HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020_0214_BOR OP Session Meeting MinutesCOUNTY OF KAUAI
Minutes ol' Meeting
OPEN SESSION
,\roved : -1/13/2020
Me eting Datc trebruary 14,21120Boald/Cornnrission BoARD OF REVIEW
Start ol N{ecting: l :05p.nrLocation
P[escn I Chail Craig De Costa, Member Julie Caspillo, Member Katherine Lcwi Otsuji, and Membcr Stella Fujita.
Also: Ofllcc of the County Attorney: Deputy County Attorney Mark Bradbtrry, Boards & Comnrissions Stafi: Support Clerk Arleen
Kuwamura. Real Property Tax Manager: Brad Cone. COK Appraisers: Craig Arzadon, Damien Ventura, Sean Roche, Mike
Hubbard, Kelsie Antone and Terry Phillips.
Vice Chair Christophcr WhiteExcused
Absent Nonc
SUBJECT DISCI.JSSION ACTION
Call to Order Chair De Costa called the rneeting to order at
I :05 p.m. with lbur members present which
constituted a quorum.
Approval ot'
Minutes
Tlrcre wus rut Mittute.; uvuilal e
Appeals
7. 20-0000007 M. Hubbarcl Dave & Kay Sinovic 5-5-(X)2 002-0000
Ms. Kay Sinovic was in attendance and presented their testimony to the Board. Mr. Hubbard was prescnt on behall'of the
County and presented his report to the Board.
The Board rcviewcd the testimony providetl in Exccutivc Sessron
6. 20-0000025 M. Hubbard Quinrus HBR, LLC 5-4-01 l-003,0055
Mr. Ccorge Costa wers in attendancc represcnting Mr. GcolT King and presented a noticc and his testimony to thc Board. Mr.
Hubbard was present on behall'of thc County and presented his report to thc Board.
The Board reviewed the testinrony provided in Executivc Sessron
End ol Meeting: 2: l6 p.m.Mo'ikeha Building, Meeting Rcxrm 2 A/B
I
a. Nonc available
I
Board o1' Rcvicw
Opcn Session
F-ebruary 14, 2020 Page 2
SUBJEC'I DISCI ]SSION ACTION
I. 20-00000l4 C. Alazadon Michael Buenconse Sharolvn Kawakami 3-3-009-043-0000
'l'ltc Chuir De Coslu ,qralcd u conlirttrurttc ol the ultpcul utttil fitrtlrcr ttolift
2. 20-0000048 C. Arazadon Holly lloreta 3-3-01 7- I 67-0000
'llrc Clruir De Costu grutttul u torttitttrum e ol tfu uppt'ul ntil.ffurtlrcr trotit;c
Stipulation/
Withdrawn 9. l9-0000075 M. Hubbard PoiDu Resort Paltners LP (20re) 2 E IILAQLQAQ2
t0. l9-0000076 M. Hubbarcl Poiou Rcsort Paltners LP (201 9)2 rJ-02 I (X)1 0(X)3
I L l9-0000077 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-o2l-001-000.+
12. l9-000007tt M. Huhbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019 )2-8-02 1 -001 -0009
I3. l9-0000079 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Paltncrs LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0010
14. l9-0000080 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (201 9)2-8-02 | -001-00 t4
I6. l9-00()0082 M. Ilubhard PoipLr Rcsort Plltncrs LP (20t, 2-8 02r-001-qQ!6
17. l9-0000083 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0021
18. l9-0000084 M. Hubbard Poipu Rcsort Partners LP (20re) 2-8-02l QQ1QQ22
21. l9-00q0087 M. tlLrbbard Poipr.r Resort Partncrs LP (20t9) 2-8-02l-001-0049
22. l9-0000088 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partncrs LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0050
23. l9-0000089 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0054
I
8. l9-0000074 M. Hubbard PoipLr Rcsort Plltners LP (2019) 2-8-02 l-001-0001
15. l9-0000081 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-02 I -001-001 5
19. l9-0000085 M. Hubbard Poipu Reson Panners LP (2019) 2-8{21-001-004u1
20. l9-0000086 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-02 l-001-0045
Board o1' Review
Open Session
February 14, 2020 Page 3
DISCUSSION ACTION
2..1. l9-0000090 M. llubharcl Poipu Rcsort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0055
25. l9-0000091 M. Huhbard Poipu Rcsort Partners LP (2019\ 2-8-021-001-0056
26. t9-0!Q0092 M. Hubbarl Poipu Rcsolt Partncrs LP (20t9) 2-8-021-001-0057
27. l9-0000093 M. Hubbard Poipu Rcsort Partners LP (2019) 2-n-021-001-0058
28. l9-0000094 M. Hubbalcl Poipu Rcsort Paltners LP (20t9) 2-8-021-0ol-0065
29. l9 0000095 M. Llubbard Poipu Rcsort Paltners [-P (2019) 2-ri 021 001 0066
10. l9-0000096 M. Hirbbtrd PoiDu Resort Paltnels LP (20 r9)2-8-02 I -001 -0073
33. l9-0000099 M. Hubbard Poipu Rcsort Partnels LP (20r9) 2-8-021-001-0089
