appears that water has been infiltrating through the mortar topping, resulting in corrosion of the embedded wire mesh reinforcing and cracking of the mortar, although some cracks and joints may have already been present in the topping from the initial construction. This water infiltration has likely resulted in the extensive termite and dry -rot deterioration in the roof and ceiling framing as well as the cracks, delaminations and corroded lath at the perimeter lath and plaster ceiling. May 14, 2015 Structural Assessment of Aloha Petroleum Lihue Station Aloha Petroleum 33178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Hawaii Page 2 of 2 Repairs to the structure will require replacement of the majority, if not all of the roof and ceiling framing. This will also require replacement of the roof topping mortar and lath and plaster ceiling that is supported on the roof framing. In addition, large portions of the roof topping mortar and lath and plaster ceiling may require replacement due to the cracking, delamination and reinforcing corrosion observed in these elements. If the entire roof coverings and framing are to be removed and replaced, the supporting stone masonry columns and walls below which appear to be unreinforced should also be retrofitted or replaced, as this type of unreinforeed construction does not meet current construction standards. Due to these conditions, repair and retrofit of the structure is not feasible and the entire structure should be removed and replaced. The opinions and comments formulated during this work are based on observations made at the time of the investigation. No guarantee or warranty as to future life, performance, or need for repair of any reviewed conditions will be expressed or implied. This work does not include an assessment of mechanical, electrical, geotechnical, hazardous materials or other nonstructural conditions. Compliance with any specifications and legal or code requirements, except as expressly noted, is specifically excluded from this work. Please call us should you have further questions on this matter. Sincerely, MKE Associates LLC Glenn H. Miyasato, P.E. Its Member Enclosures: Photos I through 10 May 14, 2415 Structural Assessment of Aloha Petroleum Lihue Station Aloha Petroleum 33178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Kauai Photos Photo 1. Photo 2. May 14, 2015 Structural Assessment of Aloha Petroleum Lihue Station Aloha Petroleum 33178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Kauai Photos Photo 3. Photo 4. May 14, 2015 Structural Assessment of Aloha Petroleum Lihue Station Aloha Petroleum 33178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Kauai Photos Photo 5. Photo 6. May 14, 2015 Structural Assessment of Aloha Petroleum. Lihue Station Aloha Petroleum 33178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Kauai Photos Photo 7. Photo 8. May 14, 201 S Structural Assessment of Aloha Petroleum Lihue Station Aloha Petroleum 33178 Kuhio Highway, Lihue, Kauai Photos Photo 9. Photo 10. Exhibit A KAUAI HISTORIC RESOURCE PROFILE Name: Lihue Post Office Tax Map Key: Location: 4441 Rice Street, Lihue State Site No.: Owner: U.S. Postal Service Original Use: `Post Office Present Use: Post Office Condition: Good Integrity: Addition in rear, open areas enclosed with glass; restored after Hurricane Iniki Historical Information: Built by E.E. Black, contractor, for $57,830. Discarded design by federal architect Lewis A. Simon was not deemed appropriate by local citizens for tropical climate. Floyd Williams, an architect/engineer, suggested open-air, Mediterranean -style building. On National Register. Observations: One-story concrete, rectangular -plan, symmetrical building, with gable, hip, and shed roofs of clay tile. Shed roofs over side sections extend further than main gabled space and create unusual intersection with shed roof over front entry. Spanish -style lamps flank entries. Main entry defined by two chamfered piers. Circular vent in gable. Metal -frame double casement windows with five panes. Small horizontal windows above shed roofs on side. Decorative rafter ends. Quarry the floor. Sources: Spencer Mason Architects, SHPO and KHS files SLU District: County G P: 3-6-05: 10 30-1 1 -9342 Urban County Zoning: Date -Original: 1939 Date(s)-Altered: I , I , 1994 Reconnaissance Survey FEB 2 3 2017 Shanlee Jimenez From: Kaaina Hull Sent: Friday, January 27, 2017 12:02 PM To: Shanlee Jimenez Cc: Myles Hironaka Subject: FW: MEETING NOTICE - Lihue Post Office facility proposal Shan, Can you put this on the KHPRC agenda. Mahalo I Ka' Gina Hull Deputy Director of Planning County of Kaua' i 4444 Rice Street, Suite A473 Lihu' e, Hawai' i 96766 (808)-241-4050 CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This message is covered by the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, Title 18, United States Code, §§ 2510-2521, This e-mail and any attached files are deemed privileged and confidential, and are intended solely for the use of the individual(s) or entity to whom this e-mail is addressed. If you are not one of the named recipient(s) or believe that you have received this message in error, please delete this e-mail and any attached files from all locations in your computer, server, network, etc., and notify the sender IMMEDIATELY at khul1@kauai.gov. Any other use, re-creation, dissemination, forwarding or copying of this e-mail and any attached files is strictly prohibited and may be unlawful. Receipt by anyone other than the named recipient(s) is not a waiver of any attorney -client, work product, or other applicable privilege. Nothing in this message is intended to constitute an Electronic signature for purposes of the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (UETA) or the Electronic Signatures in Global and National Commerce Act ("E-Sign") unless a specific statement to the contrary is included in this