HomeMy WebLinkAbout2010 0720 Minutes Open_APPROVED Meeting Minutes — Approved as circulated 9/21/10
Mayor's Advisory Committee For Equal Access (MACFEA)
Tuesday, July 20, 2010
Mo'ikeha Meeting Room 2A & 213
4444 Rice Street, Uhu'e, HI 96766
Those present at the meeting were: Rita Manriquez — State Traumatic Brain Injury
Advisory Board (STBIAB); Dr. Lucy Miller — DCAB (Disability and Communication
Access Board) member; Dawn Cummings — Family Advocate; Sharry Glass —
Advocate, Teacher/Trainer; Kathy English — Hawai'i Disability Rights Center; Betty Bell
— Kaua'i Federation for the Blind; Linda Nuland-Ames — ADA Consultant; Rev. Richard
Chun, Senior Representative. Staff members also present: Christiana Pilkington —ADA
Coordinator; Barbara Davis — Staff Secretary; Marc Guyot, Deputy County Attorney.
Captioner: Daryl Morrell, Caption First. Guests: Roberta Eiben
Members absent or excused: Julia Hall — American Red Cross; El Doi — Kaua'i
Developmental Disabilities Council (DDC); Rhoda Rojas — Hawai'i Center for
Independent Living-Kaua'i (HCIL); Elena Costales — Consumer, KCIL Volunteer.
Ms. Pilkington announced that Chair El Doi was out of town for a family emergency and
Vice Chair Elena Costales was ill so a Chair Pro Tern would need to be elected to run
today's meeting.
ACTION: Ms. Glass nominated Dr. Lucy Miller. With no other nominations, Attorney
Guyot noted there were sufficient members to make a quorum and called for the vote.
Motion carried 7:0
Call to Order
The meeting was called to order by Acting Chair Dr. Lucy at 12:02 pm in the Mo'ikeha
Building Meeting Room 2A & 2B at 4444 Rice Street in LThu'e with a quorum of 7
members present and 1 member joining thereafter.
Approval of Agenda
Ms. Bell moved to approve the agenda as circulated. Ms. Glass seconded the motion.
Motion carried 7:0
Approval of June 16, 2010 Minutes
Ms. Glass moved to approve the minutes as circulated. Ms. Manriquez seconded the
motion. Motion carried 7:0
MACFEA Page 1
Business
o Email dated July 7 from Cindy Omura regarding Department of Transportation's
scheduled hearings for the State Pedestrian Master Plan
Ms. Pilkington announced that this was a State-wide plan and KauaTs meeting was
scheduled from 5:30 to 7:30 pm at the Kaua'i War Memorial Convention Hall on
Tuesday, July 27th. The State is looking for public input on alternative ways of
transportation. Ms. Glass said she would be attending as this is the appropriate venue
to bring up low speed vehicles such as wheelchairs, scooters, mopeds, golf carts and
small electric vehicles.
ACTION: Ms. Glass moved to accept the communication for the record. Ms. English
seconded the motion. Motion carried 7:0
o Update for taping the Together We Can Mayor's show and the final format for the
July 26, 2010 ADA Proclamation presentation
Ms. Pilkington advised the Committee that the Mayor will be reading the ADA
Proclamation in the rotunda of the Round Building at 1 :00 pm on July 26 th. Prior to that
time, Dr. Lucy, Sharry Glass, Rhoda Rojas and she will sit with the Mayor in his office
for the filming of the Together We Can show. They will tie this to the proclamation and
some of the things MACFEA has worked towards for the county to be in compliance
with the ADA these past 20 years. There are also plans to have the Mayor ask
questions to people in the audience at the Proclamation as to how ADA has affected
them personally or their family. Additionally, there will be refreshments following the
Proclamation and Ms. Pilkington asked the committee members to extend an invitation
to their family and friends to attend. Ms. Glass said her contribution to the program
would be a kind of historical perspective remembering back to the 1980's when a
person had to be carried up the stairs in the Historical County Building to attend a
County Council meeting; this was before they finally installed the elevator. In addition
the Kaua'i War Memorial Convention Hall was not accessible to veterans as they
couldn't go on the stage or backstage if they used a wheelchair, crutches or walker
unless they were carried up the very narrow stairs. Also none of the bathrooms inside
the Convention Hall were accessible and now all of that has changed because of ADA.