34. l9-0000100 M. Huhbard Poipu Rcsort Partners LP (20t9) 2-n-02t-001-0095
35. l9-OI)00101 M. Huhbard Poipu Rcsort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-00r-0096
36. l9-0000102 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP r20t91 2-8-021-001-0097
37. l9-0000103 M. Hubbard Poipu Rcsort Partnels LP (2019) 2-tt 0l I 00t 009n
38. l9-0000104 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Paltners LP (2019) 2 n 02r 001 0099
39. l9-0000101 M. Flubbarcl Poipu Rcsort Partners LP (20 r9) 2-ll-02 r-001-0100
40. l9-0000106 M. Hubbard Poipu Rcsort Partners LP (20t9) 2-8-02r-001,010t
41. l9-0000107 M. Hubbord Pqlps Rcsorr Paftncrs LP (2019)t,8 0t1 00r 0109
12 19,000010n M. Hubbard Poipu Rcsort Partners l-P (2019) 2-8-021-001-01l0
31. I9-0000097 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-02 l-001-0077
32. l9{000098 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-02 I -001-0081
SUBJECT
43. l9-0000109 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-01 l2
Board of Review
Open Session
February 14, 2020 Page 4
SUBJECT DISCUSSION ACTION
,+5. 19-00001ll M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (20l9 )2-8,02 I-00t-01I5
47- I9-00001 I3 M. Hubbarcl Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-02L001 0l3r
.11t. l9 0000114 M. llubhard Poipu Resort Partnels LP (2019) 2-8-02 l-001-0133
49. 19-00001 l5 M. llubbard Poipu Resolt Partners LP (2019)
50. 19-00001l6 M. Hubhard Poinu Rcsort Partners LP (201 ()
)2-n-02 I -001-01 39
5 I . l9-0(XX) I l7 M. l lubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (20l9) 2-n-02 r-001-0I.+0
52. l9 0(X)01 I 8 M. I Iuhhard Poipu Resurt l)urtners LP (2019) 2lt-021-0ot-ot,+r
55. l9-0000121 M. Hubbard PoiDu Resorl Partners LP (20t9) 2-13 02 I 001-0151
56. l9-(XXD | 22 M. I Iubbard Poipu Resolt Partnels L[)(2O19) 2-8-021-001-0154
57. l9-0000 | 23 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partnels LP (20r9) 2-8-021-001-0l5rl
58. l9-0000124 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0r59
59. l9-0000125 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0160
60. l9-0000126 M. Hubbarl Poipu Resort Pzulners LP (20r9) 2-tr-02t-001-0165
61. 19-0000127 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (20 l9 )2-n-02 I -001-0166
44. 19-0000110 M. Hubbard Poipu Reson Partners LP (2019) 2-8-02 l-001{)ll4
46. l9-00001l2 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001{l2l
53. l9-00001l9 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0142
54. l9-0000120 M. Hubbard Poiou Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-U-02 l-001-0150
62. l9-0000128 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0167
63. l9-0000129 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-it-021-001-0173
I
Board of Rcview
Open Session
February 1,1, 2020 Page 5
STJtsJECT DISCUSSION A(]TION
64. l9-000OI30 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-02r,001-0174
67. l9-0000133 M. Hubbard Poipu Rcsort Paltners LP (2019) 2-8-02 l-001-0196
68. l9-0000134 M. Hubbard Poiou Resort Partncrs LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0197
69 19-00001 35 M. Hubbard Poipu Re sort Partncrs LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0198
70. l9 0(X)01 16 M. HLrbbard Poi l)u Rcsorl Paltncrs LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0199
71. l9-0000137 M. Hubbard Poi D Ll Rcsorl Parlncrs l-P (2019) 2-8-02t-001-0200
73. l9-00001 39 M. Hubbard Poin u Resort Partncrs LP (20r9) 2-8-021-001-0202
74. l9-0000140 M-Hubbard Poipu Rcsort Paltners LP (20t9) 2-8-021-001-0203
7-5. l9-0000141 M. Hubbard Poinu R esort Pa[tncrs LP (20t9\ 2-8-02r-001-0206
76. l9-0000142 M. Hubbald Poi t)u Rcsort Paltncrs LP (2019) 2-8-02t-00t-0207
77. l9-0000143 M. Hubbard Poi n u Resofl Partncls LP (2019)2-8-02t-00t-0208
7ll. l9-0000144 M. Hubbard Poi ll u Rcsort Partncl s L,P (2019) 2-8-021-001-0209
79. l9-0000145 M. Hubbard Poi r')u Resort Partncls LP c0 | 9) 2-lJ-02 I -00 I -02 l0
80. l9-0000146 M. Hubbard Poi ll u Resort Partners LP (20l9)I tt 0ll 001 02 ll
81. l9-0000147 M. Hubbard Poi t)ru Rcsort Panncrs LP (2019)I n 0ll 001 0lt9
E.thibit A. Ms. F'u.jitu setrsnded lhe ntotion. Motiort currictl 1:0.