message. Thank you for your cooperation. From: Mary Daubert Sent: Friday, January 27, 2017 10:14 AM Subject: MEETING NOTICE - Lihue Post Office facility proposal ANNOUNCEMENT FROM THE USPS The U.S. Postal Service announced today the location and time of a public meeting at which it will discuss its proposal to consolidate the Lihue Post Office's retail operations at 4441 Rice Street with its delivery operations at its Carrier Annex at 3230 Kapule Highway. The meeting will be held at 6 p.m. on Thursday, Feb. 23, in the Exhibition Room at the Kaua'i War Memorial Convention Hall located at 4191 Hardy Street in Lihue. The public is invited to attend the meeting to learn about the proposal and share their comments. MARY DAUBERT Public Information Officer County of Kauai 4444 Rice Street Suite 235 Lihue, HI 96766 808.241.4909 FEB2 3 2017 Bernard P. Carvalho, Jr. Mayor Wallace G. Rezentes, Jr. Managing Director PLANNING DEPARTMENT County of Kauai, State of Hawaii 4444 Rice Street, Suite A-473, Lihu'e, Hawaii 96766 TEL (808) 241-4050 FAX (808) 241-6699 FE8 U� 2017 Jody Lowe, Real Estate Specialist USPS Facilities Office PO Box 27497 Greensboro, NC 27498-1103 Subject: Disposal Action Historic Lihu`e Post Office 4441 Rice Street, Lihu`c, Kauai, Hawaii Dear Ms. Lowe: Michael A. Dahilig Director of Planning Ka`Mna S. Hull Deputy Director of Planning The County of Kauai, Department of Planning OPPOSES the disposal action of the Historic Vibu`e Post Office located at 4441 Rice Street, Lrniu`e, Kauai, Hawaii. The Department disagrees that the property and postal service at this location "is excess and no longer necessary". We strongly urge you to reconsider the proposed disposal action. The Liihu`e Post Office is Integral to the L1hu`e Town Core Revitalization Plan The-L�u4e Post -Office -is -a-key-component in-impl-ementing-the Liheo town Core Urban...... Design Plan (LTCUDP). The LTCUDP prioritizes the revitalization of Rice Street neighborhoods to promulgate business, provide additional housing, and improve livability in Llhu`e. The Post Office is located at one of the busiest centers in the Liliu`e Town Core. In addition to numerous homes and businesses, adjacent to the post office are two of Kaua`i's largest employers, the State of Hawaii and the County of Kauai. Given its location, the Lihu`e Post Office is a vital service to those that live and work in the surrounding area, and it is integral in ongoing investments to further revitalize the area into an economically vibrant and livable community. The US DOT TIGER Grant for Revitalization of the Llhu'e Town Core The United States Department of Transportation (US DOT) recently awarded the County of Kauai $13.8 million through the Transportation Investment Generating Economic Recovery (TIGER) grant to implement the L!hu`e Town Core Urban Design Plan. As previously stated, the Lihu`e Post Office is integral to this area's revitalization efforts. A disposal action of the L-ihu`e Post Office would run counter to these revitalization efforts, including but not limited to the efforts and investment by the US DOT. An Equal Opportunity Employer ' FFB 2 2017 Uhu`e Post Office February 2, 2017 Page 2 of 2 The L-ihu`e Post Office is a RecogLiized Historic Feature The Lihu`e Post Office is listed on the National Register of Historic Places and the Hawaii Register of Historic Places. Established in 1939, the iconic Spanish Mission -style Lnlu°e Post Office retains its original structural and historical integrity. At its dedication in 1939, Judge Wood, Postal Inspector for Hawaii, proclaimed that the new Lihu`e Post Office would be the model for other tropically designed postal installations across the Territory. Maintaining the historical postal use within this original, historical structure is crucial to the continued retention of the buildings historical integrity. We further understand that there have been complaints about inadequate parking at the Lihu`e Post Office and surrounding area. Please be aware that under the proposed TIGER grant improvements, the County will approximately double the amount of on -street parking in the Rice Street area. Furthermore, while many' of the L-Aiu`e Post Office patrons do drive, the Department is aware that many walls from nearby homes or businesses, An audit conducted in April of 201.6 by the County of Kauai in partnership with the Healthy Hawaii Initiative Evaluation Team (University of Hawaii) showed 127 pedestrians entering the LAiu`e Post Office during a three hour period between 11:00 am to 2:00 pm. Relocating postal services from the Town Core Area to the airport will require virtually every patron to drive to the site. Removing this service is not only detrimental to the numerous revitalization efforts, it is detrimental to the many individuals, businesses, and families that currently access the site on foot. We strongly urge you to reconsider the proposed disposal action. Thank you for your consideration. Should you have any questions or concerns, please do not hesitate to contact me directly at Id-lull@lcauai.g_ov or at (808) 2414059. Respectfully yours, Ka`aina S. H 1, Deputy Director County of Kauai, Department of Planning cc: Senator Brian Schatz Senator Mazie Hirono Congresswoman Tulsi Gabbard Congresswoman Colleen Hanabusa VA2017 Master FilesLAdministration\LihuePostOffice-.020217v2,docx Bernard P. Carvalho, Jr. Mayor OFFICE OF THE MAYOR County of Kauai, State of Hawaii 4444 Rice Street, Suite 235, Lillu`e, Hawaii 96766 TEL (808) 241-4900 FAX (808) 241-6877 February S, 2017 Aloha Mr. Lowe, Wallace G. Rezentes, Jr. Managing Director The Uihu`e Post Office has graced the streets of Uihu`e since 1939. Our residents are fond of this venerable building, and often utilize the services offered there. When we heard about the U.S. Postal Service's recent proposal to move retail operations from this historic location, we were taken aback as it has been an