Ms. Glass said people did not realize how far-reaching the benefits of the changes
would be such as where there are ramps instead of stairs it benefits moms and dads
pushing strollers, people who are temporarily injured and people with heart or
respiratory problems. Captioning for the deaf and hearing impaired people also reaches
those using English as a second language and makes it easier to understand people
with accents. Ms. Bell said the County is doing a good job and should be
acknowledged for the Paratransit system but suggested they could discuss an extended
schedule for those who use Paratransit recognizing even though it is expensive to
operate. Dr. Lucy said many of these changes that affect so many did not come
voluntarily, they had to be legislated such as special parking for the handicapped; we
MACFEA Page 2
can see why this legislation was so appropriate and now it is already being taken for
granted. Ms. Pilkington said that prior to the ADA they had the Rehabilitation Act but it
was the ADA that gave the Rehab Act of 1973 its bite. It was through ADA that we got
the UFAC (Unified Federal Access Code) which is the design code originally specifying
doorways should be 30 inches wide and you have to have a 60 inch area for someone
in a wheelchair to turn.
o Decision-making on changing meeting schedule to a bi-monthly basis
ACTION: Ms. Bell moved to change the meeting schedule to every other month rather
than monthly. Ms. Glass seconded the motion.
Meetings will be conducted in September, November, January, March and May which
should be the months Ms. English is able to come from O'ahu to attend; special
meetings will be called as necessary.
Motion carried 8:0
Reports
DCAB's report for July, 2010
Dr. Lucy reported that the Chief of the disability rights section of the Department of
Justice will be on O'ahu for a special conference September 8 and 9 at the Ala Moana
Hotel and sponsored in part by DCAB. The new ADA Title II and Title III rules include
the adoption of the revised and updated ABA/ADA accessibility guidelines which should
be approved by the Office of Management and Budget on the Federal level before these
meetings. Dr. Lucy said she was particularly interested in the meeting on the 9th where
they will discuss the update and refinements to the service animal guidelines. Dr. Lucy
made available a document on Assistance Dog Model State Law pointing out this may
not necessarily reflect the final bill but it does clarify many things. Dr. Lucy noted that
because of budget concerns, DCAB also meets bimonthly even though some
committees may meet more often. When asked about guidelines for parks and outdoor
developed areas, Ms. Pilkington said we defer to the Outdoor Developed Area Access
Guidelines which have not been adopted by Justice yet but Kaua'i County has asked
DCAB to review some parts of our bike paths and the more developed parks that have
problems which were not addressed in the ADA access guidelines. Ms. Pilkington said
that the Access Board also published recreation guidelines which address harbors,
playgrounds and other areas that you can't find under the ADA access guidelines. The
DOT (Department of Transportation) has adopted the ADA/ABA Guidelines for their
building standard and there are other Federal agencies that are going through this
process but they have not been adopted yet by the Department of Justice.
Members' reports
Betty Bell: The National Federation of the Blind meets monthly in the State Building and
members desperately need a bench or some type of accommodation at the back of the
MACFEA Page 3
building where they wait for the busses. Ms. Bell said if a bench were donated she did
not know the proper format to get it installed. Ms. Pilkington suggested the National
Federation of the Blind contact Ms. Janine Rapozo at The Kaua'i Bus to explain the
need for the bench there and let her be the liaison with the State as they may already
have something in the works for that area. Ms. Glass suggested that in addition to
contacting Ms. Rapozo, they also contact the Lion's Club whose main focus is for the
visually-impaired and blind and who might be willing to provide the bench.
Kathy English: Our new fiscal year starts in October so we are gathering input for our
priorities for next year and you can find the survey at www.hawaiidisabilitiesrights.org or
we have paper surveys which you can fill out and mail back on what you think we
should be focusing on for the next year. We are working on Act 163, signed into law
that says you cannot be in a public high school after age 20 which we believe is
discriminatory for the special education programs. When the State applied for funds to
implement the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, they said they were going to
provide services through age 21 which means to the 22nd birthday and that is not what
this law is doing so we will challenge it in court.
Rita Manriquez: The Traumatic Brain Injury Advisory Board met on July gth. Ms.
Manriquez spoke with Dr. David Frey, who is in charge of the Honolulu division of DDD,
about her being the only medical person at the initial shelter set up during the tsunami
alert and he advised her to contact the head of the Department of Health on Kaua'i so at
the time of future disasters there will be a lot more nurses and medical people involved.
Attorney Guyot suggested that MACFEA create a Permitted Interaction Group that
would meet immediately following the main meeting to work on the preparation for the
Mayor's Together We Can show.
ACTION: Ms. Glass moved to create a Permitted Interaction Group for the purpose of
creating a script for the Mayor's program. Rev. Chun seconded the motion. Motion
carried 8:0
Next MACFEA meeting: Tuesday, September 21 , 2010
Adjournment: Ms. Nuland-Ames moved to adjourn the meeting at 12:58 pm. Ms. Bell
seconded the motion. Motion carried 8:0
Respectfully submitted by:
Barbara Davis, Staff Support
( ) Approved as is
( ) Approved with amendments.
MACFEA Page 4