| 65. l9-0000131 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-021-001-0181
| 66. 19-0000132 M. Hubbard Poipu Resort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-02 l-001-01 88
72. l9-0000138 M. Hubbard Poipu Rcsort Partners LP (2019) 2-8-02 l-001-0201
Board of Review
Open Session
February 14, 2020 Page (r
STJBJEC'f DISCUSSION ACTION
3. 20-0000002 M. Hubbard Williarrs Pali Propcrtics LLC 5-3-003-0,12-0002
No one was present on behall'ol'thc appellant; however, a written testimony was provided to the board. Mr. Hubbard was
present on bchalf of the County and prcsented his report to the Board.
4. 20-0000034 M. Hubbard Princevillc Dcv Co ID 5-4-006-002-0024
No one was present on behalf of the appellant. Mr. Hubbard was present on behalf of the County and presented his report to
the Board.
'fhc Boald rcvicrvcd tlle tcstirnony pr-nvidcd in Executivc Scr:ion
5. 20-0000033 M. Hubbard Princev illc Dcv Corn 5-4-006-009-001 6
No one was present on behalf of the appellant. Mr. Hubhard was present on bchalf ol the County and p[esented his repolt to
the Board.
The Board reviewcd the tcstimony provided in Executive Scssron
Discussion of
2020 Iloard of
Review
Conference -
tentatively set
lbr May 29,
2020, Honolulu
International
Airport
Conf'erence
Rooms
Chair De Costa announced that the 2020 Board of Review Conference will be heltt on May 29tl'. He noted infbrmation is
tentative and that the timing of the schedulc n.right not be exact but similar. Opened the lloor for discussion. Hcaring none.
Discussion on
Board of
Chair De Costa noted he did not get to type up the comments of the last meeting. He opened the floor for comments and
suggestions. Hearing none.
Thc Board rcvicwed the tcstimony providcd in Exccutive Session.
Board of Review
Open Scssion
February 1,1, 2020 Page 7
SI]B.IF,CT I) IS('t ISStON ACTION
Review Annual
Report to the
Mayor for 2019
Pursuuttt /a H/lS 5\ 92-1, 92-5(u) (1), 92-9(u) ( l-
4) (h) and 92-6(a) (2). Ms. Ot:;uji nnvetl thut tlte
Bourd go into E.tctrrtivt Ses.siort ut I :55p.m. .for
thc purpose oJ retietting u upproring lhc
Erectttive Scssiort ninute.s. Ms. Caspilkt
sct'ottded tht nuttitnt. Mtstiort turried 5:0.
Return to ()pen
Session
Ratilv Board o1'Revrew actions taken in Executivc Scssion l'qt 4Dpeals shown
on thc attachcd listing and makc thosc dccisions public
The meeting resumed in Open Session at 2: l6
p.m.
Mt. Ot.:tr.ji rttot'etl kt ntilr the Bourd'.s utliotts itr
E.teculiva Se.s.siott u to nuka llnst dccisitnts
yrblic. M.s. Fu.jitu sccontlcd tlrc notittn.'fhc
Hcurittg no objattiorts, Motiort curried 1:0.
Appeals
I
I
I
3. 20{000002 M. Hubbard Williams Pali Properties LLC 5-3-003-042-0002
4. 20-0000034 M. Hubbard Princeville Dev Corp 5-4-006-002-0024
I
Executive
Session
5. 20-0000033 M. Hubbard Princeville Dev Corp 5-,1-006-009-0016
Page 8
Ms. Otsuji tnove to susluin the Countl-'s usscssed value ol $8112,200 urd in dddilion lo, tt(,tote thc corredcd CPR ntunbtr lo
bt CPR 55 and rutt 35. Ms. Fujita setrntled the motion. Motion curried 4:0.
7. 20-0000007 M. Hubbard Dave & Kav Sinovic 5-5-002-002-0000
Ms. Otsuji moved to sustuirt the Count\"s Tax ClussiJitution of Residential lnvestor. Ms. Cuspillo seconded the motiott
Motiort carried 1:0.
Announcements Next Meeting Fridav, March 6. 2020
Ad.iournment Chair Dc Costa adjourned the rneeting at 2: I 6
p. r11
Submitted by
Arleen Kuwamura, StafT Support Clerk
( ) Approved as circulated.
(X) Approved with amendments. See minutes of 316/2020 meering.
Reviewcd and Approved hy:
Craig De Costa, Chair
Board of Review
Open Session
February 14,2020
6. 20-0000025 M. Hubbard Ouintus HBR. LLC 5-4-01l-003-0055
I