integral part of the community for decades, and is included in all of the future plans for the area, i.e. the General Plan update, Uhu'e Community Plan and the U-hu'e Town Core Revitalization and Mobility Plan. It is my hope that you and other Postal Service officials will work closely with us to resolve this matter. Thank you very much. Sincerely, Bernard Carvalho, Jr. Mayor, County of Kauai An Equal Opportunity Employer iA N SUBMITTED FOR CONSIDERATION KAUA`I PRESERVATION COMMISSION MEETING THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 23, 2017 3:00PM INTRODUCTION The Reconstruction & Enlargement of Kaua`i's Only True Pipe Organ The attached information provides an overview of a project at All Saints' Episcopal Church in Kapa`a to rebuild and enlarge the church's pipe organ —the only true pipe organ on Kauai. All Saints' Church has embarked on a capital campaign to raise the money necessary to complete the project. Our goal is to have the project completed by Easter 2018. The organ project coincides with sub -projects designed to support the installation of the organ by restoring and enhancing the interior of the church. These sub -projects include: • Refinishing the concrete floor in the sanctuary • Repainting the interior walls and ceiling • Possibly restoring the board & batten look on the walls • Modifying the original organ space and adjacent storage area to install the new organ This project is necessary because the original organ installed in 1925 needed to be decommissioned in 2016 due to problems associated with the age of the organ and coastal environment. All Saints' Church also took the decision to rebuild and enlarge the original organ due to its historic association with the Wilcox family and because it is the only true pipe organ on the Island. The facade and pipes from the original organ will be restored and re -used in the new instrument. (Refer to photos following The Reverend Ryan D. Newman's letter.) The original organ had 328 pipes. The reconstructed, enlarged organ will have 1,350 pipes. In order to install the enlarged organ we propose the following: • Use the original organ space plus the adjacent storage area as a larger organ room • The refurbished space will become in effect a giant speaker box • This will require modification to the space by removing three windows and two doors As part of All Saints' ongoing maintenance program, a sub -project is to replace the deteriorating roof of the church with new, longer -lasting shake that will retain the historic appearance of the current roof. The new roof will be installed at the same time work is done on the interior of the church. While this is not part of the overall organ project, the need to replace the roof comes at an opportune moment. LL SAINTS' EPISCOPAL CHURCH &PRESCHOOL KAUA`I'S FIRST AND ONLY PIPE ORGAN at All Saints' Episcopal Church and Preschool (Kapa'a, Hawai'i) The Episcopal Church in Hawaii was Chartered in 1862 under the laws of the Kingdom of Hawaii after King Kamehameha IV and Queen Emma invited the Church of England to Hawaii. The King and Queen supported the Church's presence throughout the islands with gifts of land, and by founding the Cathedral of St. Andrew in Honolulu. Queen Emma also founded Queen's Hospital (now Queen's Medical Center) and St. Andrew's Priory School for Girls, both in Honolulu. The last reigning monarch of Hawai'i, Queen Lili'uokalani, depended upon the spiritual support of the Episcopal Church during and following the overthrow of her reign in 1893. All Saints' was founded as KauaTs first mission of the Episcopal Church in 1924 at Kealia, four miles north of Kapa'a. The mission moved to its present campus in 1925. In 1962, the All Saints' mission became a parish church of the Episcopal Diocese. In 1925, Mrs. S. W. Wilcox generously donated an Austin Pipe Organ to KauaTs first Episcopal mission. It was the first pipe organ on Kauai. Ninety years later, the historic instrument is still KauaTs only pipe organ. Taking into consideration the responsibility of maintaining the historic legacy of Mrs. Wilcox's generous gift to the people of Kaua'i, to honor King Kamehameha IV and Queen Emma's vision to share the Christian faith with the people of the Hawaiian Islands, and for the sustainability and vitality of All Saints' as we approach the beginning of our second century of ministry on Kauai, our congregation has come to the understanding of our call to be stewards of the wonderful resources God has entrusted to our care. One of those treasured gifts is KauaTs only pipe organ. The pipe organ is an integral and beloved part of the Church's worship services and community music outreach programs in service to All Saints' vision to be a cathedral for the people of Kauai. Unfortunately, age and the tropical environment took their toll on this beautiful and historic instrument. The pipe organ's various wood, metal, and leather parts deteriorated. Routine maintenance and minor repairs were unable to stop the inevitable finale of the current pipe organ's lifespan. In February 2016, the pipe organ was decommissioned. The project's goal is to reconstruct and expand KauaTs only pipe organ thereby allowing All Saints' to share this prominent, beautiful, and historic instrument with the people of and visitors to Kauai. THE RIGHT REVEREND ROBFRT L. FITZPATRICK, BISHOP OF HAWATI D THE REVEREND RYAN D. NEWMAN, RECTOR AND HEAD OF SCHOOL PO BOX 248 1 4-1065 KUHIO HIGHWAY I KAPA'A I HAWAI'I 96746 (908) 822-4267 1 ALLSAINI'SKAUALORG I CHURCH@ALLSAINTSKAUALORG ALL SAINTS' (KAPA'A) - ORGAN PROJECT With the installation of the reconstructed pipe organ (Rosales Opus 40), The All Saints' 'Ghana, under the leadership of The Reverend Ryan D. Newman, have identified corresponding projects in the Church sanctuary that are essential to protecting and preserving this historic instrument. The following projects are scheduled to coincide with the organ reconstruction project: • Replace the old, damaged roof with a new, long-lasting shake roof. • Paint the interior of the Church and return the flooring to its original design state. • Convert an existing storage room adjacent to the northwest side of the sanctuary into an Organ Chamber Room that will house the 1,350 pipes for the reconstructed instrument (the original organ had only 328 pipes). SPECIFICALLY TO THE PRESERVATION COMMISSION'S CONSIDERATION Converting the storage room into an Organ Chamber Room necessitates that All Saints' remove the windows and doors associated with the room for the following reasons; 1. To support the operational environment required to properly house and maintain a world -class organ and its supporting components. 2. To create an air tight space that is necessary for an organ chamber which will include a spray foam insulation. 3. To ensure the organ chamber has the required atmospheric conditions to protect against heat, moisture, dirt/dust, insects, and other contaminants that can damage the instrument and significantly decrease its lifespan. 4. To provide an optimal acoustical environment that properly supports and amplifies sounds across the whole spectrum of the acoustical range. An optimal acoustical environment is especially important to capture sounds in the lower frequencies which are often diminished significantly by improperly prepared organ chambers. In January2016, All Saints' launched a capital campaign to reconstruct the pipe organ. A budget of $285,000 has been established to reconstruct the organ and to make some enhancements to the sanctuary and the adjoining spaces to support the pipe organ's functionality and the future vision of the music program. The target completion of the project is Easter Day 2018. All Saints' is grateful to be working with Rosales Pipe Organ Services, Inc. of Los Angeles, California. Manuel Rosales and his team bring an impressive background to 2 ALL SAINTS' (KAPA'A) - ORGAN PROJECT this extraordinary project. Manuel has restored organs throughout the United States and is a leader in the preservation of historic organs; he is considered by his colleagues to be one of the best in the industry. Rosales Pipe Organ's signature project is the world-renowned organ at the Walt Disney Concert Hall in Los Angeles. Manuel's vision is to design and build an exceptional and one -of -a -kind custom organ. Manuel has taken a deep interest in the project because of the historical and cultural implications of rebuilding Kaua`i's only pipe organ. The renewed, enlarged, and reimagined pipe organ will benefit the people of Kauai and those who visit the Garden Island for generations to come. Rosales Organ Builders' Opus 40 will be a most significant addition to the music, cultural, and worship life of the Island. Itwill be a diverse instrument celebrating Hawaiian culture, language and sounds. It will be the first organ in the world to contain both English and Hawaiian nomenclature. Also, the organ will integrate Native Hawaiian instruments and sounds. The updated facade design is inspired by Queen Emma's private prayer kneeler, which is prominently featured in the All Saints' Sanctuary. Upon completion of the project, the organ and renewed church interior will be an ideal setting for worship and music education, outreach through community concerts, and a sacred gathering space for the people of Kauai. "The pipe organ at All Saints' is not just an instrument; it is a link to our history, our ancestors, and our sacred traditions. To rebuild the All Saints' pipe organ is "pono" — good for the Church, good for the Island of Kauai, good for future generations, and good for the Glory of God," says The Reverend Ryan D. Newman. 3 SUBJECT AREA - SEE NEXT PAGE FOR DETAILS u i ORGAN ROOM _ - ❑ I' I I I ❑ I I I I �, I --- ❑ II I'I sMUTY I L---- ---- -- -- - - --- - - -- -- Rm ALL SAINTS EPISCOPAL CHURCH PLAN BASE SHEET ONE DOOR �N WE CANNOT B SEEN ALTAR WINDOWS & DOORS TO BE REMOVED THREE WINDOWS ON NORTH SIDE OF CHURCH -- _ CAN BARELY BE SEEN FROM THE HIGHWAY c c I SIDE Of CHURCH -- OM TH9, HIGHWAY ORGAN ROOM ONE DOOR ON EAST SIDE OF' CHURCH -- CAN BE SEEN FROM TH"IGHWAY CURRENT WINDOWS & DOORS WITH PHOTOSHOPPED APPEARANCE AS IF WORK HAD BEEN DONE PAGE 1 OF 3 PHOTO ON LEFT: Existing appearance of east facing door that can be seen from the highway. PHOTO ON RIGHT: Photoshopped view as if work had been completed. CURRENT WINDOWS & DOORS WITH PHOTOSHOPPED APPEARANCE AS IF WORK HAD BEEN DONE PAGE 2OF3 PHOTO ON LEFT: Existing appearance of north facing windows that are barely visible from the highway. PHOTO ON RIGHT: Photoshopped view as if work had been completed. CURRENT WINDOWS & DOORS WITH PHOTOSHOPPED APPEARANCE AS IF WORK HAD BEEN DONE PAGE 3OF3 PHOTO ON LEFT: Existing appearance of west facing door that is not visible from the highway. PHOTO ON RIGHT: Photoshopped view as if work had been completed. Name: Location: Owner: Original Use: KAUAI HISTORIC RESOURCE PROFILE All Saints Episcopal Church Kuhio Highway, Kapaa Episcopal Church Church Present Use: Church Condition: Good Integrity: No major alterations visible Historical Information: First Episcopal Church on Kauai. Designed by Guy Rothwell, Honolulu architect. Land donated by Henry D. Sloggett. Distinguishing Features: One-story, rectilinear -plan, wood -frame church. Complex roof form of steep gable with flared hip on three sides over lanai. Smaller gable over projecting sanctuary. Woad -shingled walls and roof. Lava stone piers with concrete capitals & bases. Four sets of 12-pane double doors on both sides of nave with louvered vents above doors. Tax Map Key : State Site No.: SLU District: County G P: 4-5-04: 18 30-08-9361 County Zoning: Date -Original: 1925 Date(s)-Altered: Wider doors at entry. Interior wood elements include exposed scissor truss supported by carved -� brackets and gothic arch at sanctuary end. _ �- G th;�c-arc d 4- d h I s windows over entr ==� o e s acne gas y and in sanctuary. Sacristy: 6/6 double -hung windows; paneled and glazed doors. Major Sources: Spencer Mason Architects, SHPO & KHS files. KAUAI HISTORIC RESOURCE PROFILE Name: All Saints Episcopal Church Location: Kuhio Highway, Kapaa Owner: The Episcopal Church in Hawaii Original Use: Church Present Use: Church Condition: Excellent Integrity: Well -restored; new rock wall and lamps around entry area Historical Information: First Episcopal Church on Kauai. Designed by Guy Rothwell, Honolulu architect. Land donated by Henry D. Slogget. Observations: One-story, wood -frame church. Complex roof form of steep gable with flared hip on three side over larval. Smaller gable over projecting sanctuary. Wood -shingled walls and roof. Lava stone piers with concrete capitals and bases. Four sets of 12- pane double . doors on both sides of nave with louvered vents above doors. Wider doors at entry. Interior wood elements include exposed scissors truss supported by carved brackets and gothic arch at sanctuary end. Gothic -arched stained glass windows over entry and in sanctuary. Sacristy: fi/6 double -hung windows; paneled and glazed doors. Tax Map Key: 4-5-04: 18 State Site No.: SLU District: County G P: County Zoning: Date -Original: 1925 Date(s)-Altered: c. 1992 Sources: Spencer Mason Architects, SHPO and KHS files 1994 Reconnaissance Survey All Saints' Episcopal Church 801h ANNIVERSARY HISTORICAL TOUR August 8 -12, 2005 1925 — 2005 AIoha and welcome to All Saints` Episcopal Church! Mahalo for joining us as we celebrate our 80a' Anniversary. We hope you enjoy your tour of the grounds and facilities of the church that is steeped in history and holds many fond and wonderful memories for the countless families and visitors that have worshipped here. All Saints' congregational history can be traced back to the arrival of the Rev. Henry Alpheus and Mrs. (Juelle 1.) Willey on Kauai October 28, 1924. In the next few months, while laboring under unfavorable circumstances in Kealia, Mr. Willey succeeded in obtaining land and making plans for the buildings in Kapaa. Mr. and Mrs. Henry Digby Sloggett gave the approximately five acres of land_ The congregation was organized in 1924, declared itself an interracial church and chose its name by a vote of the congregation. It became the first Anglican Church an Kauai. ALL SAINTS' CHURCH BUILDING The church building was designed by Honolulu architect Guy N. Rothwell, who also designed the Parish Hall/gym and Memorial Church School Building_ It was completed on December 6, 1925 and contains many items of historical interest including: The Victory Window above the door, designed by the Zettler Studios in NYC, was dedicated in April 1946 to all who made such great sacrifices for final victory in World War [I and to all the servicemen of the Honor Roll. It depicts an almost life-size figure of Christ with pierced hands and feet, clothed in shades of red, standing victoriously on a globe showing the Western Hemisphere including the Hawaiian Islands. The background is in beautiful shades of blue. The Honor Roll contains the names of the men serving in the armed forces in WW II from All Saints' Church. The brass plaque mounted in the back of the church under the Victory Window was ordered in 1948 from the International Bronze Tablet Co. of New York City and contains the names of the six men who gave their lives and 70 men who returned home. The money for the plaque, the Victory Window and the fighting came from voluntary contributions. The Austin pipe organ, the first and only pipe organ on Kauai was a gift of Mrs. S. W. Wilcox in 1925, The marble baptismal font was a gift of the children of All Saints' Church School in memory of their fellow student Herman W. K. Mahikoa, offered through their Birthday Thank Offering, The Gethsemane window above the altar was dedicated on September 8, 1927 and is inscribed Na memoriam Josephine Wundenberg King, 1848 — 1925". It was a gift of Mrs. Charles A. Rice. It was badly damaged by Hurricane Iniki on September 11, 1992, and was lovingly restored by Vance T. Wood of Stained Glass Art in California, in an on -site workshop put up in the Memorial HaLL It was to - dedicated on February 14, 1993. Mrs. King's great - ggrandson Holbrook Goodale and members of his family who so generously contributed to the restoration were in church for the re -dedication. The two stained glass side windows, Mary and the Baby Jesus inscribed "In loving memory Grace King Rice, 1880 — 1940"; The Boy Jesus in the Temple inscribed "In loving memory Mary Josephine King Forster, 1873 — 1940", were designed, executed and installed under the direction of Mr. Henry L. Willet of the Willet Stained Glass Studios of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. The dedication service, held Sunday, August 27, 1972 was lead by the Rector, the Ven. Richard S. O. Chang. The marble altar inscribed "In memoriam Lucy Etta Wilcox Sloggett, October I877 — December 1933," was the gift of Henry Digby Sloggett. ALL SAINTS' MEMORIAL CHURCH SCHOOL BUILDING ('I`IIE MEMORIAL HALL) This building was formally dedicated on November 12, 1939 and was used for the church school service, providing a place for three of the seven church school classes held Sunday mornings. Confirmation classes, young peoples' forums, lectures, and meetings of various sorts were also held here. Although it was often referred to as "the chapel" for short, it is not a formally consecrated building. Now referred to as Memorial Hall it is used for meetings and other church gatherings. The tower is a memorial to David K. Hayseld'en, who served on the vestry for many years. It houses the church bell which is rung each Sunday to call all - to worship and to call the Sunday school children to Communion. The Founders' Porch is divided into three bays. The central bay is dedicated to Her Majesty, Queen Emma of Hawaii, 'through whose instrumentality the Anglican Church was brought to the Islands," and is the gift of the Iolani Guild of St. Andrew's Cathedral. The right bay commemorates Capt. James Makee, founder of the industrial life of the Kawaihau District. Capt. Makes began the cultivation of cane and the manufacture of sugar in the Kapaa area His granddaughter, Wilhelmina 9• Tenney of Honolulu, gave this bay. The left bay is a thank offering for "the loving service rendered to the people of Kauai" by the Rev. Marcos E. Carver, the first resident Episcopal priest on Kauai in the early 2e century who labored here from 1917 to 1925. It is the gift of several of his Kauai friends. The sanctuary was the gift of Mrs. Ida E. Von Holt in memory of Bishop LaMothe, in whose episcopate All Saints' was founded. Notice the beautiful altar carved by Diedrich Hofgaard. The stained glass window over the altar depicting Christ blessing little children is a memorial to the Rev. Thurston R. Hinckley, for some years associate to the vicar of All Saints', and is the gift of more than three hundred of his friends. The building was originally divided into three classrooms by accordion doors. One of the classrooms is dedicated to the memory of Lucy Etta Wilcox Sloggett, founder and long time president of All Saints' Women's Guild, by which organization it was presented. The center room is a memorial to Idenry Digby Sloggett and was given "by many of those who loved him." The classroom at the front entrance of the building is the gift of Mrs. Dora Rice Isenberg in memory of Sisters Beatrice and Albertine, founders and for many years teachers of St. Andrew's Priory School. A timeline of events in the life of All Saints' Church, Kauai and the world is displayed around the building. Take a moment to remember wall of this where you were when some of these events took place. ALL SAINTS' PARISH HALL Wig. (THE GYM) -� '!Y�, v ' 0�' '4'__r� a� erTF ; This buildingwas built in 1929 and has served All Saints' Church and the cormnlsnity in many ways. fiver the years it has served as a Parish Ball complete with a commercial kitchen serving church dinners for up to 300 guests, a theater for shows and pageants, a gym for basketball and volleyball league games, Sunday school classrooms, an Inr-a u onal school, a meeting place fur community welfare programs and dances in times past sponsored by All Saints' Young Men's Club, Eli-Y boys and Leilani girls clubs. These dances were well chaperoned, well attended and the one place "careful mothers Permit their daughter to dance -" The hall was also the home of the All Saints' Kindergarten that met throughout the school year and had more than 50 children enrolled (1944). Soon after the beginning of WW 11 the hall was taken over by the army as a barracks- 'Three different outfits, one after the other were for a long time part of the "All Saints' family" To demonstrate how important a resource the gym was to the community, the first month after its return to civilian status attendance was counted at athletic eventsaaY pearocil the erons, club meetings, attendancee totaled slightly thirty- over 10.800 people! The gym is currently used by our Sunday school classes, men's weekly basketball games, various commurury and church functions, and the kitchen by Anahola Granola a popular local business. It is the future home of the .All Saints' Book Store and coffee lounge. ALL SAINTS' RECTORY t The Rectory was the first building completed on Lune 30, 1925 and became the home of the Rev. and Mrs. Henry A. Willey, firs[ vicar of All Saints' Church. The much beloved Willey's welcomed many groups into their home for meetings, dinners and friendly gatherings. Drying the war Mr. and Mrs. Willey hosted alter church luncheons for servicemen stationed on Kauai to make them feel they had a home away from home. The Vestry and the Women, 9 Guild met regularly at the Rectory. a� For our Sod' Anniversary celebrated August 7 through August I4`a, 2005 we have put together a display of a number of items of local historical and cultural interest: The Gift of Royalty, this very lovely silver chalice and paten, each bearing the inscription " Presented by Queen Emma to the fast Anglican Church on Kauai, September 6, 1993," was used at the fast communion service held at All Saints' Church on Christmas Day 1925- Kauai had its fust resident Anglican priest as early as IS81. on September 8, 1881 the Rev. R. Wainwright and his wife, a sister of Bishop Willis, came to Kauai as a tutor to the family of Mr. George Dole of Kapaa. He remained here until after May S, 1985 —the last entry he made in the old Kauai Church register. It is reported that the Wainwrights went from here to the Mainland - The silver was then entrusted to Dean Ault of St. Andrew's Cathedral in Honolulu who used it for many years olio istering to the sick in 13011olulu until he then returned it to Archdeacon Willey when All saints' became the "firsAnglon liicann church each s oil Kairai , it has been passed church as they have been founded. It comes to us today on loan from St. Michaels and All Angels of Lihuc, the most recently established Episcopal Church on Kauai. Queen Emma's Rthiw s lady in he home- It rayer desk w'as used for many s years by gracious was bequeathed by Her Majesty, borna reve 36, di d 1885, to one of her ladies-in-waiting whom later presented it to All Saints' Church. It is now used each Sunday in our healing services. Note the other Hawaiian artifacts and displays of interest OTHER BUILDINGS NOT ON THE TOUR THE HENRY WILLEY MFAORIAL COLUNMARIUM This building was dedicated Thanksgiving Day 1958 to be used as the final resting place for urns containing the ashes of Henry Alpheus Willey (December 21, 1887 —January 4, 1959), his beloved wife luelle I_ (18S8 — 1965), and cur many other loved ones. The use of the property on which the Columbarium and cemetery are located was acquired in 1955 by means of a trade with Lihue Plantationfa r new church's Wailua Cemetery property cemetery was dedicated on Memorial Day 1955 when the move of the remains from the Wailua cemetery was completed. Then in 1973 the church received a gift from the H. D. Sloggett Memorial trust of the half -acre of land on which the cemetery and Columbarium are situated. SLOGGETT CENTER AND ALL SAINTS' PRESCHOOL This building was dedicated in February 1980- Its four wings around a central courtyard house the Church office, kitchen, large meeting room and the classrooms and restreoms for All Saints' Preschool. All Saints' Preschool was originally started in 1966 as a preschool for church members' children only. It was located in the All Saints' Gymnasium Building with a staff of two. A few years later it expanded to include children from the community, using the Memorial Hall building- Today, it is housed entirely in the Sloggett Center with a capacity of 49 students and a staff of ten. It serves as a day school for children ages three to five years, and is an outreach ministry of All Saints' Episcopal Church, licensed by the State of Hawaii. All Saints' Episcopal Church 1065 Kubio Highway, P. O. Box 248 Kapaa, HI 96746 phone: 8o8.822.4267 Fax: 80g.8212417 Email: allsaintskanai@verizon.net Visit us at www.allsaintskauai.org UMAKOSHI ENTERPRISES, LLC REMODEL 4277 HALENANI STREET, LIHUE, KAUA1 TMK (4) 3-6-009;016 February 7, 2017 Building Permit Number 16-1634 SUMMARY This 4277 Halenani Street commercial building was built in 1953 as a restaurant, and has been locally known as `Ma's Place' or `Ma's Kitchen' since 1962 when the Umakoshi Family took over the restaurant. The restaurant was open until 2 AM for night time revelers and reopened again at 5:30 AM for `Early Birds'. The restaurant has been vacant for approximately 6 years after the declining health of Mrs.Umakoshi, who ran the restaurant as a family business. Ma's Family Kitchen, LLC has purchased the building and has applied for a building permit to renovate the structure into 4 offices and 2 apartments. The building permit zoning use application has been approved by the Planning Department and we are seeking review of the Application by the Kauai Historic Preservation review Commission because we plan on replacing the front and rear doors, which will affect the exterior elevations. FRONT ELEVATION: As one looks at the building from Halenani Street one can see three different existing entry door styles. On the far left the entire bay of fixed glass with jalousie windows above and original entry door has been boarded up with plywood and a 3' x 6-8" hollow core wood door, that previously accessed a travel agency. We will be restoring the fixed glass with jalousie windows above to match the other two bays original fenestration. The center bay still has the original 4'-0" x 7'-4" bi-fold doors that were originally in each of the three bays entrances. The center bay was used as a service 1 emergency entrance I exit and the entry to the restaurant was to the far right. At the far right entry, the existing 3' x 6'-8" aluminum storefront entry door with fixed glass sidelight and transom window replaced the original bi-fold doors after Hurricane Iniki, in 1992. In the photograph package one can view the existing Halenani Street exterior elevation and the 2 Door Options that we are considering for your review and comment. Option 1 would replace all three existing entrances with a 3' x 6'-8" steel 'fan lite' door within the existing 4'-0" x 7'-4" opening. The side and top would be filled in with solid wood material and painted. Please note that a similar door and treatment has been installed in neighboring buildings on the same side of the street. Option 2 would replace the 2 existing doors in the left and right bays with a replication of the original bi-fold door currently seen in the center bay. Due to current building code requirements the 3 historic bi-fold doors would be fixed as a single 4'-o" x 7'-4" swing door. REAR ELEVATION: There are a variety of existing exterior service, entry and bathroom doors in the rear of the building, three of which are 2'-8" x 6-8". Current code requires that these entry doors be 3'-0" x 6'-8". In the photograph package one can view the existing Rear Alley exterior elevation and the 2 Door Options that we are considering for your review and comment. Option 1 would install all three new entrances with a 3' x 6'-8" steel 'fan lite' door. Option 2 would install all three new entrances with a 3' x 6'-8" steel 'rectangular lite' door. OTHER WORK: There are no other proposed changes to either the front or rear elevations, except to repair and paint the existing features that have deteriorated over time due to lack of maintenance. The original metal exhaust hood on the roof will be sealed water tight and painted with a metallic finish. The deteriorated red vinyl `Restaurant' lettering on the front windows will be removed and the fixed glass replaced by new clear safety glass. 1 Recent Sales in Tieihborhood Previous Parcel Next Pace! Return to Main Search Page Recent Sales innArea - - -- Owner and Parcel Information Owner Name/ Type MA'S FAMILY KITCHEN LLC / Fee Omer Today's Date Mailing Address PO BOX 223459 Parcel Number PRINCEVILLE, HI 96722 Location Address 4277 HALENANI ST Project dame Tax Classification COMMERCIAL Parcel Map Neighborhood Code 3610-3 Land Area (acres) Legal Information LOT 2 FAIRVIEW 6U.5INESS TRACT FP 429 5000 SF Land Area (approximate sq ft) Assessment Information Show or 1 essme t Year Tax Total Market Total Assessed Total Exemption Classification value value 2017 COMMERCIAL $ 325,000 $ 325,000 $ 0 Commercial Improvement Information Kauai Home February 8, 2017 350090160000 Shaer Parcel Map 0.1148 5,000 Total Net Taxable Value $ 325,000 Building Number Building Type Structure Year Built effective Year Built Building Square Footage Sketch 1 132 1953 1990 2,256 Sketch Building I Section Floor # Area Perimeter Usage Wall Height Exterior Wall Construction 1 01. 2,256 220 RESTAURANT 9 WOOD WOOD FRAME Description ASPHALT PARKING Date 11/28/2008 Sale Date Price Instrument # 09/20/2016 $ 275,uou 14-A- 61240165 02/04/200.9 $ 275,000 08-029590 11/22/2005 $ 0 05-241691 09/21/1994 $ 0 440015767E Other Building and Yard Improvements Quantity 1 Permit Information Permit Number Reason 0800001635 REROOF Sales Information Instrument Instrument Date Type Description Recorded FEE CONVEYANCE 0/07/2016 1 FEE CONVEYANCE 0 2/28/2008 FEE CONVEYANCE 1/2912005 1 FEE CONVEYANCE 09/27/1994 Year Built 1980 Permit A mount $ 271,500 Area 1,197 Document Cert Conveyance Document # # Book/Page Tax Type 275 412.5 0 Current Tax Bill Information 2016 Tax Payments show Flis_iorical Taxes Tax Period Description Original Taxes Due Date Tax Net Penalty Interest Other Amount Assessment Credits Tax Doe 2016-2 Real property Tax 02/20/2017 $ 1,303.29 $ 0.00 $ 1,303.29 50.00 $ 0.00 $ 0.00 5 1,303.29 Tax bid computed to 02/20,f2017 $ 1,303-29 $ 0-00 S 1,303.29 S 0.00 $ 0.00 $ fl-oo $ 1,303.29 Remat Sales In WRObborhood Previous Parcel Next Pa Recent Sakes in Area - rim Return tq "Min -1corch Page Kauai e The Kauai County Tax Assessor's Office makes every effort to produce the most accurate information possible. No verranties, expressed or implied, ant provided for the data herein, its use or interpretation. Website Updated- February 7, 2017 D 2UH by the Ivlusi Cenniv Tas <%s.msorls Office i Webshc design by upublic.net RICE STREET I w /ia - w h 33 Ja — MALAYA STREET HALENANI STREET 9 A "OALA w �+ r � a � N VICINITY MAP N.T.S. UMAKOSHI ENTERPRISES LLC REMODEL 4277 HALE NANI STREET, LIHUE, KAUAI TMK (4) 3-6-009:016 February 7, 2017 aorr� '+ sir A doom Zoom P�by Get Zoa�m Ta CenteT Qn su�ws�w Area Print I' SearC F + tY In Ckirt Hand Infra Parcel Parcel h asum � Toal Page � _Sales _ � Additiv Controls �_.1p,; ri ht r;) P, gPubhc r,_r 4! f% Available Layers l.lf'Je 00ke''y� „ff ./ Parcels & G�1fee Sf,op {� Parcel Numbers 4303 f i 1 Address # s +� Yearly Sales Buildings � ./ Streets ( Goggle) Satellite (Goggle) Hybrid (Goggle) ,r` � _ lfiysical (Goggle) 2H 2 2558 ; 2943 f1 4277 - -, FHarnur;,r-1in 4' Kauai �� Ong Radio �,Qjp Lih,ue Christian hurc-7/ M2650'if# a i,ng 22 2 t.'a Show Scale Liai GriSt2930 - Ka� Wedding DJ 2926 293 Kauai Pa _ S ! 25��`F; tam � � -• �`=�:� - � Kauai County maces every effort to produce the most accurate information possible. No varranties, expressed or implied, E All data is subject to change before the next certified taxroll. L. Oalp the Arta ]—d. 2. Xf�p a ba-d nn manum I. {owrrd in the fs;d as chomp on — 3. Lndergmutrd utTxtica, 5rtic tanks, etc. —rr - t field located ea�ept as nmvd. +, 'rte acmP1 iacadat4 e=#steaee, size. dlpih, rnttdi[ian or capQtNr} att an;' drainage. s items, sup -surface umler sS Lest, orsvptwl fsrptic lank sysrem..R+Warliaa, sad "ihty live= to tea nrot is s ' drys{. of thi= r-�P. Tt .:apmsri—gm•etomentsd nrallarur. h• 4m—Im ahordd be gom icd for this m&trmatwa. 5. Lmprmemenis a±4 aultjec( Lot 2 are. nosed betas: i. btial�rrz>a:�er>e.ppr��sas-��a 3. utlrsmt n,ei: s tAt $- R'aod oralt is apprvaimatelp 0_Sq h. Rf3tD£ subject Lnr 2. �• gees ��= � aPPm�tim-=rug dlo iL t1'FS[43E subject fac �. D lnrrt.rC_si Lace of =n —11 is.aopc i—Ts 0.10 R. t:YS1&E subeoc, Lot 2. G Duudiag mra^_r is zPPraamn;el.� D;1D tt. t,Y81DE aubjecv i� �_ SNaIDE subject lo: 2. G_ EaQ co.-arr is 3PP.'nximatel4' uu PrQpnrr}'line_ L4_ F-)itffift tior is.eppnnnmatctc 1.20 ft. MITStf)5 [{abject In 2. a. nrat end o€emu rstl is apiamdaeatc€y.p, IQ fd, IYSlpi suGjecx Lox ?. 3. Sunildi.dfcZ corner is opp[vya_imty 6.1 P a. YYSIDE mhjetr dn[ 2. n. 8udd'nxgcnrnee % cPPsa<baodely 0-10 ft. NSIDE Let 4, L Maiu lints feats Llac is aPPtnxi:naecic G.50 ft. ( Ti51j3E aubje,,I Lot 2. Si. Miam Link renr.Q ime n nppm—fa ly 11-ro ft. OL-Mm whjrrr L.,a ? X. Sauthenst fytc.a!'wncrett essrb-Is apprnxisaatrly 0. LO fi. OUTSIDE sOhject lei Z O.:+QreTtircgt fnre of catu —111s approx.%'U tdv 0.10 fr. LTISIDE #ubjert Lof 2. A_ 9uliding tntrt— is aop,=:.,tely 0.70 ft. OLTSMF zubjot Lot 2. Q. &dldin3 rarrQr is npp_P dMatet%, Lt-10 ftt. LYSLTIr subject Ln! 2 .9 rr .a 11t r� t K-2 SURVEY MAP SHOWLVG�, Lot 2 of Fairview Business Tract, First Addition, File Flan 429 Being a portion of R.P. 4480, L.C. Aw. 7713, Ap. 2, fart 1 to Kamamalu Kalapaki, Lihue, Kauari, Hawaii Tax Map Key_ (4) 3-6-09: 016 Date of Field Survey: June 23 & 24, 20I6 0 20' 40' ands %VORK WAS PWIP-AM BY,ME QRLl"mv%ISRtEii'St3Q'iR3, 0. poc�v.c,►na�s P-, CILSALAWMI >ad Satx.q m & rt. m"7n 7, BATH-3 GARDEN I wn 2's BATH-4 --------{ N�IT--3 _ a,i9, OFFICE R-S' REF - U14IT-4 4'-V OFFICE �C. APPARTt11ENT Lf— � W � -31� 3'-]D _ FiE_F OPEN AREA m OFFICE �j UNIT-2 OFFICE RCF _ 4. 1 U 96 l .-I. UN1TW5 _ I. LLI _..._� -.- F�2 `�� APPARTMENTUT -6 LIATH-1 -- ----- —oo REF BATI-I I � UNfT--1 JT----�iREF OFFICE I]� V J 4--5�' GFFICE- UNBI'-6 ....�_.""-� ..._.` WRATH--S... I�l OFFICE rl1NEW FLOOR FLAN Fd 1 5 10 is NEW FLOOR PLAN uvmcirn�.W EXISTING FRONT STREET ELEVATION UMAKOSHI ENTERPRISE-S LLC RLMODE:L 4277 HALE NANI STREET LIHUE KAUAI TM K L4) 3-6-009; 016 February 7, 2017 Building Permit Number 16-1634 MA'S KITCHEN PROPERTY 4277 HALENANI STREET, LIHUE, HAWAII TMK_ 4`" 3-6-9-016 (5„000 SQUARE FEET) (24 JUne 2016) .y� NEIGHBORS ON HALENANI STREET UMAKOSHI ENTERPRISES LLC REMODEL 4277 HALENANI STREET LIHUE KAUAI TMK (4) 3-6-009;016 February 7, 2917 Building Permit Number 16- 634 K AN-.r _ - - - ww 11 EXISTING REAR EXTERIOR ELEVATION UMAKOSHI ENTERPRISES, LLC REMODEL 4277 HALENANI STREET, L1„HUE, KAUAI TMK 4 3-0-009;01 S February 2017 Building Permit „Number 1 6-1634 + to loom N+ i k1to It L NOW L n r¢ a ��.;, a - s�Wsw .® _ w vINK s` OPTION 1 : FRONT STREET ELEVATION --- zn \ ■ OPTION 2: FRONT STREET ELEVATIO i